Assessing the Consequences of a Channel Switch

Xinlei (Jack) Chen; John, George; Narasimhan, Om
May 2008
Marketing Science;May/Jun2008, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p398
Academic Journal
Switching marketing channels is an expensive and sticky decision. While a number of theories suggest efficiency and strategic differences between channels, there is virtually no work on combining these ideas into an empirically workable methodology to assess the impact of a channel switch. In this study, we undertake to close this gap with an empirical study of the sports drink market, featuring competing producers and heterogeneous channels. We estimate demand and cost parameters for a number of alternative models of competitive interaction and use these estimates to study the switching of Gatorade from its extant (independent wholesaler) channel to the direct store delivery (DSD) channel belonging to Pepsi. Our initial results indicate the following: Pepsi should switch Gatorade to the DSD channel only if (i) the switch decreases Gatorade's manufacturing cost by at least 14%, or (ii) the switch increases the share of profit it can obtain by at least 13%, or (iii) the switch enhances demand by the equivalent of a price cut of 4.96� for a 32-ounces package. Absent these increases, Pepsi should not switch. Our methodology and results speak to both managers contemplating a channel switch and antitrust authorities faced with the task of evaluating the consequences of a change in vertical structure.


Related Articles

  • Sports Drinks Score. Covino, Renee M. // Convenience Store News;Mar2012, Vol. 48 Issue 4, p45 

    The article presents comments regarding the PepsiCo's switch from warehouse delivery to direct-store delivery (DSD) of Gatorade products in the convenience channel through company owned and independent bottlers. Butch Fulton, beverage category manager for Plaid Pantries said that he expected a...

  • Sports drink packaged for pre-teens.  // Food Engineering;Nov2002, Vol. 74 Issue 11, p18 

    Reports on the launch of medium sized bottles, by beverage company Pepsico Inc.'s Gatorade Co., that cater to the pre-teenage group. Design and manufacture of the bottles by Amcor PET Packaging; Features of the bottles; Development of new flavors along with the launch of the bottles.

  • Gatorade thirsts for expansion. Schoettle, Anthony // Indianapolis Business Journal;8/20/2001, Vol. 22 Issue 23, p1A 

    Reports the expansion of Gatorade division by PepsiCo Inc. in Indiana, Indianapolis. Use of the facilities to expand Tropicana and other juice products; Market share of Gatorade; Growth potential of Gatorade brand.

  • PepsiCo Plans to Invest $5.5 Billion in India.  // India -- West;11/15/2013, Vol. 38 Issue 52, pA33 

    The article reflects on plan of Pepsico Inc. to invest 5.5 billion dollar in India for double production and growth in markets and also informs that the maker of several brands Mountain Dew, Gatorade Co. and Frito-Lay chips plans to spend the money on new products, and manufacturing capabilities.

  • Pepsi pushes local Gatorade growth. Schoettle, Anthony // Indianapolis Business Journal;6/16/2003, Vol. 24 Issue 14, p3 

    Reports on the benefits which sports drink company Gatorade can derive from letting beverage firm PepsiCo acquire one of its production facilities. Increase in employment opportunities and production capabilities; Distribution, packaging and marketing of bottled drink products; Market expansion.

  • Gatorade quenching thirst for expansion. Schoettle, Anthony // Indianapolis Business Journal;9/13/2004, Vol. 25 Issue 27, p5A 

    Reports on the expansion of Gatorade's plant in Indianapolis, Indiana. Dominance of Gatorade in the sports-drink market; Acquisition of Gatorade by PepsiCo; Plan of PepsiCo to centralize the warehousing and distribution of Gatorade.

  • DSD Suppliers Using ASNs to Boost Store Receiving. Garry, Michael // SN: Supermarket News;7/23/2007, Vol. 55 Issue 30, p18 

    The article reports that the majority of large direct-store-delivery (DSD) vendors in the U.S. are using advance shipment notifications (ASNs) as part of an electronic back-door receiving process according to PepsiCo. It notes that six more retailers are looking at adopting the ASN process with...

  • They want to be like Don. Kelley, Kristine Portno // Beverage Industry;Jun94, Vol. 85 Issue 6, p75 

    Presents a corporate profile on beverage maker Gatorade. Ownership; Company operations; Marketing and management schemes; Advertising promotions; Sales; Competition from Coca-Cola Co. and PepsiCo Inc.

  • The sultan of swamp. Prince, Greg W.; Sfiligoj, Eric // Beverage World;Oct94, Vol. 113 Issue 1576, p88 

    Focuses on the sports drinks beverage industry in the United States. Competition between Gatorade, Pepsi-Cola Co. and Coca-Cola Co.; Sales and gallonage; Segments; Share by distribution channel.


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics