Blinding of Outcomes in Trials of Orthopaedic Trauma: An Opportunity to Enhance the Validity of Clinical Trials

Karanicolas, Paul J.; Bhandari, Mohit; Taromi, Behzad; Akl, Elie A.; Bassler, Dirk; Alonso-Coello, Pablo; Rigau, David; Bryant, Dianne; Smith, Shona E.; Walter, Stephen D.; Guyatt, Gordon H.
May 2008
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;May2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 5, p1026
Academic Journal
Background: Blinding personnel in randomized controlled trials is an important strategy to minimize bias and increase the validity of the results. Trials of surgical interventions present blinding challenges not seen in drug trials. How often orthopaedic trauma investigators undertake blinding, and the frequency with which they could potentially utilize blinding, remains uncertain. Methods: We conducted a systematic review of all randomized controlled trials of orthopaedic trauma published from 1995 to 2004. Two reviewers assessed each trial for eligibility and extracted data regarding its characteristics, out- comes, reporting of blinding, and feasibility of blinding. Results: We included 171 unique randomized controlled trials spanning a variety of body regions and interventions. The most commonly reported outcomes were clinical (e.g., mortality or wound infection; 91% of trials), radiographic (83%), patient-reported (66%), and physiological results (e.g., range of motion; 56%). Less than 10% of the trials in each category reported the use of blinded outcome assessors. This contrasted with blinding that investigators could have accomplished: blinding was feasible with use of simple methods such as independent assessors, concealed incisions, and masked radiographs for 89% of clinical assessors, 89% of radiographic assessors, 96% of physiological assessors, and 35% of patient-reported assessors. Conclusions: Trials in orthopaedic trauma typically measure many outcomes requiring judgment, but the individuals assessing those outcomes are seldom blinded, Investigators have the opportunity to enhance the validity of future clinical trials by incorporating simple blinding techniques.


Related Articles

  • Commonly Missed Orthopedic Problems. Ballas, Michael T.; Tytko, James; Mannarino, Frank // American Family Physician;1/15/1998, Vol. 57 Issue 2, p267 

    States that when not diagnosed early and managed appropriately, common musculoskeletal injuries may result in long-term disabling conditions. Mention of some of the most common knee ligament injuries; Symptoms of slipped capital femoral epiphysis; What could result if fermoral neck stress...

  • Mobilize musculoskeletal injuries. Hoffman, Douglas; Rubin, Aaron // Physician & Sportsmedicine;Mar99, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p40 

    Recommends the management of musculoskeletal injuries by early mobilization methods. Immobilization of fractured distal radius; Treatment of ankle sprains; Early motion for shoulder and elbow dislocations.

  • Type-II Error Rates (Beta Errors) of Randomized Trials in Orthopaedic Trauma. Lochner, Heather V.; Bhandari, Mohit; Tornetta III, Paul // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Nov2001, Vol. 83-A Issue 11, p1650 

    Background: Although an investigator may limit bias through randomization, concealment of patient allocation, and blinding, the results of randomized trials may be less convincing when the sample size is not sufficiently large to reveal a true difference between treatment groups. When the sample...

  • Dysphagia and dyspnea due to an anterior cervical osteophyte. Maiuri, Francesco; Stella, Lucio; Sardo, Luigi; Buonamassa, Simona // Archives of Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgery;Apr2002, Vol. 122 Issue 4, p245 

    Hypertrophic anterior cervical osteophytes have been reported as a cause of dysphagia, with about 100 cases described in the literature; on the other hand, chronic or acute dyspnea due to edema of the laryngeal inlet or bilateral vocal cord adduction-fixation is rare. We report a 57-year-old...

  • Acute lymphoblastic leukemia presenting with thigh pain in a 2 year old: a case report with clinico-pathologic correlation. Mounasamy, Varatharaj; Savell, Jason; Giusti, Vincent; Herrera-Soto, José A. // European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology;Dec2006, Vol. 16 Issue 4, p372 

    Musculoskeletal pain may be the initial presentation of various malignancies. Leukemia presenting with bone pain is not uncommon . This case illustrates that periosteal reaction can be one of the initial radiological signs of leukemia and an immunohistochemical study with karyotyping is...

  • What's New in Orthopaedic Trauma. Cole, Peter A.; Miclau, III, Theodore; Ly, Thuan V.; Switzer, Julie A.; Mengnai Li; Morgan, Robert A.; Bhandari, Mohit // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Dec2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 12, p2804 

    The article presents an overview of orthopedic research which was conducted between June of 2007 and May of 2008 and which has led to improvements in the treatment of and a better understanding of orthopedic trauma. Research which has been conducted in several specialized areas of orthopedics,...

  • Temperature: rising. Philp, Matt // Metro (NZ);Jan2004, Issue 271, p36 

    Orthopedic trauma (OT) is not a gentle specialty. OT surgeons work with the broken bodies pulled from car wrecks and accident sites. It is, according to David Sage, Auckland District Health Board's Chief Medical Officer, a business of daily bloody mayhem. "It takes a particular kind of person to...

  • XXVI SICOT Triennial World Congress and the forty sixth SBOT Annual Meeting. Hinsenkamp, Maurice // International Orthopaedics;Aug2014, Vol. 38 Issue 8, p1547 

    The article offers information on the XXVI Société Internationale de Chirurgie Orthopédique et de Traumatologie (SICOT) Triennial World Congress and the 46th Sociedade Brasileira de Ortopedia e Traumatologia (SBOT) Annual Meeting that will take place in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil in 2014.

  • Postcards from the past: The Third SICOT Congress, Bologna 1936. Di Matteo, Berardo; Tarabella, Vittorio; Filardo, Giuseppe; Viganò, Anna; Tomba, Patrizia; Marcacci, Maurilio // International Orthopaedics;Aug2014, Vol. 38 Issue 8, p1745 

    This manuscript describes the events and eminent personalities who animated the third Congress of the 'Société Internationale de Chirurgie Orthopédique et Traumatologie', held in Bologna (Italy) in 1936. During this meeting the Society acquired its definitive name and the acronym under...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics