Regional variability in use of a novel assessment of thoracolumbar spine fractures: United States versus international surgeons

Ratliff, John; Anand, Neel; Vaccaro, Alexander R.; Lim, Moe R.; Lee, Joon Y.; Arnold, Paul; Harrop, James S.; Rampersaud, Raja; Bono, Christopher M.; Gahr, Ralf H.
January 2007
World Journal of Emergency Surgery;2007, Vol. 2, p24
Academic Journal
Background: Considerable variability exists in clinical approaches to thoracolumbar fractures. Controversy in evaluation and nomenclature contribute to this confusion, with significant differences found between physicians, between different specialties, and in different geographic regions. A new classification system for thoracolumbar injuries, the Thoracolumbar Injury Severity Score (TLISS), was recently described by Vaccaro. No assessment of regional differences has been described. We report regional variability in use of the TLISS system between United States and non-US surgeons. Methods: Twenty-eight spine surgeons (8 neurosurgeons and 20 orthopedic surgeons) reviewed 56 clinical thoracolumbar injury case histories, which included pertinent imaging studies. Cases were classified and scored using the TLISS system. After a three month period, the case histories were re-ordered and the physicians repeated the exercise; 22 physicians completed both surveys and were used to assess intra-rater reliability. The reliability and treatment validity of the TLISS was assessed. Surgeons were grouped into US (n = 15) and non-US (n = 13) cohorts. Inter-rater (both within and between different geographic groups) and intra-rater reliability was assessed by percent agreement, Cohen's kappa, kappa with linear weighting, and Spearman's rank-order correlation. Conclusion: Non-US surgeons were found to have greater inter-rater reliability in injury mechanism, while agreement on neurological status and posterior ligamentous complex integrity tended to be higher among US surgeons. Inter-rater agreement on management was moderate, although it tended to be higher in US-surgeons. Inter-rater agreement between US and non-US surgeons was similar to within group inter-rater agreement for all categories. While intra-rater agreement for mechanism tended to be higher among US surgeons, intra-rater reliability for neurological status and PLC was slightly higher among non-US surgeons. Intra-rater reliability for management was substantial in both US and non-US surgeons. The TLISS incorporates generally accepted features of spinal injury assessment into a simple patient evaluation tool. The management recommendation of the treatment algorithm component of the TLISS shows good inter-rater and substantial intra-rater reliability in both non-US and US based spine surgeons. The TLISS may improve communication between health providers and may contribute to more efficient management of thoracolumbar injuries.


Related Articles

  • Nonoperatively treated type A spinal fractures: mid-term versus long-term functional outcome. R. Post; V. Leferink; P. Dijkstra; H. ten Duis // International Orthopaedics;Aug2009, Vol. 33 Issue 4, p1055 

    Abstract��This study focuses on the mid-term (four�years) and long-term (ten�years) functional outcome of patients treated nonoperatively for a type A spinal fracture without primary neurological deficit. Functional outcome was measured using the visual analogue scale spine...

  • Timing of thoracic and lumbar fracture fixation in spinal injuries: a systematic review of neurological and clinical outcome. Rutges, Jozef Paulus Henricus Johannes; Oner, F. Cumhur; Leenen, Luke Peter Hendrik // European Spine Journal;May2007, Vol. 16 Issue 5, p579 

    A systematic review of all available evidence on the timing of surgical fixation for thoracic and lumbar fractures with respect to clinical and neurological outcome was designed. The purpose of this review is to clarify some of the controversy about the timing of surgical fracture fixation in...

  • Vertos II findings conflict with earlier study results. PEDERSEN, AMANDA // Medical Device Daily;10/22/2010, Vol. 14 Issue 206, p1 

    The article focuses on a study by Vertos II which showed the effectiveness of vertebroplasty for treating acute fractures of the vertebrae. According the study, the surgical procedure if appropriately used, has the potential to enhance patient outcomes and improve cost efficiency within the...

  • Is it useful to apply transpedicular intracorporeal bone grafting to unstable thoracolumbar fractures? A systematic review. Ma, Yiqun; Li, Xilei; Dong, Jian // Acta Neurochirurgica;Dec2012, Vol. 154 Issue 12, p2205 

    Background: The debate over the use of intracorporeal bone graft in treating unstable thoracolumbar fractures continues. We compiled evidence for the effect of transpedicular intracorporeal bone grafting (TPG) on outcome in patients with traumatic thoracolumbar fractures. Method: A systematic...

  • Treatment of multiple osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures by percutaneous cement augmentation. Saracen, Agnieszka; Kotwica, Zbigniew // International Orthopaedics;Nov2014, Vol. 38 Issue 11, p2309 

    Purpose: Vertebral compression fractures cause significant pain and some patients are debilitated by the pain due to the fracture. Conventional surgery carries a high risk and has a poor outcome. Vertebroplasty is a minimally invasive surgical procedure, which in vertebral fractures restores...

  • Type D fractures of the odontoid process. Korres, Demetrios; Mavrogenis, Andreas; Gratsias, Petros; Posantzis, Marcos; Giannakopoulos, Evangelos; Efstathopoulos, Nikolaos // European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Traumatology;Dec2010, Vol. 20 Issue 8, p597 

    Type D fractures of the odontoid process are rare and usually occur in the elderly. The mechanism of fracture is unclear. Non-operative treatment is indicated provided that adequate immobilization using skull traction followed by either a collar or a halo vest can be achieved. The prognosis is...

  • Back Issues and Reflexology Support. Booth, Lynne // Positive Health;Aug2014, Issue 216, p1 

    A reprint of the article "Back Issues and Reflexology Support," by Lynne Booth, which appeared in the August 2014 issue of "Reflexology," is presented. It discusses the effectiveness of reflexology treatments in easing pain, the theory behind reflexology, and two case studies that shows the...

  • Vertebroplasty for vertebral fracture. Wilson, David J. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition;7/16/2011, Vol. 343 Issue 7815, p104 

    No abstract available.

  • Outcomes of surgery for unstable odontoid fractures combined with instability of adjacent segments. Lei Wang; Chao Liu; Qing-hua Zhao; Ji-Wei Tian // Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery & Research;2014, Vol. 9 Issue 1, p37 

    Background At present, traumatic atlantoaxial dislocation or C2-3 instability complicating odontoid fractures remains rarely reported. The aim of this study was to further investigate the surgical treatment strategies and curative effects for odontoid fractures combined with instability of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics