Illness causal beliefs in Turkish immigrants

Minas, Harry; Klimidis, Steven; Tuncer, Can
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007, Vol. 7, p34
Academic Journal
Background: People hold a wide variety of beliefs concerning the causes of illness. Such beliefs vary across cultures and, among immigrants, may be influenced by many factors, including level of acculturation, gender, level of education, and experience of illness and treatment. This study examines illness causal beliefs in Turkish-immigrants in Australia. Methods: Causal beliefs about somatic and mental illness were examined in a sample of 444 members of the Turkish population of Melbourne. The socio-demographic characteristics of the sample were broadly similar to those of the Melbourne Turkish community. Five issues were examined: the structure of causal beliefs; the relative frequency of natural, supernatural and metaphysical beliefs; ascription of somatic, mental, or both somatic and mental conditions to the various causes; the correlations of belief types with socio-demographic, modernizing and acculturation variables; and the relationship between causal beliefs and current illness. Results: Principal components analysis revealed two broad factors, accounting for 58 percent of the variation in scores on illness belief scales, distinctly interpretable as natural and supernatural beliefs. Second, beliefs in natural causes were more frequent than beliefs in supernatural causes. Third, some causal beliefs were commonly linked to both somatic and mental conditions while others were regarded as more specific to either somatic or mental disorders. Last, there was a range of correlations between endorsement of belief types and factors defining heterogeneity within the community, including with demographic factors, indicators of modernizing and acculturative processes, and the current presence of illness. Conclusion: Results supported the classification of causal beliefs proposed by Murdock, Wilson & Frederick, with a division into natural and supernatural causes. While belief in natural causes is more common, belief in supernatural causes persists despite modernizing and acculturative influences. Different types of causal beliefs are held in relation to somatic or mental illness, and a variety of apparently logically incompatible beliefs may be concurrently held. Illness causal beliefs are dynamic and are related to demographic, modernizing, and acculturative factors, and to the current presence of illness. Any assumption of uniformity of illness causal beliefs within a community, even one that is relatively culturally homogeneous, is likely to be misleading. A better understanding of the diversity, and determinants, of illness causal beliefs can be of value in improving our understanding of illness experience, the clinical process, and in developing more effective health services and population health strategies.


Related Articles

  • Prevalence and determinants of minor psychiatric disorder in Turkish immigrants living in The Netherlands. Bengi-Arslan, Leyla; Verhulst, Frank C.; Crijnen, Alfons A. M. // Social Psychiatry & Psychiatric Epidemiology;Mar2002, Vol. 37 Issue 3, p118 

    Background: The aim of this study was to assess the prevalence of and risk and protective factors for minor psychiatric disorder in a general population sample of Turkish immigrants living in the Netherlands.Methods: Minor psychiatric disorder was assessed with the...

  • Insides Spilling Out. DJURIC, GEORGE // Xavier Review;Fall2013, Vol. 33 Issue 2, p56 

    The article offers the author's view on delusion. The author states that delusion is a belief held with strong conviction despite the strong evidence to the contrary and are always pathological and may rise from distorted ways of people explaining life. The author mentions the shared psychosis...

  • NAHÇIVAN TÃœRK HALK Ä°NANISLARINDA MÄ°TOLOJÄ°K SAYILAR. Durbılmez, Bayram // Electronic Turkish Studies;2008, Vol. 3 Issue 7, p340 

    Giving meanings to words and commenting the meanings gave way to some symbolist, mystical and philosophical movements, which extend up to mythological ages used to think that everything has some relations to gods, spirits or demons, and they believed that the mystery of some numbers were asked...

  • What If? What If Millions Could Be Led To Healthy Lifestyle Practices By Bogus Arguments - Should We Make Them For The Good Of The People?  // Electronic Ardell Wellness Report (E-AWR);2/27/2009, Issue 476, p2 

    The author reflects whether there will be any good that can be achieved from senselessness. He states that even among individuals, who are better off enough to have sizable opportunity to advance a little from their primitive roots, things such as dismal beliefs are common. He cites that people...

  • The Nature and Purpose of Belief. Leicester, Jonathan // Journal of Mind & Behavior;Summer2008, Vol. 29 Issue 3, p217 

    This paper reviews intellectualistic, dispositional, and feeling or occurrent theories of belief. The feeling theory is favored. The purpose of belief is to guide action, not to indicate truth. Decisions about actions often have to be made quickly in the absence of evidence. Belief gives speed...

  • Mental Illness Beliefs Inventory: A Preliminary Validation of a Measure of the Level of Belief in the Medical Model of Mental Illness. Lewis, Steve J.; Laçasse, Jeffrey R.; Spaulding-Givens, Jennifer // Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry;2010, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p30 

    The article reports on the validation of the Mental Illness Beliefs Inventory (MIBI). The authors say the lack of objective criteria for mental disorders has led to their listed beliefs regarding mental disorder. They report that MIBI can be used to investigate various research questions. Citing...

  • Editorial. Leeming, David A. // Journal of Religion & Health;Fall2006, Vol. 45 Issue 3, p309 

    The article examines the connection between religion, spirituality and health. The relationship between traumatic stress and religion is explored. The role of religion and spirituality in the functional recovery of older adults from radical illness is discussed. The difference between mad and...

  • CHALLENGING EXPECTATIONS: HOW INDIVIDUALS WITH PSYCHIATRIC DISABILITIES FIND AND KEEP WORK. Killeen, Mary B.; O'day, Bonnie L. // Psychiatric Rehabilitation Journal;Fall2004, Vol. 28 Issue 2, p157 

    The results of this qualitative study involving in-depth interviews of 32 individuals with psychiatric disabilities document the importance of beliefs and expectations with regard to employment. Each of the participants were either currently receiving Social Security benefits or had received...

  • Spreading the Word: Religious Beliefs and the Evolution on Immigrant Congregations. Stevens, W. David // Sociology of Religion;Summer2004, Vol. 65 Issue 2, p121 

    Current models of change in immigrant churches posit that ethnic congregations become more acculturated in response to inter-generational conflicts. As second and third generation church members attempt to meet their own unique social needs, ethnic churches are forced to revise their goals and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics