Validation of two models to estimate the probability of malignancy in patients with solitary pulmonary nodules

Schultz, E M; Sanders, G D; Trotter, P R; Patz Jr, E F; Silvestri, G A; Owens, D K; Gould, M K
April 2008
Thorax;Apr2008, Vol. 63 Issue 4, p335
Academic Journal
Background: Effective strategies for managing patients with solitary pulmonary nodules (SPN) depend critically on the pre-test probability of malignancy. Objective: To validate two previously developed models that estimate the probability that an indeterminate SPN is malignant, based on clinical characteristics and radiographic findings. Methods: Data on age, smoking and cancer history, nodule size, location and spiculation were collected retrospectively from the medical records of 151 veterans (145 men, 6 women; age range 39-87 years) with an SPN measuring 7-30 mm (inclusive) and a final diagnosis established by histopathology or 2-year follow-up. Each patient's final diagnosis was compared with the probability of malignancy predicted by two models: one developed by investigators at the Mayo Clinic and the other developed from patients enrolled in a VA Cooperative Study. The accuracy of each model was assessed by calculating areas under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve and the models were calibrated by comparing predicted and observed rates of malignancy. Results: The area under the ROC curve for the Mayo Clinic model (0.80; 95% Cl 0.72 to 0.88) was higher than that of the VA model (0.73; 95% Cl 0.64 to 0.82), but this difference was not statistically significant (Δ = 0.07; 95% Cl -0.03 to 0.16). Calibration curves showed that the probability of malignancy was underestimated by the Mayo Clinic model and overestimated by the VA model. Conclusions: Two existing prediction models are sufficiently accurate to guide decisions about the selection and interpretation of subsequent diagnostic tests in patients with SPNs, although clinicians should also consider the prevalence of malignancy in their practice setting when choosing a model.


Related Articles

  • Solitary Lung Nodule in a 77-Year-Old Male Smoker. Ahsanuddin, Arshad Naveed; Williams, H. James // Archives of Pathology & Laboratory Medicine;Dec2003, Vol. 127 Issue 12, p1631 

    Presents a pathologic case study of pulmonary cryptococcoma seen in an old man with a solitary lung nodule. Clinical history of the patient; Results of physical and laboratory examinations performed on the patient; Background on the disease.

  • A working diagnosis. McCue, Jack D.; Bottone, Susan // Cortlandt Forum;3/25/96, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p196 

    Presents a medical case involving a man who was evaluated for a solitary pulmonary nodule. Diagnostic tests include direct laryngoscopy and computerized tomography (CT) scan; Medical history; Tobacco habit; Physical examination; Etiology; Invasive technique for a definitive diagnosis; Chest...

  • Clinical significance of pulmonary nodules detected on abdominal CT in pediatric patients. Breen, Micheál; Zurakowski, David; Lee, Edward; Lee, Edward Y // Pediatric Radiology;Nov2015, Vol. 45 Issue 12, p1753 

    Background: The clinical significance of a pulmonary nodule that is detected incidentally on CT studies in children is unknown. In addition, there is limited information regarding the management of incidentally detected pulmonary nodules discovered on abdominal CT studies in...

  • Nodule on the chest. Agarwal, Saurabh; Kumar, Binay; Sharma, Naveen // Indian Journal of Dermatology, Venereology & Leprology;Nov/Dec2009, Vol. 75 Issue 6, p639 

    The article discusses the case study of a 55-year-old male who presented with an asymptomatic nodule on the chest for the last six years. There was no regional lymphandenopathy of tumor which used to bleed a little, occasionally. The histopathology showed broad anastomosing tracts of cuboidal...

  • Calcitonin estimation in patients with nodular goiter and its significance for early detection of MTC: european comments to the guidelines of the American Thyroid Association. Elisei, Rossella; Romei, Cristina // Thyroid Research;2013, Vol. 6 Issue S1, p1 

    One of the most discussed and controversial issue in the management of thyroid nodules is the need to perform a routine measurement of serum Calcitonin (Ct) in all cases. The American Thyroid Association guidelines do not recommend in favor or against this procedure since they retain that there...

  • tuberculum.  // Taber's Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary (2009);2009, Issue 21, p2386 

    A definition of the medical term "tuberculum," which refers to a small knot or a tubercle, is presented.

  • The incidental pulmonary nodule: an impetus for guidelines. Thacker, Paul // Pediatric Radiology;May2015, Vol. 45 Issue 5, p777 

    A letter to the editor is presented that discusses the guidelines for incidental pulmonary nodule.

  • End-stage care in COPD and heart failure. Gibbs, Louise // Pulse;4/5/2004, Vol. 64 Issue 14, p70 

    Focuses on the end-stage care of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary diseases (COPD) and heart failure. Assessment of cancer problems; Details on the symptomatic management of breathlessness, pain, nausea, constipation and anxiety/depression; Significance of pulmonary rehabilitation to...

  • Asymptomatic nodules over forearm and hand.  // Indian Journal of Dermatology, Venereology & Leprology;Nov/Dec2003, Vol. 69 Issue 6, p425 

    Presents a trivia on asymptomatic nodules over forearm and hand.


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics