Risk-adjusted cesarean section rates for the assessment of physician performance in Taiwan: a population-based study

Chao-Hsiun Tang; Han-I Wang; Chun-Sen Hsu; Hung-Wen Su; Mei-Ju Chen; Herng-Ching Lin
January 2006
BMC Public Health;2006, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p246
Academic Journal
Background: Over the past decade, about one-third of all births nationwide in Taiwan were delivered by cesarean section (CS). Previous studies in the US and Europe have documented the need for risk adjustment for fairer comparisons among providers. In this study, we set out to determine the impact that adjustment for patient-specific risk factors has on CS among different physicians in Taiwan. Methods: There were 172,511 live births which occurred in either hospitals or obstetrics/gynecology clinics between 1 January and 31 December 2003, and for whom birth certificate data could be linked with National Health Insurance (NHI) claims data, available as the sample for this study. Physicians were divided into four equivalent groups based upon the quartile distribution of their crude (actual) CS rates. Stepwise logistic regressions were conducted to develop a predictive model and to determine the expected (risk-adjusted) CS rate and 95% confidence interval (CI) for each physician. The actual rates were then compared with the expected CS rates to see the proportion of physicians whose actual rates were below, within, or above the predicted CI in each quartile. Results: The proportion of physicians whose CS rates were above the predicted CI increased as the quartile moved to the higher level. However, more than half of the physicians whose actual rates were higher than the predicted CI were not in the highest quartile. Conversely, there were some physicians (40 of 258 physicians) in the highest quartile who were actually providing obstetric care that was appropriate to the risk. When a stricter standard was applied to the assessment of physician performance by excluding physicians in quartile 4 for predicting CS rates, as many as 60% of physicians were found to have higher CS rates than the predicted CI, and indeed, the CS rates of no physicians in either quartile 3 or quartile 4 were below the predicted CI. Conclusion: Overall, our study found that the comparison of unadjusted CS rates might not provide a valid reflection of the quality of obstetric care delivered by physicians, and may ultimately lead to biased judgments by purchasers. Our study has also shown that when we changed the standard of quality assessment, the evaluation results also changed.


Related Articles

  • Does medical insurance type (private vs public) influence the physician's decision to perform Caesarean delivery? Movsas, Tammy Z.; Wells, Eden; Mongoven, Ann; Grigorescu, Violanda // Journal of Medical Ethics;Aug2012, Vol. 38 Issue 8, p470 

    Introduction US data reveal a Caesarean rate discrepancy between insured and uninsured patients, with the C-section rate highest among the privately insured. The data have prompted concern that financial incentives associated with insurance status might influence American physicians' decisions...

  • Fee Exemption for Maternal Care in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Review of 11 Countries and Lessons for the Region. Richard, Fabienne; Antony, Matthieu; Witter, Sophie; Kelley, Allison; Sieleunou, Isidore; Kafando, Yamba; Meessen, Bruno // Global Health Governance;Summer2013, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p1 

    Several countries have recently introduced maternal health care fee exemptions as a quick win approach to reach MDG 5 goals. It has also been argued that these policies were relevant first steps towards universal health coverage (UHC). The scope and contents of the benefits package covered by...

  • The other end of the stethoscope. Inlander, Charles B. // People's Medical Society Newsletter;Feb94, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p2 

    Opinion. Argues why President Bill Clinton's health reform proposals will not work. Benefits of a single-payer system; Suggestion that Hillary Rodham Clinton did little to seek opinion of the consumer on health-care issues; Bias which the Clinton plan reflects; Why the single-payer system did...

  • MedPAC: Cut therapy caps 33%, hike audits. Berklan, James M. // McKnight's Long-Term Care News;Dec2012, Vol. 33 Issue 12, p3 

    The article reports that Medicare Payment Advisory Commission has recommended that the U.S. Congress drop the annual allowable limits for Medicare Outpatient Part B payments by one-third. It would mean caps at 1,270 dollars down from 1,880 dollars.

  • Türkiye'de Obstetrik Anestezi Uygulamalarindaki DeÄŸiÅŸimin DeÄŸerlendirilmesi. Töre, Gülbin; Gurbet, Alp; Şahin, Şükran; Türker, Gürkan; Yavaşcaoğlu, Belgin; Korkmaz, Serdar // Journal of the Turkish Anaesthesiology & Intensive Care Society ;Mar2009, Vol. 37 Issue 2, p86 

    Aim: The role of anaesthesiologists in obstetric practices was increased due to the advances in medicine, advanced age for pregnancy and coexisting diseases. In this study, the Turkish obstetric anaesthesia practice data of 1998 was compared with the results of the survey made in 2005, to find...

  • Prior Cesarean Delivery in Women with Secondary Tubal Infertility. Wolf, Marsha E.; Daling, Janet R.; Voigt, Lynda F. // American Journal of Public Health;Nov90, Vol. 80 Issue 11, p1382 

    The history of cesarean delivery was evaluated in a population-bused case-control study of secondary infertility in King County, Washington, Sixty-one married women diagnosed with secondary infertility due to tubal problems who had a previous viable pregnancy were compared to 343 married women...

  • Experience of childbirth in first-time mothers of advanced age - a Norwegian population-based study. Aasheim, Vigdis; Waldenström, Ulla; Rasmussen, Svein; Schytt, Erica // BMC Pregnancy & Childbirth;2013, Vol. 13 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Delaying the first childbirth to an advanced age has increased significantly during the last decades, but little is known about older first time mothers' experience of childbirth. This study investigates the associations between advanced maternal age in primiparous women and the...

  • Primary Caesarean Section And Fetal Outcome Amongst Nulliparous Women At A Health Facility In Southern Nigeria. Utoo, B.; Utoo, P. // Internet Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics;2013, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p1 

    Background: Caesarean section in nulliparous women is of serious import because it significantly affects the Obstetric future of the woman. However, Caesarean section could be a crucial intervention measure that will enhance favourable maternal and fetal outcome. Objective: To assess the primary...

  • A comparison of trends in caesarean section rates in former communist (transition) countries and other European countries. Katikireddi, Srinivasa V.; Gorman, Dermot R.; Leyland, Alastair H. // European Journal of Public Health;Jun2013, Vol. 23 Issue 3, p381 

    Caesarean section rates are rising across Europe, and concerns exist that increases are not clinically indicated. Societal, cultural and health system factors have been identified as influential. Former communist (transition) countries have experienced radical changes in these potential...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics