Living Proof and the Pseudoscience of Alternative Cancer Treatments

Vickers, Andrew J.; Cassileth, Barrie R.
January 2008
Journal of the Society for Integrative Oncology;Winter2008, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p37
Academic Journal
Michael Gearin-Tosh was an English professor at Oxford University who was diagnosed with multiple myeloma in 1994. He rejected conventional chemotherapeutic approaches and turned to a variety of alternative cancer treatments, particularly those involving nutritional supplements and dietary change. In 2002, Dr. Gearin-Tosh published a book, Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny, recounting his experiences. The book gained significant public and media attention. One chapter was written by Carmen Wheatley, an advocate of alternative cancer treatments. In distinction to Dr. Gearin-Tosh's personal story, Dr. Wheatley makes general claims about cancer treatment that are supposedly based on the research literature. This appears to provide scientific validation for a highly unconventional program of cancer care. However, the scientific case made for alternative cancer treatments in Living Proof does not bear serious examination. There are numerous inaccuracies, omissions, and misrepresentations. Many important claims are either entirely unsubstantiated or not supported by the literature cited. In conclusion, a highly publicized book gives the impression that alternative cancer treatments are supported by scientific research. It also suggests that little progress has been made in the conventional treatment of myeloma. This is highly misleading and may lead to cancer patients rejecting effective treatments.


Related Articles

  • Allopathic Medicine's Stonewall Shaken. Straus, Howard D. // Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine;2003 1st Quarter, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p5 

    Presents view on the book 'Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny,' by Professor Michael Gearin-Tosh which deals with the supposed effectiveness of alternative therapy in the treatment of multiple myeloma. Treatment course offered by conventional medicine; Response of medical professionals on the...

  • LIVING PROOF: A MEDICAL MUTINY. Hall, Harriet A. // Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine;Spring/Summer2005, Vol. 9, p78 

    The article reviews the book "LIVING PROOF: A MEDICAL MUTINY," by Michael Gearin-Tosh.

  • Living Proof (Book). Bibel, Barbara // Library Journal;5/1/2003, Vol. 128 Issue 8, p62 

    Reviews the non-fiction book, 'Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny,' by Michael Gearin-Tosh.

  • Living Proof (Book). Hoffer, A. // Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine;2002 1st Quarter, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p58 

    Reviews the book 'Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny,' by Michael Gearin-Tosh.

  • Living Proof--A Medical Mutiny. Goodman, Sandra // Positive Health;Mar2002, Issue 74, p5 

    Reviews the book 'Living Proof,' by Michael Gearin-Tosh.

  • Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny. Malpas, James Spencer // New England Journal of Medicine;12/12/2002, Vol. 347 Issue 24, p1986 

    Presents a review of the book 'Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny' by Michael Gearin-Tosh.

  • LIVING PROOF (Book).  // Kirkus Reviews;2/15/2002, Vol. 70 Issue 4, p235 

    Reviews the book 'Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny,' by Michael Gearin-Tosh.

  • Living Proof (Book). Camidge, Ross // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);4/6/2002, Vol. 324 Issue 7341, p855 

    Reviews the book 'Living Proof: A Medical Mutiny,' by Michael Gearin-Tosh.

  • Why the Gerson Therapy Heals. Gerson, Charlotte // Gerson Healing Newsletter;Jul/Aug2004, Vol. 19 Issue 4, p4 

    Reviews the book "Living Proof -- A Medical Mutiny," by Michael Gearin-Tosh.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics