Benefits of Protecting Investment Portfolios with Options: A Historical Perspective

Dubil, Robert
February 2008
Journal of Financial Planning;Feb2008, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p58
Academic Journal
• This paper examines the true effectiveness of options in protecting investment portfolios using 1967-2006 stock index data. Options theory typically ignores the bid-ask spread and has no room for volatility skew. We use real prices of S&P 500 options to account for both of these significant costs of using options. We compute terminal investment values, period returns, return-to-volatility (Sharpe) and return-to-semi-volatility (loss risk) statistics. • We overlayed an unprotected portfolio with five option strategies over 40-, 30-, 20-, and 10-year holding horizons, on a quarterly and yearly basis. We found several strong results that hold both for young investors (seeking return) as well as near-retirement investors (seeking low risk). • While most expensive, buying near- or at-the-money puts works best. Overall the return is similar to unprotected portfolios, but the risk is significantly reduced. Puts provide the highest reward-to-risk ratios. They should be used by investors who are retired or nearing retirement. • Put spreads (buy at-the-money puts and sell out-of-the-money puts) are cheaper than puts, but not effective. They result in lower returns and their risk mitigation is weak. A young investor seeking the highest possible return would be better off with a put strategy or no options. • Collars can, through the sale of high strike calls, reduce the cost of insurance, even to zero, and they help mitigate risk. But unless the strikes are well chosen, they can lead to a dramatic reduction of total return. • Using quarterly option strategies is better than an annual strategy, but if done right, both can work well in reducing risk and enhancing return.


Related Articles

  • 'What's The Market Trend?' Page Gets Improvements, More Color. JUAN CARLOS ARANCIBIA // Investors Business Daily;8/29/2014, pB04 

    A longtime IBD staple has just undergone a face-lift.

  • HAPPY NEW YEAR: YOUR BEST INVESTMENT STRAGEGY FOR 1993. Kuhn, Susan E.; Neumeier, Shelley; Sheeline, William E. // Fortune;1/11/1993, Vol. 127 Issue 1, p25 

    Discusses the investment strategies for the major markets. Reference to the Standard & Poor's stock range; View of Gregory Nie, a technical analyst with Kemper Securities, that stocks could face a difficult first half; Information that any technology and financial services companies, especially...

  • Bid-Ask Spreads and Trading Activity in the S&P 100 Index Options Market. George, Thomas J.; Longstaff, Francis A. // Journal of Financial & Quantitative Analysis;Sep93, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p381 

    This paper examines the cross-sectional distribution of bid-ask spreads in the S&P 100 index options market. Cross-sectional differences in bid-ask spreads are found to be directly related to differences in market-making costs and trading activity across options. We also examine the relation of...

  • VIX and VIX Futures Pricing Algorithms: Cultivating Understanding. Hancock, G. D'Anne // Modern Economy;May2012, Vol. 3 Issue 3, p284 

    This article reviews the development of the S&P 500 volatility index and uses market information to develop algorithms which aid in clarifying some of the salient points in the determination of an index value. Understanding the pertinent points provides insight into the interpretation and...

  • VIX, it protects and diversifies. Bittman, James // Futures: News, Analysis & Strategies for Futures, Options & Deri;Jul2007, Vol. 36 Issue 9, p38 

    The article reports on the Volatility Index also known as VIX introduced by Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE) in the U.S. The Volatility Index was developed to track the implied volatility level of Standard & Poor's (S&P) 500 Stock Index options considered as cash-settled index options based...

  • When the Market Sleeps. Nelson, Brett // Forbes Global;10/18/2004, Vol. 7 Issue 18, p46 

    Focuses on the sale of option contracts on the Standard & Poor's 500 Index Max G. Ansbacher, a Wall Street veteran. Description of index options; Risk of selling covered calls; Overview of Ansbacher's trading strategy.

  • Nothing to Fear but the Fear Index. Poppick, Susie // Money;Dec2011, Vol. 40 Issue 11, p50 

    Several graphs are presented regarding the swings in investment markets, including a graph on the number of 4 percent swings in the Standard and Poor's (S&P) index, a graph detailing the Volatility index (VIX) in 2006-2011, and a graph indicating highs and lows of the VIX in 1997-2008.

  • Are you confident about sentiment? Simons, Howard L. // Futures: News, Analysis & Strategies for Futures, Options & Deri;Aug2005, Vol. 34 Issue 10, p36 

    Evaluates the effect of consumer sentiment surveys and retail sales reports on financial markets in the U.S. Relationship between consumer confidence and retail sales; Market capitalization on consumer expectations; Relative performance of the S&P retail index to the Standard & Poor's 500 stock...

  • S&P500 at critical level. Abrams, Colin // Finance Week;5/24/2004, p22 

    Examines the performance of Standard & Poor's (S&P) 500 Index and Anglo American and their effect on the direction of the JSE Securities Exchange in South Africa. Factors that make the S&P index a critical level to observe; Trend in the weekly relative strength index of the financial...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics