Sector Perceptions among State-Level Public Managers

Feeney, Mary K.
July 2008
Journal of Public Administration Research & Theory;Jul2008, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p465
Academic Journal
In this article, I investigate whether or not there is variance in public managers' perceptions of worker quality and work life, by sector. Specifically, I investigate whether state-level public managers perceive the public sector or the private sector as having more challenging work and more talented workers, and how those perceptions are conditioned by previous work experience, motivations for taking their current jobs, education, race, and other demographic characteristics. Using multinomial logistical regression of data from the National Administration Studies Project-III survey of managers in Georgia and Illinois, I find that public managers motivated by desires for advancement and public service motivation are more likely to report positive perceptions of the public sector. Managers whose last job was in the private sector, compared to those whose last job was in the public sector, are less likely to respond favorably about the private sector. Increased perceptions of red tape increase the odds of having positive private sector perceptions and having a business degree, compared to another degree, decrease favorable public sector perceptions. These findings are important to understanding the relationships between manager characteristics and sectors perceptions among state-level public managers.


Related Articles

  • The Land of Milk and Honey Once More. Scheer, Robert // Progressive Populist;12/15/2012, Vol. 18 Issue 22, p14 

    The article discusses how the changing demographics of California are producing an American electoral majority that is more culturally sophisticated, socially tolerant and supportive of a healthy public sector.

  • Benchmarking as a policy-making tool: from the private to the public sector. Papaioannou, Theodoros; Rush, Howard; Bessant, John // Science & Public Policy (SPP);Mar2006, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p91 

    Benchmarking has a long history in the management world. It first emerged in the private sector as an engineering tool and having passed through different stages of development, is now also a policy-making tool in the public sector. The paper argues that although typologies of benchmarks can be...

  • Managing Reforms: The Politics of Organizing Reform Work. Bowornwathana, Bidhya; Poocharoen, Ora-orn // Public Organization Review;Sep2005, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p233 

    Literature in the field of New Public Administration has focused mainly on individual countries especially the successes and failures of public sector reform efforts. This article introduces a more comparative perspective by looking at the different ways governments are managing public sector...

  • Policy Analysis and Croatian Public Administration: The Problem of Formulating Public Policy. PETAK, ZDRAVKO; PETEK, ANA // Politicka Misao: Croatian Political Science Review;2009, Vol. 46 Issue 5, p54 

    The paper considers the role of policy analysis tools in preparing decisions within the Croatian public administration system, concentrating on the specific phase of adoption or formulation of public policy. The starting argument in the paper is that the application of policy analysis is fairly...

  • Total Quality Management Systems in the Hellenic Public Administration: A Case Study on the Common Assessment Framework Application. Irene, Tsimboukidou; Panagiota, Dionysopoulou; John, Mylonakis // Public Administration Research;2013, Vol. 2 Issue 2, p124 

    The application of the Quality Management System in the Public Sector requires established objectives and continuous improvement aimed at citizens' satisfaction. Therefore, more empirical evidence is needed to meet citizens' requirements. The main quality tools used are: Management by...

  • Can Public Policy Survive Without Government? Milward, Brint // Government Executive;9/24/2015, p1 

    The article presents the author's views on the instruments of public policy used by various governments. He opines on the involvement of the private and nonprofit sectors in helping governments to deliver better public services. He comments on the government's role when the instruments of...

  • Policy Evaluation in the Government of Japan. Yoshimuta, Tsuyoshi // Public Manager;Winter2003/2004, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p43 

    This article compares the Japanese Government Policy Evaluation Act (GPEA) of 2002 with that of the U.S. Government Performance and Results Act (GPRA) of 1993. It elaborates on the major provisions of GPEA and describes ways in which GPEA is different from GPRA. Policy evaluation gradually is...

  • PUBLIC POLICY ANALYSIS. Walker, Warren E.; Fisher, Gene H. // Encyclopedia of Operations Research & Management Science;2001, p651 

    The article presents information on public policy analysis. It refers to a systematic approach to making policy choices in the public sector. It aims to assist policymakers in choosing a preferred course of action from among complex alternatives under certain conditions. It is not mean to...

  • ISSUES IN INTRODUCING TRAINING NEEDS ANALYSIS IN SLOVENIA'S PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION. RODIC, Bla�; VUKOVIC, Goran; ZAVR�NIK, Bruno; MIGLIC, Gozdana // Transylvanian Review of Administrative Sciences;2012, Issue 37E, p155 

    A modern public administration requires professional, skilled, and well-trained civil servants. Training is an important development component of a modern civil service and its employees. As a basic method of human resources development, training should be adjusted to the administrative...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics