Is the HIV burden in India being overestimated?

Dandona, Lalit; Lakshmi, Vemu; Kumar, G. Anil; Dandona, Rakhi
January 2006
BMC Public Health;2006, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p1
Academic Journal
Background: The HIV burden estimate for India has a very wide plausibility range. A recent population-based study in a south Indian district demonstrated that the official method used in India to estimate HIV burden in the population, which directly extrapolates annual sentinel surveillance data from large public sector antenatal and sexually transmitted infection (STI) clinics, led to a 2-3 times higher estimate than that based on population-based data. Methods: We assessed the generalisability of the reasons found in the Guntur study for overestimation of HIV by the official sentinel surveillance based method: addition of substantial unnecessary HIV estimates from STI clinics, the common practice of referral of HIV positive/suspect patients by private practitioners to public hospitals, and a preferential use of public hospitals by lower socioeconomic strata. We derived conservative correction factors for the sentinel surveillance data and titrated these to the four major HIV states in India (Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu), and examined the impact on the overall HIV estimate for India. Results: HIV data from STI clinics are not used elsewhere in the world as a component of HIV burden estimation in generalised epidemics, and the Guntur study verified that this was unnecessary. The referral of HIV positive/suspect patients from the private to the public sector is a widespread phenomenon in India, which is likely causing an upward distortion in HIV estimates from sentinel surveillance in other parts of India as well. Analysis of data from the nationwide Reproductive and Child Health Survey revealed that lower socioeconomic strata were over-represented among women seeking antenatal care at public hospitals in all major south Indian states, similar to the trend seen in the Guntur study. Application of conservative correction factors derived from the Guntur study reduced the 2005 official sentinel surveillance based HIV estimate of 3.7 million 15-49 years old persons in the four major states to 1.5-2.0 million, which would drop the official total estimate of 5.2 million 15-49 years old persons with HIV in India to 3-3.5 million. Conclusion: Plausible and cautious extrapolation of the trends seen in a recent large and rigorous population-based study of HIV in a south Indian district suggests that India is likely grossly overestimating its HIV burden with the current official sentinel surveillance based method. This method needs revision.


Related Articles

  • Infection with Human Immunodeficiency Virus, an Epidemic Out of Control: Personal Reflections. Sande, Merle A. // Journal of Infectious Diseases;3/15/99 Supplement 2, Vol. 179, pS387 

    Examines the worldwide problem of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. Estimated number of persons living with HIV infection at the end of 1997; Origin of HIV; Successful attempts to intervene in the transmission of HIV.

  • CE/CME questions.  // AIDS Alert;Jun2008, Vol. 23 Issue 6, p71 

    A quiz about HIV infection is presented.

  • Plasma HIV viral load in patients with hemophilia and late-stage HIV Disease: A measure of... Engels, Eric A.; Rosenberg, Philip S. // Annals of Internal Medicine;08/17/99, Vol. 131 Issue 4, p256 

    Discusses the relationship between plasma HIV viral load and subsequent risk for disease progression in patients with late-stage HIV disease. HIV viral load as strong predictor of AIDS-related illness; Linear relation between viral load and risk for AIDS-related illness; Viral load prediction...

  • CE/CME questions.  // AIDS Alert;Apr2007, Vol. 22 Issue 4, p47 

    A quiz regarding human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is presented.

  • Discrimination fuels rise of HIV in Philippines.  // Filipino Post;7/12/2012, p10 

    The article reports on the increasing numbers of HIV cases in the Philippines which is attributed to the discrimination against homosexuals and people who are already infected with HIV.

  • Unfolding Story. Meyer, Charles R. // Minnesota Medicine; 

    The article discusses various reports published within the issue including one on the care of geriatric HIV patients, one on the potential decrease of incidents rate in sexually transmitted HIV in the U.S., and one on disease inferno in Africa and other parts of the Third World.

  • Effect of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) Type 1 Envelope Subtypes A and D on Disease Progression in a Large Cohort of HIV-1-Positive Persons in Uganda. Kaleebu, Pontiano; French, Neil; Mahe, Cedric; Yirell, David; Watera, Christine; Lyagoba, Fred; Nakiyingi, Jessica; Rutebemberwa, Alleluiah; Morgan, Dilys; Weber, Jonathan; Gilks, Charles; Whitworth, Jimmy // Journal of Infectious Diseases;5/1/2002, Vol. 185 Issue 9, p1244 

    The effect of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) type I envelope subtypes A and D on disease progression was investigated in 1045 adults in Uganda. At enrollment and every 6 months, a clinical history, examination, and laboratory investigations that included CD4 cell counts were done. HIV-1...

  • Prevalence of Infection with Human Immunodeficiency Virus in East Timor. Chevalier, Benoit; Carmoi, Thierry; Sagui, Emmanuel; Pierre, Claude // Clinical Infectious Diseases;3/15/2001, Vol. 32 Issue 6, p991 

    Focuses on a study which determined the prevalence of HIV infection in East Timor, Indonesia. Results; Implications of the results.

  • Introduction of HIV-2 and multiple HIV-1 subtypes to Lebanon. Pieniazek, Danuta; Hu, Dale J.; Fridlund, Carol; Schable, Charles; Rayfield, Mark A.; Heneine, Walid; Baggs, James; Matar, Ghassan M.; Abdelnoor, Alexander M.; Mokhbat, Jacques E.; Uwaydah, Marwan; Bizri, Abdul Rahman; Ramos, Artur; Janini, Luiz M.; Tanuri, Amilcar; Heyndrickx, Leo // Emerging Infectious Diseases;Oct-Dec98, Vol. 4 Issue 4, p649 

    Analyzes HIV genetic variability, phylogenetic relationships, and transmission dynamics in 26 HIV-infected patients from Lebanon. Molecular characteristics of HIV infection; Classification of the strains; Epidemiologic analysis of the patients' travel histories and behavioral risks.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics