Industrial Relations, Historical Contingencies and Political Economy: Britain in the 1960s and 1970s

Phillips, Jim
December 2007
Labour History Review;Dec2007, Vol. 72 Issue 3, p215
Academic Journal
Historical literature on labour and industrial relations is broadly silent on theoretical questions; and management and industrial relations literature tends to overlook historical contingency. This article brings these different literatures into closer alignment, examining the concept of pluralism in industrial relations, indicating that the embeddedness of non-pluralist values among employers shaped the erosion of pluralist realities � joint industrial bargaining mechanisms � from the 1970s onwards. The article explores Alan Fox's paper for the Donovan Commission, Industrial Sociology and Industrial Relations (1966), with its emphasis on the manner in which competing 'frames of reference' generated contrasting interpretations of industrial relations and industrial conflict, and examines material developments in the sectors singled out by Fox: coalmining and the docks. The article generally supports a central criticism of some pluralist approaches in industrial relations literature, concluding that broader forces � including macro-economic management and counter-inflationary wages policy, perceived by some workers as class injustice � were the central contingencies shaping industrial conflict. As Fox emphasised in his later writings, attempts to reform the system of industrial relations � by both Labour and Conservative governments � were misguided, but reflected the subject's growing politicisation.


Related Articles

  • Unions and a Lid on Wages. Wenham, Brian // New Republic;9/25/65, Vol. 153 Issue 13, p17 

    Encourages trade unions to support the Labour Party's policy on restraint wage increases in a time of economic downtrend in Great Britain. Response of the Trade Union Congress (TUC) members to self-screening of wage claims; Administrative problem of coping with the demands from various labor...

  • LETTER FROM LONDON. Panter-Downes, Mollie // New Yorker;1/28/1974, Vol. 49 Issue 49, p70 

    This article discusses Great Britain politics and government under Prime Minister Edward Heath. The government intervened in a labor dispute between miners and companies. The government refused a labor union's promise to hold back other wage claims if the dispute is resolved and the miners are...

  • WHAT IF...Britain had said no to the IMF. Sandbrook, Dominic // New Statesman;8/16/2010, Vol. 139 Issue 5014, p11 

    In this article the author creates a piece of alternate history as he speculates as to how British political and social life would have been different had the government not accepted a loan from the International Monetary Fund in December 1976.

  • 30 year ago.  // New Statesman & Society;10/14/94, Vol. 7 Issue 324, p9 

    Focuses on the political events of October 1964 in Great Britain. Structural reform of the British industry.

  • LETTERS TO THE EDITORS. Pelling, Henry // Bulletin -- Society for the Study of Labour History;Spring70, Issue 20, p25 

    Presents a letter to the editor in response to the article "Popular Politics and Society in Late Victorian Britain?".

  • UNOFFICIAL TRADE UNION MILITANCY AMONG THE FIFE MINERS IN THE 1920'S AND 1930'S. Gilby, Bill; Sime, Martin // Bulletin -- Society for the Study of Labour History;Spring79, Issue 38, p12 

    The article focuses on the intra-union conflicts among miners in Fife, Scotland. At the heart of the intra-union conflicts among the Fife miners lay a basic conflict of ideologies between the right-wing Labour officials of the 'Old Union' led by William Adamson, Member of Parliament, and the...

  • World without unions? Look at New Zealand. Dannin, Ellen J. // San Diego Business Journal;9/4/95, Vol. 16 Issue 36, p24 

    Discusses a work environment without unions in New Zealand. Concern in the United States about the decline of unions; NZ's Employment Contracts Act (ECA); ECA view of the interests of employer and employee as naturally unitary and beneficial to both; View of unions as source of labor-management...

  • Trade Union Act 1984 provision in force.  // Accountancy;Oct84, Vol. 95 Issue 1094, p22 

    Discusses the provisions in the 1984 Trade Union Act in Great Britain.

  • �Krise des Normalarbeitsverh�ltnisses� - nach 25 Jahren revisited Vorbemerkung. M�ckenberger, Ulrich // Zeitschrift f�r Sozialreform;2010, Vol. 56 Issue 4, p399 

    The following contributions revisit the article "The crisis of the standard employment relationship" published 25 years ago in this journal. They concur in the observation that what was a prognosis at that time - an increasing patchwork of deregulated flexible employment - is a reality today and...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics