Political dynamics promoting the incremental regulation of secondhand smoke: a case study of New South Wales, Australia

Bryan-Jones, Katherine; Chapman, Simon
January 2006
BMC Public Health;2006, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p192
Academic Journal
Background: The history of governmental responses to the accumulation of scientific evidence about the harms of secondhand smoke (SHS) presents an intriguing case study of incremental public health policy development. Australia has long been considered a world-leader in progressive tobacco control policies, but in the last decade has fallen behind other jurisdictions in introducing SHS legislation that protects all workers. Bars, clubs and pubs remain the only public indoor spaces where smoking is legally permitted, despite SHS exposure in the hospitality industry being higher and affecting more people than in any other setting after domestic exposure. This paper examines the political dynamics that have shaped this incremental approach to SHS. Methods: In-depth interviews with 21 key stakeholders in the state of New South Wales (NSW), including politicians, their advisors, health officials and tobacco control advocates, were conducted and subjected to thematic content analysis. Interviewees' comments provided insights into the dynamics surrounding the debates and outcomes of SHS legislative attempts and the current political environment, and about how to progress SHS legislation. Results: SHS restrictions have been delayed by several broad factors: the influence of industry groups successfully opposing regulation; issue wear-out; and political perceptions that there is not a salient constituency demanding that smoking be banned in bars and clubs. Interviewees also provided suggestions of strategies that advocates might utilise to best overcome the current political inertia of incremental compromises and achieve timely comprehensive smoking bans. Conclusion: Advocates concerned to shorten the duration of incremental endgames must continue to insist that governments address SHS fundamentally as a health issue rather than making political concessions to industry groups, and should broaden and amplify community voices calling on governments to finish the job. Publicity to the growing number of state and national governments that have successfully implemented total bans over the past decade is likely to make incrementalism an increasingly unattractive political option.


Related Articles

  • Smoke-free air policies: past, present and future. Hyland, Andrew; Barnoya, Joaquin; Corral, Juan E. // Tobacco Control;Mar2012, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p154 

    Smoke-free policies have been an important tobacco control intervention. As recently as 20 years ago, few communities required workplaces and hospitality venues to be smoke-free, but today approximately 11% of the world's population live in countries with laws that require these places to be...

  • Beyond 'Reach': Evaluating a Smoke-Free Homes Social Marketing Campaign. Smith, P. B.; MacQuarrie, C. R.; Herbert, R. J.; Begley, L. H. // International Journal of Health Promotion & Education;2009, Vol. 47 Issue 2, p57 

    Environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) is an important public health risk, with children especially vulnerable to its adverse effects. This study evaluates an evidence-based social marketing and community engagement campaign designed to address children's exposure to ETS in the home. A pre- and...

  • What if the government refuses to ban smoking in public places? Rao, Jammi N. // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);9/25/2004, Vol. 329 Issue 7468, p749 

    Presents an opinion on the need for the British government to pass laws banning smoking in public areas. How Ireland is faring after the adoption of such a law; Statistics from New York City and Norway; Disbelief of the author that the government would not institute a ban in the face of all the...

  • The effect of smoke-free policies on hospitality industry revenues in Cyprus: an econometric approach. Talias, Michael A.; Savva, Christos S.; Soteriades, Elpidoforos S.; Lazuras, Lambros // Tobacco Control;Oct2015, Vol. 24 Issue e3, pe199 

    Objective Smoke-free policies aiming to improve quality of indoor air and significantly reduce exposure to secondhand smoke in the hospitality industry are faced with strong opposition from the tobacco industry and hospitality venue owners claiming that they lead to reductions of revenues. The...

  • Is the smoke-free protections glass half full or half empty? Hyland, Andrew // Tobacco Control;Oct2015, Vol. 24 Issue e3, pe178 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses reports within the issue on topics including world progress towards providing smoke-free environments, how non-cigarette products that are burned can pollute the air and the possibility of implementing a comprehensive nationwide...

  • An exploration of the theoretical concepts policy windows and policy entrepreneurs at the Swedish public health arena. GULDBRANDSSON, KARIN; FOSSUM, BJÖOuml;RN // Health Promotion International;Dec2009, Vol. 24 Issue 4, p434 

    In John Kingdon's Policy Streams Approach policy formation is described as the result of the flow of three ‘streams’, the problem stream, the policy stream and the politics stream. When these streams couple, a policy window opens which facilitate policy change. Actors who promote...

  • Conservation of resources theory and research use in health systems. Alvaro, Celeste; Lyons, Renée F.; Warner, Grace; Hobfoll, Stevan E.; Martens, Patricia J.; Labonté, Ronald; Brown, Richard E. // Implementation Science;2010, Vol. 5, p79 

    Background: Health systems face challenges in using research evidence to improve policy and practice. These challenges are particularly evident in small and poorly resourced health systems, which are often in locations (in Canada and globally) with poorer health status. Although organizational...

  • Frameworks for Understanding Dilemmas of Health Care in a Globalized World: A Case Study of Reproductive Health Policies in Peru. Miranda, J. Jaime; Yamin, Alicia Ely // Politics & Ethics Review;2005, Vol. 1 Issue 2, p177 

    The article presents a case study that looks into the paradigm of health policies in Peru. Health indicators of Peru like mortality rate as well as population control initiatives from 1995-1998 are discussed. Integral concepts that need to be considered in health policies such as human rights,...

  • Estimating the Economic Impact of Secondhand Smoke on the Health of a Community. Zollinger, Terrell W.; Saywell Jr., Robert M.; Overgaard, Amanda D.; Jay, Stephen J.; Holloway, Angela M.; Cummings, Sandra F. // American Journal of Health Promotion;Jan/Feb2004, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p232 

    Purpose. This study provides a model to estimate the health-related costs of secondhand smoke exposure at a community level. Model Development. Costs of secondhand smoke-related mortality and morbidity were estimated using national attributable risk values for diseases that are causally related...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics