Attribution of physical complaints to the air disaster in Amsterdam by exposed rescue workers: an epidemiological study using historic cohorts

Slottje, Pauline; Smidt, Nynke; Twisk, Jos W. R.; Huizink, Anja C.; Witteveen, Anke B.; van Mechelen, Willem; Smid, Tjabe
January 2006
BMC Public Health;2006, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p142
Academic Journal
Background: In 1992 a cargo aircraft crashed into a residential area of Amsterdam. A troublesome aftermath followed, with rumors on potential toxic exposures and health consequences. Health concerns remained even though no excess morbidity was predicted in retrospective risk evaluations. This study aimed to assess to what extent the rescue workers attribute long-term physical complaints to this disaster, including its aftermath, and to examine associations between such attribution and types of exposure and background variables. Methods: Historic cohort study that collected questionnaire data on occupational disaster exposure, attribution of physical complaints, and background variables on average 8.5 years post-disaster. For the present study the workers who were exposed to the disaster were selected from the historic cohort, i.e. the professional firefighters (n = 334), police officers (n = 834), and accident and wreckage investigators (n = 241) who performed disaster-related tasks. Results: Across the three occupational groups, a consistent percentage (ranging from 43% to 49%) of exposed workers with long-term physical complaints attributed these to the disaster, including its aftermath. Those with more physical complaints attributed these to a stronger degree. Multivariate logistic regression analyses showed that attribution was significantly more often reported by firefighters who rescued people, and by police officers who reported the identification and recovery of or search for victims and human remains, clean-up, or security and surveillance of the disaster area; who witnessed the immediate disaster scene; who had a close one affected by the disaster; and who perceived the disaster as the worst thing that ever happened to them. Age, sex and educational level were not significantly associated with attribution. Conclusion: This study provides further cross-sectional evidence for the role of causal attribution in post-disaster subjective physical health problems. After on average 8.5 years, almost a third (32%) of all the exposed workers, and almost half (45%) of the exposed workers with physical complaints, attributed these complaints to the disaster, including its aftermath. The similarity of the results across the occupational groups suggests a general rather than an occupation-specific attribution process. Longitudinal studies are needed to determine whether causal disaster attribution leads to persistence of post-disaster complaints and health care utilization.


Related Articles

  • 2 Doctor's mercy dash. Williams, Sue // Australian Women's Weekly;Apr2007, Vol. 77 Issue 4, p44 

    This article reports on the involvement of plastic surgeon Fiona Wood with Australia's high-level rapid response team. She had flown into Yogyakarta, Indonesia as part of the Australian Health Protection Committee, a group of specialists on call to save lives in tragedies throughout Australia...

  • Epidemiological disaster research: the necessity to include representative samples of the involved disaster workers. Experience from the epidemiological study air disaster Amsterdam - ESADA. Huizink, Anja C.; Smidt, Nynke; Twisk, Jos W. R.; Slottje, Pauline; Smid, Tjabe // Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health;Oct2006, Vol. 60 Issue 10, p887 

    Objective: To study whether the methods used to select participants in research on prevalence rates of the health effects of exposure to a disaster may cause bias. This study compared background characteristics, disaster exposure, and complaints reported by (1) police officers who participated...

  • Flight of L'Oiseau Blanc. A.M.H.S. // Archaeology;Mar/Apr94, Vol. 47 Issue 2, p20 

    Reports on the discovery of a metal fragment believed to be from the Oiseau Blanc (the White Bird) which disappeared during an attempted first nonstop flight between Paris and New York in a pond in southeastern Newfoundland. Disappearance of the plane's crew; Search for additional evidence.

  • Air safety: erosion of confidence. O'Lone, R.G.; North, D.M. // Aviation Week & Space Technology;8/24/87, Vol. 127 Issue 8, p18 

    The Detroit crash of Northwest Airlines MD-82 which killed 155 people, along with a series of near-midair collisions, has subjected US air safety to renewed scrutiny. The preliminary investigation of the August 16 crash is centering on the performance of a veteran crew, and raises questions...

  • Northwest wreckage confirms flaps retracted.. Ott, J. // Aviation Week & Space Technology;8/31/1987, Vol. 127 Issue 9, p32 

    Examination of flap mechanisms recovered from the wreckage of Northwest Airlines Flight 255 which crashed August 16 indicates the flaps on the McDonnell Douglas MD-82 were retracted during takeoff. The digital flight recorder provides further evidence that the flaps were retracted, as well as...

  • Inquiry finds crash was inevitable after... Greeley Jr., B.M. // Aviation Week & Space Technology;1/25/88, Vol. 128 Issue 4, p20 

    An investigation into the September 28 crash of a US Air Force/Rockwell B-1B found the crash was inevitable after a bird strike started a fire that ignited hydraulic systems necessary to control the aircraft. Three members of the six-man crew ejected safely but the other three were killed. ...

  • Safety of aging aircraft undergoes... O'Lone, R.G.; Ott, J. // Aviation Week & Space Technology;5/16/1988, Vol. 128 Issue 20, p16 

    Potentially broader implications of the structural failure of an Aloha Airlines Boeing 737 over the Hawaiian Islands on April 28 are being closely scrutinized by several government agencies. The airline has retired all four of its high-cycle Boeing 737 twin jets, and an industry-wide...

  • Senate leaders back captain, but question... Mann, P. // Aviation Week & Space Technology;7/11/1988, Vol. 129 Issue 2, p20 

    Discusses reactions of Senate defense leaders to the operational decisions taken by the USS Vincennes commander in the Iranair shootdown. Senators back the commander but question the advisability of deploying blue-water vessels in the Persian Gulf's narrow confines. Reactions; US actions in...

  • A320 crash inquiry finds no aircraft... Lenorovitz, J.M. // Aviation Week & Space Technology;8/8/1988, Vol. 129 Issue 6, p28 

    Discusses the findings of a preliminary investigation into June crash of an Air France A320 during an air show flyby. The report says there was no sign of malfunction on board the aircraft, and criticizes Air France for allowing passengers on the aircraft during an air show demonstration. ...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics