Health system barriers to strengthening vaccine-preventable disease surveillance and response in the context of decentralization: evidence from Georgia

Hotchkiss, David R.; Eisele, Thomas P.; Djibuti, Mamuka; Silvestre, Eva A.; Rukhadze, Natia
January 2006
BMC Public Health;2006, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p175
Academic Journal
Background: A critical challenge in the health sector in developing countries is to ensure the quality and effectiveness of surveillance and public health response in an environment of decentralization. In Georgia, a country where there has been extensive decentralization of public health responsibilities over the last decade, an intervention was recently piloted to strengthen district-level local vaccine-preventable disease surveillance and response activities through improved capacity to analyze and use routinely collected data. The purpose of the study is 1) to assess the effectiveness of the intervention on motivation and perceived capacity to analyze and use information at the district-level, and 2) to assess the role that individual- and system-level factors play in influencing the effectiveness of the intervention. Methods: A pre-post quasi-experimental research design is used for the quantitative evaluation. Data come from a baseline and two follow-up surveys of district-level health staff in 12 intervention and 3 control Center of Public Health (CPH) offices. These data were supplemented by record reviews in CPH offices as well as focus group discussions among CPH and health facility staff. Results: The results of the study suggest that a number of expected improvements in perceived data availability and analysis occurred following the implementation of the intervention package, and that these improvements in analysis could be attributable to the intervention package. However, the study results also suggest that there exist several health systems barriers that constrained the effectiveness of the intervention in influencing the availability of data, analysis and response. Conclusion: To strengthen surveillance and response systems in Georgia, as well as in other countries, donor, governments, and other stakeholders should consider how health systems factors influence investments to improve the availability of data, analysis, and response. Linking the intervention to broader health sector reforms in management processes and organizational culture will be critical to ensure that efforts designed to promote evidence-based decision-making are successful, especially as they are scaled up to the national level.


Related Articles

  • GPs consulted? Yeah right! Wynyard, Ruth // New Zealand Doctor;4/25/2007, p2 

    The article discusses general physicians' lack of involvement in the laboratory changes in New Zealand. Doctor Johann Coetze is frustrated by the lack of consultation and criticizes a policy that requires doctors to explain why they need to order a blood test. Physicians note that consulting...

  • The market has failed. Godlee, Fiona // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);12/1/2007, Vol. 335 Issue 7630, p1102 

    The author reflects on the use of markets in health care in Great Britain. She suggests that markets fail when information is not transferred properly and because pharmaceutical providers have the power to influence price or quantity of drugs. She argues that even the most perfect healthcare...

  • The Dilemmas of Child Health Care in Tropical Africa. Guillozet, Noel // Clinical Pediatrics;Jun1976, Vol. 15 Issue 6, p530 

    This article looks into the health care problems in Cameroon. In many ways, the health problems of Cameroon typify the health care problems facing most countries of the tropical Third World in Africa and of Central and South America. The country has fewer than 250 practicing physicians, and at...

  • A Tool for Health Planners. Shapiro, Sam // American Journal of Public Health;Sep77, Vol. 67 Issue 9, p816 

    The article presents a report entitled "Statistical Notes for Health Planners, a cooperative effort of the National Center for Health Statistics and the Bureau of Health Planning and Resources Development in the U.S. The report is systematically probing into the nature of mortality statistics,...

  • CWF Edits to Be Revised for SNF Consolidated Billing Payments.  // hfm (Healthcare Financial Management);Dec2004, Vol. 58 Issue 12, p14 

    Reports on planned revisions to the common working file (CWF) edits in the U.S. Impact of policy alterations on consolidated billing payments of skilled nursing facility in the U.S. Assessment on present CWF edits.

  • Unintended consequences. Chapman, Jake // Nursing Management - UK;Jul2005, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p30 

    Explains the reason behind the occurrence of unintended consequences from many medical policies aimed at improving public health services and suggests ways to avoid them. Difference between modern systems thinking and mechanistic thinking implicit in scientific management and...

  • More Than the Flu. Kettl, Donald F. // Governing;Dec2004, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p13 

    Focuses on the impact of the shortage of influenza vaccine supply on the public health system in the U.S. Condition of the nation's public health system as of December 2004; Factors that contributed to the shortage of vaccine in the country; Implications of the spread of bird flu in Asia for...

  • Starting down the road to targets in health: the case of Italy. France, George; Taroni, Francesco // European Journal of Public Health;2000, Vol. 10 Issue suppl_4, p25 

    Italy adopted a health targets strategy in 1998 covering five key areas of population health and involving 100 targets. It has already become clear that how the health targets are ‘managed’ will be crucial to the strategy's success. Italy has a national health service but also has a...

  • Targets for health in Germany. Wismar, Matthias; Busse, Reinhard // European Journal of Public Health;2000, Vol. 10 Issue suppl_4, p38 

    Background: Health care policy in Germany is dominated by economic (cost-containment), institutional and supply issues. Public health in general is low on the political agenda with much scope for improvement. Better health as an objective in itself has by and large been a neglected issue. Health...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics