Very Large Amounts of Radiation are Required to Produce Cancer

Brooks, Antone L.; Hui, T. Edmond; Couch, Lezlie A.
October 2007
Dose-Response;2007, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p263
Academic Journal
The public fear of radiation is in part driven by the Linear No Threshold Hypothesis (LNTH), or the concept that each and every ionization increases the risk for cancer. Even if this were true, it is important to recognize that the increased risk is very small at low doses and cannot be detected. This paper demonstrates the large number of assumptions and extrapolations needed when using the LNTH to estimate low-dose cancer risk. The manuscript provides information at every level of biological organization suggesting that many of these linear assumptions do not hold. While the initial damage may be produced linearly with dose, the processing of that damage is very non-linear. Finally, the paper provides the unique prospective on radiation-induced cancer, demonstrating that it takes large amounts (total energy) of radiation delivered to large populations to detect an increase in cancer frequency. These observations are supported by both theoretical calculations and examples based on past human radiation exposure.


Related Articles

  • Health Effects of Low Level Radiation: When Will We Acknowledge the Reality? Cuttler, J. M. // Dose-Response;2007, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p292 

    The 1986 April 26th Chernobyl event was the worst nuclear power accident�it killed 31 people. Its significance was exaggerated immensely because of the pervasive fear of ionizing radiation that has been indoctrinated in all of humanity. In reality, our environment includes radiation from...

  • LOW-LET-INDUCED RADIOPROTECTIVE MECHANISMS WITHIN A STOCHASTIC TWO-STAGE CANCER MODEL. Sch�llnberger, H.; Stewart, R. D.; Mitchel, R. E. J. // Dose-Response;2005, Vol. 3 Issue 4, p508 

    A stochastic two-stage cancer model with clonal expansion was used to investigate the potential impact on human lung cancer incidence of some aspects of the hormesis mechanisms suggested by Feinendegen (Health Phys. 52 663--669, 1987). The model was applied to low doses of low-LET radiation...

  • Rad-By-Rad (Bit-By-Bit): Triumph of Evidence Over Activities Fostering Fear of Radiogenic Cancers at Low Doses. Strzelczyk, J.; Potter, W.; Zdrojewicz, Z. // Dose-Response;2007, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p275 

    Large segments of Western populations hold sciences in low esteem. This trend became particularly pervasive in the field of radiation sciences in recent decades. The resulting lack of knowledge, easily filled with fear that feeds on itself, makes people susceptible to prevailing dogmas....

  • Low-Dose Cancer Risk Modeling Must Recognize Up-Regulation of Protection. Feinendegen, Ludwig E.; Pollycove, Myron; Neumann, Ronald D. // Dose-Response;2010, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p227 

    Ionizing radiation primarily perturbs the basic molecular level proportional to dose, with potential damage propagation to higher levels: cells, tissues, organs, and whole body. There are three types of defenses against damage propagation. These operate deterministically and below a certain...

  • Special Issue Introduction. Scott, Bobby R. // Dose-Response;2010, Vol. 8 Issue 2, p122 

    No abstract available.

  • Targeted Radiotherapy: Microgray Doses and the Bystander Effect. Mairs, Robert J.; Fullerton, Natasha E.; Zalutsky, Michael R.; Boyd, Marie // Dose-Response;2007, Vol. 5 Issue 3, p204 

    Indirect effects may contribute to the efficacy of radiotherapy by sterilizing malignant cells that are not directly irradiated. However, little is known of the influence of indirect effects in targeted radionuclide treatment. We compared ?-radiation-induced bystander effects with those...

  • Requirements for Identification of Low Dose and Non-Linear Mutagenic Responses to Ionising Radiation. Sykes, Pamela J.; Day, Tanya K. // Dose-Response;2007, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p308 

    Cancer results from multiple changes in gene expression that can occur both genetically and epigenetically. High doses of radiation can lead to mutations and cancer. At high doses the number of mutations caused by radiation is essentially linear with dose. Low dose radiation induced protective...

  • EFECTO DE BAJAS DOSIS DE RAYOS X SOBRE LA TOLERANCIA A LA SALINIDAD EN PLANTULAS. Fern�ndez, A. Ram�rez; Gonz�lez N��ez, L. M.; Talauera, S. P�rez // Nucleus;1998, Issue 25, p44 

    The work presents the effect of different radiation doses (ranging from 50 to 200 (3y), applied on irradiated lettuce seeds in an X-ray source for surface therapy, with a working regime of 30 kV and 10 mA and a dose rate of 12,9 Gy/min on the germination and growth of plantules in the presence...

  • Leukemia incidence in the Russian cohort of Chernobyl emergency workers. Ivanov, V.; Tsyb, A.; Khait, S.; Kashcheev, V.; Chekin, S.; Maksioutov, M.; Tumanov, K. // Radiation & Environmental Biophysics;May2012, Vol. 51 Issue 2, p143 

    Of all potentially radiogenic cancers, leukemia, a type of cancer of the blood, has the highest risk attributable to ionizing radiation. Despite this, the quantitative estimation of radiation risk of a leukemia demands studying very large exposed cohorts, because of the very low level of this...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics