TITLE

Above Politics: Credible Commitment and Efficiency in the Design of Public Agencies

AUTHOR(S)

Miller, Gary

PUB. DATE

April 2000

SOURCE

Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;Apr2000, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p289

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

The state has, since its origins, been characterized both by the production of public goods and a competition for the surplus benefits generated by the creation of those goods. Holmstron's (1982) analysis of an impossibility result leads to the conclusion that this problem is logically inescapable. There is no process for exactly allocating the benefits of an interdependent social process that eliminates moral hazard. Furthermore, morally hazardous behavior can undermine the efficiency of the processes that generate the benefits. In both firms and states, therefore, the credible constraint of morally hazardous behavior is a fundamental concern. In both forms of social organization, delegation to bureaucracy can enhance efficiency by creating barriers between those actors with moral hazard and the producers of the benefits. The characteristics of Weberian bureaucracy, including rational/legal constraints and autonomous professional norms, serve to insulate bureaucrats from efficiency-undermining political pressures. This perspective provides support for concerns oft he century-old Progressive reform tradition, which wanted to place bureaucrats "above politics "--and stands in contrast to the more recent principal/agency perspective, which argues that the fundamental problem is the creation of incentive systems that make bureaucratic subordinates increasingly responsive to the preferences of political superiors.

ACCESSION #

3330254

 

Related Articles

• GIVING THEIR ALL. Benn, Melissa // Community Care;3/17/2005, Issue 1564, p20 

  Comments on the action that should be taken by people involved in voluntary work to end the ignorance of cracks in the social structure by the British government. Commitment of British citizens to voluntary work; Loss of the meaning of political vocabulary at present; Need for the government to...

• On the Administrative Sector of Social Systems: An Analysis of the Size and Complexity of Government Bureaucracies in the American States. Noeli, James J. // Social Forces;Jun74, Vol. 52 Issue 4, p549 

  This study is concerned with the analysis of the size and complexity of the governmental bureaucracies of the 50 American states, and more generally with the "administrative sector" of all social systems. Four hypotheses are formulated and tested. All of the hypotheses are supported. and this is...

• Modeling the Impact of Public Management: Implications of Structural Context. O'Toole Jr., Laurence J.; Meier, Kenneth J. // Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;Oct99, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p505 

  Management theory suggests that management matters in public organizations--its impact is conditional on structure and often nonlinear in form. This article distills much of the theoretical work on management in public organizations into a formal, testable model. Management is presented as more...

• Managing Uncertainty through Bureaucratic Design: Administrative Procedures and State Air Pollution Control Agencies. Potoski, Matthew // Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;Oct99, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p623 

  While several positive theories offer competing explanations of how politicians use administrative procedures to influence bureaucratic performance, few have been submitted to empirical scrutiny. This article examines how state politicians use administrative procedures to design air pollution...

• THE ARCHITECTURE OF RISK AND POWER A Review Article of Magnus Hornqvist, The Organised Nature of Power: On Productive and Repressive Interventions Based on Consideration of Risk, Stockholm University, 2007, ISSN 1404-1 820, ISBN 978-91-7155-442-0. Ericson, Richard V. // British Journal of Criminology;Nov2007, Vol. 47 Issue 6, p955 

  In The Organised Nature of Power, Magnus Hornqvist initially synthesizes Foucauldian and Marxian conceptions of power in order to highlight the connection between everyday exercises of power and power relations embedded in social structure and the state. He then proceeds to demonstrate how risk...

• Getting to the Helm: Women in Leadership in Federal Regulation. Smith, Amy // Public Organization Review;Dec2014, Vol. 14 Issue 4, p477 

  Why is it important for women to hold leadership positions in organizations? If it is important for women to hold leadership positions in organizations, how do women get into such positions? Both public administration research and organizational research provide answers to these questions....

• Response to Professor Lowery. Lynn Jr., Laurence E.; Heinrich, Carolyn J.; Hill, Carolyn J. // Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;Apr2002, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p298 

  Comments on the articles on governance written by Professor David Lowery published in the April 2002 issue of 'Research and Theory.' Factors that may account for the variations in organizational performance; Importance of research on governance; Measurement and inclusion of variables in...

• The Development and Decline of Patrimonial and Bureaucratic Administrations. Delany, William // Administrative Science Quarterly;Mar1963, Vol. 7 Issue 4, p458 

  Max Weber's broad-gauge theory of the development of administration, although largely neglected by social scientists, is still useful. By confronting Weber's theory with recent empirical work, this article attempts to evaluate its present scientific status. Weber's failure to forecast correctly...

• RESEARCH NEEDS IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION: A SYMPOSIUM. Goodsell, Charles T. // Public Administration Quarterly;Fall84, Vol. 8 Issue 3, p263 

  No abstract available.

Read the Article