TITLE

Know When to Rock the Boat: How Faculty Rationalize Students� Behaviors

AUTHOR(S)

Ginsburg, Shiphra; Lingard, Lorelei; Regehr, Glenn; Underwood, Kathryn

PUB. DATE

July 2008

SOURCE

JGIM: Journal of General Internal Medicine;Jul2008, Vol. 23 Issue 7, p942

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

When faculty evaluate medical students� professionalism, they make judgments based on the observation of behaviors. However, we lack an understanding of why they feel certain behaviors are appropriate (or not). To explore faculty�s reasoning around potential student behaviors in professionally challenging situations. Guided interviews with faculty who were asked to respond to 5 videotaped scenarios depicting students in professionally challenging situations. Purposive sample of 30 attending Internists and surgeons. Transcripts were analyzed using modified grounded theory to search for emerging themes and to attempt to validate a previous framework based on student responses. Faculty�s reasoning around behaviors were similar to students� and were categorized by three general themes: Imperatives (e.g., take care of patients, behave honestly, know your place), Affect (factors relating to a student�s �gut instincts� or personality), or Implications (for the student, patients, and others). Several new themes emerged, including �know when to fudge the truth�, �do what you�re told�, and �know when to step up to the plate�. These new codes, along with a near ubiquitous reference to Affect, suggests that faculty feel students are responsible for knowing when (and how) to bend the rules. Potential reasons for this are discussed. Although faculty are aware of the conflicts students face when encountering professional challenges, their reliance on students to �just know� what to do reflects the underlying complexity and ambiguity that surrounds decision making in these situations. To fully understand professional decision-making, we must acknowledge and address these issues from both students� and faculty�s points of view.

ACCESSION #

33005595

Tags: COLLEGE teachers;  MEDICINE -- Specialties & specialists;  MEDICAL students;  PSYCHOLOGY, Comparative;  VALUES

 

Related Articles

• More med students choosing primary care.  // H&HN: Hospitals & Health Networks;8/5/95, Vol. 69 Issue 15, p12 

  Reports that majority of senior medical students in the United States have decided to train to be primary care physicians according to the National Resident Matching Program. Figures; Selected specialties.

• Choosing a specialty. Richards, Peter // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);9/24/1983, Vol. 287 Issue 6396, p898 

  Focuses on the factors to consider in choosing a field of specialization in Great Britain. Importance of part time training; Availability of career opportunities; Need for expansion in numbers of consultants on several areas.

• What specialty after registration? Rhodes, Philip // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);11/6/1982, Vol. 285 Issue 6351, p1340 

  Focuses on the choice of specialty of registered doctors. Preferred specialty of medical students; Skepticism on practice of surgery, obstetrics and gynecology of pediatrics; Inability of some medical students in making a choice.

• More and more med students let lifestyle dictate choice of specialties.  // Contemporary OB/GYN;Nov2003, Vol. 48 Issue 11, p35 

  The article reports on the increasing number of medical students in the U.S. that allow lifestyle dictate choice of specialties, according to the findings of a study published in the "Journal of the American Medical Association on September 3, 2003. The trend could change the distribution of...

• Family practice match numbers drop again.  // Family Practice Management;May2001, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p22 

  Reports the decline in the number of position filled in family practice residency programs in the United States. Data from the National Resident Matching Program; Decrease in number of medical students choosing family practice; Increase in primary care specialties; Graphical representation of...

• Medical Student Attitudes about Internal Medicine: A Study of U.S. Medical School Seniors in 1988. Babbott, David.; Levey, Gerald S.; Weaver, Sheila O.; Killian, Charles D. // Annals of Internal Medicine;1/1/91, Vol. 114 Issue 1, p16 

  Studies the attitudes of medical students toward careers in internal medicine in the U.S. Factors which affect the choice of specialty by medical students; Reasons for decision of students to switch away from general internal medicine; Significance of students' attitudes to internal medicine...

• Medical students' beliefs about nine different specialties. Furnham, A.F. // British Medical Journal (Clinical Research Edition);12/20/1986, Vol. 293 Issue 6562, p1607 

  Presents students views on nine medical specialties in London. Accumulation of multidimensional attitudes on psychiatry; Differences of views of the clinical and preclinical students; Influences of experiences on attitudes and principles.

• Dr. B. C. Bapna: A tough task master and a crusader. Sharma, S. K. // Indian Journal of Urology;Jan2010, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p2 

  The article profiles Doctor B. C. Bapna, one of the founding fathers of urology in India. He was born in Indore on July 1, 1927, and eventually moved to the U.S. in 1955 in pursuit of higher specialized education. In 1961, Bapna returned to his motherland in the hope of introducing urology,...

• Factors influencing selection of surgical specialty. Bland, Kirby I. // Journal of Postgraduate Medicine;Jul-Sep2003, Vol. 49 Issue 3, p201 

  Comments on the factors influencing selection of surgical specialty. Evaluation of appropriate influences that assist medical graduates of Pakistani Schools of Medicine in the selection of surgical vs. non-surgical specialties; Influence of combination of skills and cognitive knowledge base to...

Read the Article