Comparison of pain, cortisol levels, and psychological distress in women undergoing surgical termination of pregnancy under local anaesthesia versus intravenous sedation

Suliman, Sharain; Ericksen, Todd; Labuschgne, Peter; De Wit, Renee; Stein, Dan J.; Seedat, Soraya
January 2007
BMC Psychiatry;2007, Vol. 7, p24
Academic Journal
Background: The weight of evidence suggests that women who freely choose to terminate a pregnancy are unlikely to experience significant mental health risks, however some studies have documented psychological distress in the form of posttraumatic stress disorder and depression in the aftermath of termination. Choice of anaesthetic has been suggested as a determinant of outcome. This study compared the effects of local anaesthesia and intravenous sedation, administered for elective surgical termination, on outcomes of pain, cortisol, and psychological distress. Methods: 155 women were recruited from a private abortion clinic and state hospital (mean age: 25.4 ± 6.1 years) and assessed on various symptom domains, using both clinician-administered interviews and self-report measures just prior to termination, immediately post-procedure, and at 1 month and 3 months post-procedure. Morning salivary cortisol assays were collected prior to anaesthesia and termination. Results: The group who received local anaesthetic demonstrated higher baseline cortisol levels (mean = 4.7 vs 0.2), more dissociative symptoms immediately post-termination (mean = 14.7 vs 7.3), and higher levels of pain before (mean = 4.9 vs 3.0) and during the procedure (mean = 8.0 vs 4.4). However, in the longer-term (1 and 3 months), there were no significant differences in pain, psychological outcomes (PTSD, depression, self-esteem, state anxiety), or disability between the groups. More than 65% of the variance in PTSD symptoms at 3 months could be explained by baseline PTSD symptom severity and disability, and post-termination dissociative symptoms. Of interest was the finding that pre-procedural cortisol levels were positively correlated with PTSD symptoms at both 1 and 3 months. Conclusion: High rates of PTSD characterise women who have undergone surgical abortions (almost one fifth of the sample meet criteria for PTSD), with women who receive local anaesthetic experiencing more severe acute reactions. The choice of anesthetic, however, does not appear to impact on longer-term psychiatric outcomes or functional status.


Related Articles

  • Conscious Sedation is Well Accepted.  // Fertility Weekly;1/14/2002, p6 

    Determines the pain conception prior to, during, and after transvaginal recovery of immature oocytes for in vitro maturation by researchers in Denmark. Utilization of a visual analog scale; Performance of oocyte recovery; Correlation of pain conception to the number of punctures through the vagina.

  • Experience with Conscious sedation for Oocyte Retrieval in Nigeria. P. O., Fiebai; A. A., Ogunmokun; R. A., Ajayi // African Journal of Reproductive Health;Apr2008, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p30 

    Conscious sedation is the most common method of pain relief used during ultrasound-directed transvaginal follicle aspiration (UDFA) for in-vitro fertilisation/embryo transfer (IVF/ET). It is associated with minimal risks and facilitates early discharge following UDFA. The aim of this study was...

  • Intraoperative Sedation During Epidural Anesthesia: Dexmedetomidine Vs Midazolam. Celik, Melik; Koltka, Nursen; Cevik, Banu; Baba, Hayriye // Internet Journal of Anesthesiology;2008, Vol. 17 Issue 2, p13 

    Background: This study evaluated the ability of dexmedetomidine to provide sedation during epidural anesthesia compared with midazolam, examining the cardiorespiratory variables, analgesic requirements and side effects. Patients and Methods: Sixty patients undergoing inguinal herniorraphy under...

  • Pediatric Procedural Sedation. Lopez, Mark D.; Beltran, Gerald; Foltin, George // Pediatric Emergency Medicine Reports;Dec2008, Vol. 13 Issue 12, p145 

    The article examines the process of procedural sedation and agents that may be used in a variety of common scenarios. Originally called "conscious sedation" in 1992, the currently preferred term is procedural sedation which replaced conscious sedation to reflect the concept that effective...

  • Delayed Awakening From Anaesthesia. Saranagi, Sushmita // Internet Journal of Anesthesiology;2009, Vol. 19 Issue 1, p3 

    Ideally, on completion of surgery and anaesthesia, the patient should be awake or easily arousable, protecting the airway, maintaining adequate ventilation and with their pain under control. Time to emerge from anaesthesia is variable, and depends on many factors related to the patient, the type...

  • Trabeculectomía ab externo realizada bajo anestesia tópica con sedación consciente. Cortés-Gastélum, Marco Antonio; Paczka-Zapata, José Antonio; Mendoza-Barbosa, Jossué Fernando // Cirugia y Cirujanos;may/jun2011, Vol. 79 Issue 3, p233 

    Background: Ab externo trabeculectomy (AET) is the most common surgical procedure to treat glaucoma; topical anesthesia supplemented by conscious sedation is one of the diverse anesthetic methods to perform such type of surgery. The efficacy and safety of using topical anesthesia supplemented...

  • Conscious Sedation in Paediatric Dentistry. Sharma, Swati; Mahajan, Neeraj; Aggarwal, Rachit; Gupta, Vaibhav // JIDA: Journal of Indian Dental Association;Jan2016, Vol. 10 Issue 1, p10 

    Conscious sedation is a drug-induced depression of consciousness while the patient remains awake to respond to the verbal commands. Certain diagnostic and therapeutic procedures can be carried out under local anaesthesia with sedation and analgesia without any requirement for intervention of...

  • Effect of General Anaesthesia versus Conscious Sedation on Clinical and Procedural Outcome in Patients Undergoing Endovascular Stroke Treatment: A Matched-Pair Analysis. Rohde, Stefan; Schwarz, Stephan; Alexandrou, Maria; Reimann, Gernot; Ellerkmann, Richard Klaus; Politi, Maria; Kastrup, Andreas; Papanagiotou, Panagiotis // Cerebrovascular Diseases;2019, Vol. 48 Issue 1/2, p91 

    Introduction: General anaesthesia (GA) during mechanical thrombectomy (MT) might lead to an inferior clinical outcome compared to conscious sedation (CS). It was hypothesised that using CS might avoid a critical drop in cerebral perfusion, shorten the time of the intervention and therefore might...

  • Safe sedation in cardiology: guidance in a moving field. Piot, Olivier // Heart;Oct2015, Vol. 101 Issue 19, p1525 

    The article focuses on safe sedation and therapeutic developments in cardiology. Topics discussed include goals of sedation include achievement of patient immobility and relief of anxiety and pain; requirement of identical level of care in general anesthesia; and defining strategies for...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics