Nonoperative Compared with Operative Treatment of Acute Scaphoid Fractures

Vinnars, Bertil; Pietreanu, Mihai; Bodestedt, Åke; Af Ekenstam, Fredrik; Gerdin, Bengt
June 2008
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jun2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 6, p1176
Academic Journal
Background: Traditionally, acute nondisplaced scaphoid fractures have been treated nonoperatively in a cast, and the expected union rate approaches 90%. Internal fixation of nondisplaced scaphoid fractures has increased in popularity, and a union rate of 100% has been reported. The growing trend is to recommend internal fixation for the majority of acute scaphoid fractures. The true long-term benefits of this more complicated treatment modality have not yet been determined in randomized controlled trials. The purpose of this study was to compare the long-term results of operative fixation of acute scaphoid fractures with those of nonoperative treatment. Methods: During the period between 1992 and 1997, eighty-three patients with an acute nondisplaced or minimally displaced scaphoid fracture were randomly allocated to, and received, either nonoperative treatment with a cast or internal fixation with a Herbert screw. At a median of ten years after the injury, seventy-five (93%) of the eighty-one patients who were still alive were assessed clinically and radiographically. Results: All fractures united. A significant increase in the prevalence of osteoarthritis in the scaphotrapezial joint was found in the operatively treated group. No differences in subjective symptoms, as measured with limb-specific outcome scores, were found between the two groups. The range of motion and grip strength were greater, but not significantly greater, in the nonoperatively treated group. Conclusions: This study did not demonstrate a true long-term benefit of internal fixation, compared with nonoperative treatment, for acute nondisplaced or minimally displaced scaphoid fractures. The long-term risks of surgery should be considered when recommending operative treatment. Level of Evidence: Therapeutic Level I. See Instructions to Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.


Related Articles

  • On the Cusp of Complexity. KEATS, JONATHON // Discover;Jan/Feb2016, Vol. 37 Issue 1, p42 

    The article talks about the discovery of a microorganism by molecular biologists at Uppsala University in Sweden

  • Non-union scaphoid: Four-corner fusion of the wrist. Gupta, Ravi K.; Chauhan, Dalvir S.; Singh, Harmeet // Indian Journal of Orthopaedics;Apr-Jun2010, Vol. 44 Issue 2, p208 

    Background: Four-corner fusion of the wrist is an option for management of non-union scaphoid with painful arthritis of the wrist. Various surgical techniques have been devised for four-corner fusion, with inconsistent results. We present our experience of four-corner fusion achieved using a...

  • Comparison of Fixation Methods for Scaphoid Nonunions. Panchal, Anand; Kubiak, Erik N.; Keshner, Mitchell; Fulkerson, Eric; Paksima, Nader // Bulletin of the NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases;2007, Vol. 65 Issue 4, p271 

    The purpose of this study was to analyze the relative biomechanical stability of three types of internal fixation with cancellous bone graft in a cadaveric, scaphoid nonunion model. A scaphoid nonunion model was created by removing a volar wedge of bone from the waist of the scaphoid in 18 fresh...

  • Transtrapezial Approach for Fixation of Acute Scaphoid Fractures: Rationale, Surgical Techniques, and Results. Verstreken, Frederik; Meermans, Geert // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;5/20/2015, Vol. 97 Issue 10, p850 

    The ideal position for a screw used for scaphoid fixation is central. The purpose of this study was to compare the current volar percutaneous approaches used for scaphoid fracture fixation, explore different options to improve central screw placement, and describe our experience with the...

  • NO MORE MILK?  // Women's Fitness;Jan2016, Issue 148, p101 

    The article reports on a Swedish study by Uppsala University which suggests that drinking lots of milk could be harmful.

  • Fractura de escafoides carpiano en el niño. A propósito de un caso y revisión de la bibliografía. Torres, J.; Abat, F.; Monteiro, E.; Gelber, P. // Acta Ortopedica Mexicana;sep/oct2013, Vol. 27 Issue 5, p335 

    Objective: To conduct a bibliographic review of the infrequent fractures of the carpal scaphoid in pediatric cases based on a clinical case. The diagnosis is usually a difficult one and treatment should be stringent in order to minimize the chance of delayed healing or pseudoarthrosis. Material...

  • Reduction and Maintenance of Scapholunate Dissociation Using the TwinFix Screw. Opreanu, Razvan C.; Baulch, Michelle; Katranji, Abdalmajid // ePlasty: Open Access Journal of Plastic Surgery;2009, Vol. 9, p52 

    Objective: Closed reduction and internal fixation of the scapholunate dissociation are currently performed using K-wires or a headless bone screw. We present an alternative for this fixation by means of a cannulated screw with dynamic adjustable interfragmentary compression and discuss the...

  • A Three-Barbed Protein Hook. May, Mike // Bioscience Technology;Feb2007, Vol. 32 Issue 2, p40 

    The article provides information on 3PLA, a proximity-ligation strategy protein-finding assay developed by Edith Schallmeiner, a doctoral student in Ulf Landegren's laboratory at Uppsala University in Sweden. The advantages of the 3PLA assay are cited including its high sensitivity and extended...

  • UMA ANÁLISE SOBRE O CONCEITO DE APRENDIZAGEM NA PERSPECTIVA DE INTERNACIONALIZAÇÃO. Calixto, Cyntia Vilasboas; de Souza, Yeda Swirski; de Vasconcellos, Sílvio Luís; Garrido, Ivan Lapuente // Internext: Revista Electrônica de Negócios Internacionais da E;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p1 

    The present study aims to analyze the concept of learning in the internationalization studies. Considering the relationship between learning and internationalization had its groundwork at the Uppsala University, we believe its relevant outlining the path from the main publications regarding the...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics