Primary Arthroscopic Stabilization for a First-Time Anterior Dislocation of the Shoulder: A Randomized, Double-Blind Trial

Robinson, C. Michael; Jenkins, Paul J.; White, Timothy O.; Ker, Andrew; Will, Elizabeth
April 2008
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Apr2008, Vol. 90-A Issue 4, p708
Academic Journal
Background: Anterior dislocation of the glenohumeral joint in younger patients is associated with a high risk of recurrence and persistent functional deficits. The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of a primary arthroscopic Bankart repair, while controlling for the therapeutic effects produced by the arthroscopic intervention and joint lavage. Methods: In a single-center, double-blind clinical trial, eighty-eight adult patients under thirty-five years of age who had sustained a primary anterior glenohumeral dislocation were randomized to receive either an arthroscopic examination and joint lavage alone or together with an anatomic repair of the Bankart lesion. Assessment of the rate of recurrent instability, functional outcome (with use of three scores), range of movement, patient satisfaction, direct health-service costs, and treatment complications was completed for eighty-four of these patients (forty-two in each group) during the subsequent two years. Results: In the two years after the primary dislocation, the risk of a further dislocation was reduced by 76% and the risk of all recurrent instability was reduced by 82% in the Bankart repair group compared with the group that had arthroscopy and lavage alone. The functional scores were also better (p < 0.05), the treatment costs were lower (p = 0.012), and patient satisfaction was higher (p < 0.001) after arthroscopic repair. The improved functional outcome appeared to be mediated through the prevention of instability since the functional outcome in patients with stable shoulders was similar, irrespective of the initial treatment allocation. The patients who had a Bankart repair and played contact sports were also more likely to have returned to their sport at two years (relative risk = 3.4, p = 0.007). Conclusions: Following a first-time anterior dislocation of the shoulder, there is a marked treatment benefit from primary arthroscopic repair of a Bankart lesion, which is distinct from the so-called background therapeutic effect of the arthroscopic examination and lavage of the joint. However, primary repair does not appear to confer a functional benefit to patients with a stable shoulder at two years after the dislocation. Level of Evidence: Therapeutic Leve lI. See Instructions to Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.


Related Articles

  • CORR Insights: Factors That Influence the Choice to Undergo Surgery for Shoulder and Elbow Conditions. Matsen, Frederick // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Mar2014, Vol. 472 Issue 3, p892 

    The article focuses on the factors that affect choice of shoulder and elbow elective surgery due to presence of several risk factors. Topics discussed include consideration of repair of rotator cuff cable tears by clinicians that may later need surgical intervention, surgeon reimbursement and...

  • Sport injuries: a review of outcomes. Maffulli, Nicola; Longo, Umile Giuseppe; Gougoulias, Nikolaos; Caine, Dennis; Denaro, Vincenzo // British Medical Bulletin;Mar2011, Vol. 97 Issue 1, p47 

    Injuries can counter the beneficial aspects related to sports activities if an athlete is unable to continue to participate because of residual effects of injury. We provide an updated synthesis of existing clinical evidence of long-term follow-up outcome of sports injuries. A systematic...

  • Risk of drug-induced liver injury with the new oral anticoagulants: systematic review and meta-analysis. Caldeira, Daniel; Barra, Márcio; Santos, Ana Teresa; de Abreu, Daisy; Pinto, Fausto J.; Ferreira, Joaquim J.; Costa, João // Heart;Apr2014, Vol. 100 Issue 7, p550 

    Objective In recent years, safety alerts have been made warning of the risk of serious drug-induced liver injury (DILI) caused by cardiovascular drugs. The new oral anticoagulants (NOACs) have now reached the market. However, safety concerns have been raised about their hepatic safety. Therefore...

  • New techniques, tools level field for open and arthroscopic instability repair. Zabel, Karen // Orthopedics Today;Apr2008, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p64 

    The article reports on the techniques for open and arthroscopic repairs. According to the Orthopedics Today Hawaii 2008 conference, the anterior shoulder instability where arthroscopic procedure was done, is comparable to open procedures but with a few disorder. According to doctor William...

  • Risk of Tear Progression in Nonoperatively Treated Small Full-Thickness Rotator Cuff Tears. Tashjian, Robert Z. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;5/2/2012, Vol. 94-A Issue 9, pe61-1 

    The article presents commentary on an article in this issue by Sandro F. Fucentese and colleagues, "Evolution of Nonoperatively Treated Symptomatic Isolated Full-Thickness Supraspinatus Tears." The commentary praises the researchers for their work on determining the risk of tear progression in...

  • Repairing shoulders with arthroscopy.  // USA Today Magazine;Oct95, Vol. 124 Issue 2605, p15 

    Reports on the use of arthroscopy to repair shoulder instability in young athletes and rotator cuff damage in older patients. Breakthroughs in arthroscopic surgical techniques and scientific research; Comments from Russell F. Warren of the Hospital for Special Surgery in New York; Early...

  • A no-cutting edge. O'Brien, Richard; Hersch, Hank // Sports Illustrated;06/23/97, Vol. 86 Issue 25, p24 

    Reports on ElectroThermal Arthroscopy, a new technique for repairing the injuries caused by shoulder separations. How it works; Its cost and safety record; Developer Oratec; What the technique actually does to shoulder tissue; Success rates.

  • Anterosuperior labrum lesions of the shoulder joint: pathogenesis, arthroscopic treatment, and results. Rose, Tim; Hepp, Pierre; Korner, Jan; Josten, Christoph; Lill, Helmut // Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy;Sep2002, Vol. 10 Issue 5, p316 

    The anterosuperior labrum lesion of the shoulder without biceps anchor involvement is a rare injury, and it is unclear whether the refixation has advantages over resection. We describe the pathophysiology and treatment, and compare the functional outcome of these procedures of refixation and...

  • THROWING INJURIES IN THE ADOLESCENT ATHLETE. Shanley, Ellen; Thigpen, Chuck // International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy;Oct2013, Vol. 8 Issue 5, p630 

    INTRODUCTION: Adolescents ranging in age from 11-15 (early-mid adolescence) comprise the largest percentage of baseball and softball athletes in the United States. Shoulder and elbow injuries are commonly experienced by these athletes with baseball pitchers and softball position players most...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics