A critical appraisal of overdiagnosis: estimates of its magnitude and implications for lung cancer screening

Reich, J M
April 2008
Thorax;Apr2008, Vol. 63 Issue 4, p377
Academic Journal
Background: The magnitude of overdiagnosis is a critical and unresolved issue in lung cancer (LC) screening: (1) its contribution to the increase in survival constitutes specious evidence of benefit; (2) overdiagnosed individuals who undergo resection will experience a reduction in life expectancy, partially or completely offsetting the benefit received by others in whom earlier intervention proves curative. Method: Critical analysis of studies in opposition and support of the view that LC screening imposes a substantial burden of overdiagnosis. Results: Approximately 25%, possibly more, of radio- graphically (chest x ray) diagnosed LC appears to be overdiagnosed. Based on the observed tumour volume doubling time of low dose CT identified small malignant pulmonary nodules, CT will markedly augment lead time, increasing exposure to competing lethal morbidities, thereby increasing overdiagnosis. Conclusion: To reduce all-cause mortality, CT screening will need to reduce LC mortality by an amount that exceeds the increase in mortality attributable to surgery and loss of pulmonary reserve in persons who are overdiagnosed or pathologically understaged (ie, with occult micrometastasesl. Presently, there is no evidence that CT screening will achieve any reduction in LC mortality.


Related Articles

  • Spiral CT Lung Scans for Smokers and Former Smokers --Risks Are High, Lifesaving Benefit to be Determined.  // HealthFacts;May2005, Vol. 30 Issue 5, p4 

    Presents the results of a study on the risks of spiral computed tomography (CT) lung scans. Data on the false-positive rate of CT lung scans; Potential effects of the medical screening on the diagnosis of lung cancer; Comparison of the safety of spiral CT scans with chest X-rays.

  • Lung Cancer Screening: Ready for Prime Time? Peres, Judy // JNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute;Jan2011, Vol. 103 Issue 2, p89 

    The article reports on the result of the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST), which successfully cut deaths from the cancer by 20%. The study utilized either chest X-rays or low-dose helical computed tomography (CT) in detecting lung cancer. Hospitals and medical institutions supported the...

  • Benefits of Screening for Lung Cancer With CT Are Not Proven.  // Ascribe Newswire: Health;6/11/2004, p3 

    The medical literature does not support the widely held belief that an advanced screening technique called computed tomography can save lives simply because it detects lung cancers at a smaller size than other screening techniques, according to researchers at Duke University Medical Center and...

  • PLAIN X-RAY SCREENING: IS IT AN OPTION? B. W. O. // Radiology Today;Jan2011, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p24 

    The article focuses on the possible use of x-rays as an option for the screening of lung cancer in the U.S. Chief technology officer of Riverain Medical, Steve Worrell, mentions the effect of the result from the National Lung Screening Trial (NLST) on the role of x-rays on lung cancer mortality,...

  • The size of consolidation on thin-section computed tomography is a better predictor of survival than the maximum tumour dimension in resectable lung cancer. Linden, Philip // Current Medical Literature: Lung Cancer;2013, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p30 

    The author comments on the study "The Size of Consolidation on Thin-section Computed Tomography Is a Better Predictor of Survival Than the Maximum Tumour Dimension in Resectable Lung Cancer," by T. Mæyashiki et al published in a 2013 issue of the "European Journal of Cardiothoracic Surgery."...

  • Imaging of lung cancer with fluorine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose: comparison of a dual-head gamma camera in coincidence mode with a full-ring positron emission tomography system. Weber, W. A.; Neverve, J.; Sklarek, J.; Ziegler, S. I.; Bartenstein, P.; King, B.; Treumann, T.; Enterrottacher, A.; Krapf, M.; Häußinger, K. E.; Lichte, H.; Präuer, H. W.; Thetter, O.; Schwaiger, M. // European Journal of Nuclear Medicine;1999, Vol. 26 Issue 4, p388 

    Abstract. Dual-head gamma cameras operated in coincidence mode are a new approach for tumour imaging using fluorine-18 fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG). The aim of this study was to assess the diagnostic accuracy of such a camera system in comparison with a full-ring positron emission tomography (PET)...

  • Possibilities of Computer Assisted Tomography (CT) in Evaluation of Lung Cancer Operability. Ibralic, Muris; Smajlovic, Fahrudin // Medicinski Arhiv;2009, Vol. 63 Issue 5, p261 

    As is well known, surgical treatment is the most effective therapy for non-small cell lung cancer, although only a small number of patients are suitable for this type of treatment (25% -30%). The outcome of operative treatment and prognosis greatly depends on accurate preoperative diagnostic...

  • Diagnosis and Prognosis.  // Current Medical Literature: Lung Cancer;2012, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p51 

    Clinical reviews related to diagnosis and prognosis of lung cancer are presented. One study describes how low-dose computed tomography detected the natural history of pure ground-glass opacity lung nodules. Another study offers information on the 7th revision of the tumor, node, metastasis (TNM)...

  • Helical CT helps in reducing mortality in lung cancer screening.  // Journal of Medical Physics;Jan-Mar2011, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p51 

    The article focuses on a randomized controlled lung screening trial conducted by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institute of Health which found that low-dose helical computed tomography (CT) resulted to a reduction in lung cancer mortality.


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics