Is there a "Scottish effect" for self reports of health? Individual level analysis of the 2001 UK census

Popham, Frank
January 2006
BMC Public Health;2006, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p191
Academic Journal
Background: Scotland's overall health record is comparatively poor for a Western European country, particularly amongst people of working age. A number of previous studies have explored why this might be the case by comparing mortality in Scotland with England and Wales. A study in the 1980s showed that the higher prevalence of deprivation in Scotland accounted for Scotland's excess mortality risk. However, more recent studies suggest that deprivation now explains less of this excess. This has led to the suggestion that there is a yet unidentified "Scottish effect" contributing to Scotland's mortality excess. Recent research has also suggested that there could be an unidentified effect influencing Scotland's higher rate of heart disease. This paper explores whether there is also an unexplained Scottish excess, relative to England, in self reports of poor health. Methods: Data came from the individual Sample of Anonymised Records, a 3% random sample of the 2001 UK census. Using logistic regression models, self reports of health (limiting illness and general health) from the working age populations (aged 25 to 64) of Scotland and England were compared. Account was taken of people's country of birth. Stratified analysis by employment status allowed further exploration of Scotland's excess. Results: People born and living in Scotland reported higher levels of poor general health and limiting illness compared to people born and living in England. Adjustment for socioeconomic position and employment status largely explained the higher rates. In the stratified analysis a Scottish excess was seen only amongst the economically inactive born and living in Scotland. For those in employment, people born and living in Scotland actually had slightly lower odds of reporting poor general health and limiting illness than people born and living in England. Conclusion: This analysis suggests that higher rates of poor self reported health in Scotland can be explained by differences in employment and socioeconomic position and so there is unlikely to be an unidentified "Scottish effect" for self reports of health. Scotland's excess of poor general health and limiting illness amongst the economically inactive is probably attributable to its economic and employment history.


Related Articles

  • Risk factors of one year increment of coronary calcifications and survival in hemodialysis patients. Coen, Giorgio; Pierantozzi, Andrea; Spizzichino, Daniele; Sardella, Daniela; Mantella, Daniela; Manni, Micaela; Pellegrino, Luigi; Romagnoli, Andrea; Pacifici, Roberta; Zuccaro, Piergiorgio; DiGiulio, Salvatore // BMC Nephrology;2010, Vol. 11, p10 

    Background: Heart and coronary calcifications in hemodialysis patients are of very common occurrence and linked to cardiovascular events and mortality. Several studies have been published with similar results. Most of them were mainly cross-sectional and some of the prospective protocols were...

  • ADVERSE SOCIAL COMPARISON PROCESSES AND NEGATIVE SELF-FEELINGS: A TEST OF ALTERNATIVE MODELS. Stiles, Beverly L.; Kaplan, Howard B. // Social Behavior & Personality: an international journal;2004, Vol. 32 Issue 1, p31 

    Theoretically informed models are estimated that specify the direction of the relationship between social comparisons and negative self-feelings. The data are from three waves of an ongoing longitudinal study of adaptations to stress. Subjects are individuals who were tested in their middle...

  • Prevalence and Extent of Obstructive Coronary Artery Disease Among Patients Undergoing Elective Coronary Catheterization in New York State and Ontario. Ko, Dennis T.; Tu, Jack V.; Austin, Peter C.; Wijeysundera, Harindra C.; Samadashvili, Zaza; Helen Guo; Cantor, Warren J.; Hannan, Edward L. // JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association;7/10/2013, Vol. 310 Issue 2, p163 

    IMPORTANCE: Prior studies have shown that physicians in New York State (New York) perform twice as many cardiac catheterizations per capita as those in Ontario for stable patients. However, the role of patient selection in these findings and their implications for detection of obstructive...

  • Derivation and validation of a risk-factor model for detection of oral potentially malignant disorders in populations with high prevalence. Amarasinghe, H. K.; Johnson, N. W.; Lalloo, R.; Kumaraarachchi, M.; Warnakulasuriya, S. // British Journal of Cancer;7/27/2010, Vol. 103 Issue 3, p303 

    Background:Oral and pharyngeal cancers constitute the sixth most common type of cancer globally, with high morbidity and mortality. In many countries, most cases of oral cancer arise from long-standing, pre-existing lesions, yet advanced malignancies prevail. A new approach to early detection is...

  • Quantifying the Impact of Deprivation on Preterm Births: A Retrospective Cohort Study. Taylor-Robinson, David; Agarwal, Umber; Diggle, Peter J.; Platt, Mary Jane; Yoxall, Bill; Alfirevic, Zarko // PLoS ONE;2011, Vol. 6 Issue 8, p1 

    Background: Social deprivation is associated with higher rates of preterm birth and subsequent infant mortality. Our objective was to identify risk factors for preterm birth in the UK's largest maternity unit, with a particular focus on social deprivation, and related factors....

  • The effect of sociodemographic factors on infant mortality according to cause of death: a birth cohort in Seoul, Korea, 1999-2003. Son, Ji-Young; Lee, Jong-Tae // International Journal of Public Health;Feb2011, Vol. 56 Issue 1, p7 

    Objectives: The aim of this study was to examine the effect of socioeconomic status and demographic factors on infant mortality, classified by cause of death, in a group of children born in Seoul, Korea during 1999-2003. Methods: Linked infant birth and death data were collected from the Korea...

  • Screen Time Increases Risk of Overweight and Obesity in Active and Inactive 9-Year-Old Irish Children: A Cross Sectional Analysis. Lane, Aoife; Harrison, Michael; Murphy, Niamh // Journal of Physical Activity & Health;Jul2014, Vol. 11 Issue 5, p985 

    Background: Independent associations between screen time (ST)/physical activity (PA) and overweight (OW)/obesity have been demonstrated but little research exists on the role of ST among sufficiently active children. Purpose: To examine the combined influence of ST and PA on risk of OW/obesity...

  • Prevalence of physical inactivity in nine rural INDEPTH Health and Demographic Surveillance Systems in five Asian countries. Ng, Nawi; Hakimi, Mohammad; Van Minh, Hoang; Juvekar, Sanjay; Razzaque, Abdur; Ashraf, Ali; Ahmed, Syed Masud; Kanungsukkasem, Uraiwan; Soonthornthada, Kusol; Bich, Tran Huu // Global Health Action;2009, Vol. 2 Issue 1, p44 

    Background: Physical inactivity leads to higher morbidity and mortality from chronic non-communicable diseases (NCDs) such as stroke and heart disease. In high income countries, studies have measured the population level of physical activity, but comparable data are lacking from most low and...

  • Incidence and Risk Factors of Prolonged QTc Interval in Type 1 Diabetes. Giunti, Sara; Bruno, Graziella; Lillaz, Emma; Gruden, Gabriella; Lolli, Valentina; Chaturvedi, Nish; Fuller, John H.; Veglio, Massimo; Cavallo-Perin, Paolo // Diabetes Care;Aug2007, Vol. 30 Issue 8, p2057 

    OBJECTIVE -- Corrected QT (QTc) prolongation is predictive of cardiovascular mortality in both the general and diabetic populations. As part of the EURODIAB Prospective Complication Study, we have assessed the 7-year incidence and risk factors of prolonged QTc in people with type 1 diabetes....


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics