Cognitive Behavioral Therapy versus Short Psychodynamic Supportive Psychotherapy in the outpatient treatment of depression: a randomized controlled trial

Driessen, Ellen; Van, Henricus L.; Schoevers, Robert A.; Cuijpers, Pim; Van Aalst, Gerda; Don, Frank J.; Hendriksen, Mariƫlle; Kool, Simone; Molenaar, Pieter J.; Peen, Jaap; Dekker, Jack J. M.
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007, Vol. 7, p58
Academic Journal
Background: Previous research has shown that Short Psychodynamic Supportive Psychotherapy (SPSP) is an effective alternative to pharmacotherapy and combined treatment (SPSP and pharmacotherapy) in the treatment of depressed outpatients. The question remains, however, how Short Psychodynamic Supportive Psychotherapy compares with other established psychotherapy methods. The present study compares Short Psychodynamic Supportive Psychotherapy to the evidence-based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy in terms of acceptability, feasibility, and efficacy in the outpatient treatment of depression. Moreover, this study aims to identify clinical predictors that can distinguish patients who may benefit from either of these treatments in particular. This article outlines the study protocol. The results of the study, which is being currently carried out, will be presented as soon as they are available. Methods/Design: Adult outpatients with a main diagnosis of major depressive disorder or depressive disorder not otherwise specified according to DSM-IV criteria and mild to severe depressive symptoms (Hamilton Depression Rating Scale score = 14) are randomly allocated to Short Psychodynamic Supportive Psychotherapy or Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. Both treatments are individual psychotherapies consisting of 16 sessions within 22 weeks. Assessments take place at baseline (week 0), during the treatment period (week 5 and 10) and at treatment termination (week 22). In addition, a follow-up assessment takes place one year after treatment start (week 52). Primary outcome measures are the number of patients refusing treatment (acceptability); the number of patients terminating treatment prematurely (feasibility); and the severity of depressive symptoms (efficacy) according to an independent rater, the clinician and the patient. Secondary outcome measures include general psychopathology, general psychotherapy outcome, pain, health-related quality of life, and cost-effectiveness. Clinical predictors of treatment outcome include demographic variables, psychiatric symptoms, cognitive and psychological patient characteristics and the quality of the therapeutic relationship. Discussion: This study evaluates Short Psychodynamic Supportive Psychotherapy as a treatment for depressed outpatients by comparing it to the established evidence-based treatment Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. Specific strengths of this study include its strong external validity and the clinical relevance of its research aims. Limitations of the study are discussed.


Related Articles

  • Psychological Treatments for Depression. Scott, Jan // British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep95, Vol. 167, p289 

    The article provides updates on several psychological treatment models for depression. Some psychological approaches are behavior therapy, cognitive therapy (CT), interpersonal therapy (IPT) and brief dynamic psychotherapy. Greater emphasis on health gain and relapse prevention may increase the...

  • Management: psychodynamics. Dominian, J. // British Medical Journal;10/20/1979, Vol. 2 Issue 6196, p987 

    Focuses on the aspects of psychodynamic treatment. Interpretation on the emotional patterns of the couple; Process of behavior therapy; Details on enjoying the appropriate parental response.

  • Essential Techniques for the Beginning Psychodynamic Psychotherapist. Sublette, M. Elizabeth; Novick, Jon // American Journal of Psychotherapy;2004, Vol. 58 Issue 1, p67 

    The process of learning to conduct psychotherapy is extremely challenging, especially in the initial stages. It is not inappropriate for the novice to seek concrete guidance as to how to proceed in the initial work with the patient. Unfortunately, however, the therapist in training may be...

  • Updating the Evidence and Recommendations for Short-Term Psychodynamic Psychotherapy in the Treatment of Major Depressive Disorder in Adults. Town, Joel M.; Abbass, Allan; Driessen, Ellen; Luyten, Patrick; Weerasekera, Priyanthy // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Jan2017, Vol. 62 Issue 1, p73 

    A letter to the editor is presented concerning revised Canadian Network for Mood and Anxiety Treatments guidelines for psychological therapy treating depression in which they talk about the lack of differences between short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy and other psychotherapies at posttreatment.

  • Further Evidence for Short-Term Psychodynamic Therapy in Major Depressive Disorder. Leichsenring, Falk; Steinert, Christiane // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Jan2017, Vol. 62 Issue 1, p75 

    A letter to the editor is presented concerning the Canadian Network for Mood and Anxiety Treatments guidelines which recommend using short-term psychodynamic therapy (STPP) as a second-line treatment for mental depression and recommendations that their grading of STPP be corrected for additional...

  • Rating Short-Term Psychodynamic Therapy for the Canadian Network for Mood and Anxiety Treatments Depression Guidelines. Parikh, Sagar V.; Quilty, Lena; Ravitz, Paula; Rosenbluth, Michael; Pavlova, Barbara; Grigoriadis, Sophie; Velyvis, Vytas; Uher, Rudolf; Kennedy, Sidney H.; Lam, Raymond W.; MacQueen, Glenda M.; Milev, Roumen; Ravindran, Arun V. // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Jan2017, Vol. 62 Issue 1, p77 

    A response is presented in regards to two letters to the editor concerning the establishment of ratings concerning short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy for treatment of major depressive disorders in the Canadian Network for Mood and Anxiety Treatment guidelines.

  • Is cognitive therapy effective?: discussion paper. Gelder, M. G. // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Nov1983, Vol. 76 Issue 11, p938 

    The article discusses the efficacy of cognitive therapy as a treatment depressive disorders. Cognitive therapy is a group of treatments which can be thought of as intermediated between behavior therapy and dynamic psychotherapy, which has three kinds including cognitive restructuring, cognitive...

  • Depressed patients' preferences for type of psychotherapy: a preliminary study. Yrondi, Antoine; Rieu, Julie; Massip, Claire; Bongard, Vanina; Schmitt, Laurent // Patient Preference & Adherence;Sep2015, Vol. 9, p1371 

    Background: The treatment recommendations for depressed patients by the American Psychiatric Association encourage a focus on the patient's preferences. The focus of this study was the preference of depressed inpatients for the type of psychotherapy. Methods: Twenty-nine subjects of both sexes...

  • Good Science or Good Business? Healy, David // Hastings Center Report;Mar/Apr2000, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p19 

    Focuses on the treatment of psychological disorders. Emergence of psychodynamic therapy; Developmental trajectory for the antidepressants determined by external event; Designation of Prozac as an antidepressant; Lifestyles and the disease model.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics