Waterborne microbial risk assessment : a population-based dose-response function for Giardia spp. (E.MI.R.A study)

Zmirou-Navier, D.; Gofti-Laroche, L.; Hartemann, Ph.
January 2006
BMC Public Health;2006, Vol. 6, p1
Academic Journal
Background: Dose-response parameters based on clinical challenges are frequently used to assess the health impact of protozoa in drinking water. We compare the risk estimates associated with Giardia in drinking water derived from the dose-response parameter published in the literature and the incidence of acute digestive conditions (ADC) measured in the framework of an epidemiological study in a general population. Methods: The study combined a daily follow-up of digestive morbidity among a panel of 544 volunteers and a microbiological surveillance of tap water. The relationship between incidence of ADC and concentrations of Giardia cysts was modeled with Generalized Estimating Equations, adjusting on community, age, tap water intake, presence of bacterial indicators, and genetic markers of viruses. The quantitative estimate of Giardia dose was the product of the declared amount of drinking water intake (in L) by the logarithm of cysts concentrations. Results: The Odds Ratio for one unit of dose [OR = 1.76 (95% CI: 1.21, 2.55)] showed a very good consistency with the risk assessment estimate computed after the literature dose-response, provided application of a 20 % abatement factor to the cysts counts that were measured in the epidemiological study. Doing so, a daily water intake of 2 L and a Giardia concentration of 10 cysts/100 L, would yield an estimated relative excess risk of 12 % according to the Rendtorff model, against 11 % when multiplying the baseline rate of ADC by the corresponding OR. This abatement parameter encompasses uncertainties associated with germ viability, infectivity and virulence in natural settings. Conclusion: The dose-response function for waterborne Giardia risk derived from clinical experiments is consistent with epidemiological data. However, much remains to be learned about key characteristics that may heavily influence quantitative risk assessment results.


Related Articles

  • No simple solution to waterborne fungi: various responses to water disinfection methods. Hageskal, Gunhild; Tryland, Ingun; Liltved, Helge; Skaar, Ida // Water Science & Technology: Water Supply;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p220 

    Control strategies against waterborne fungi have been studied only to a small degree. In order to increase knowledge of the effect of water treatment on waterborne fungi, the dose-response effect of four commonly used drinking water disinfection methods was tested on selected fungal species:...

  • Acrylonitrile has Distinct Hormetic Effects on Acetylcholinesterase Activity in Mouse Brain and Blood that are Modulated by Ethanol. Yuanqing, He; Suhua, Wang; Guangwei, Xing; Chunlan, Ren; Hai, Qian; Wenrong, Xu; Rongzhu, Lu; Aschner, Michael; Milatovic, Dejan // Dose-Response;2013, Vol. 11 Issue 1, p49 

    Acrylonitrile(AN) is a neurotoxin both in animals and humans, but its effects on acetylcholinesterase (AChE) activity remain controversial. This study aimed to determine the dose-response effects of AN on AChE activity and the modulatory role of ethanol pretreatment. A total of 144 Kunming mice...

  • Mechanisms of hepatotoxicity of chloroacetonitrile: An end product of water chlorination. Abo-Salem, Osama Mohamed; Ghonaim, Mabrouk Mahmoud; Al-Zahrani, Saad Salem // Pakistan Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences;Jan2013, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p145 

    Chloroacetonitrile is a disinfectant by-product of chlorination of drinking water and is considered as a direct-acting mutagenic and carcinogenic agent. Time-course and dose-response studies were performed to examine the mechanism of chloroacetonitrile-induced hepatotoxicity. In the time-course...

  • Estimation of Benchmark Rice Cadmium Doses as Threshold Values for Abnormal Urinary Findings with Adjustment for Consumption of Jinzu River Water. Kobayashi, Etsuko; Suwazono, Yasushi; Dochi, Mirei; Honda, Ryumon; Kido, Teruhiko // Bulletin of Environmental Contamination & Toxicology;Jul2009, Vol. 83 Issue 1, p102 

    We performed this study to determine whether both eating cadmium (Cd)-polluted rice and drinking and/or cooking with Jinzu River water are associated with renal tubular dysfunction. A multiple logistic regression analysis of retrospective data indicated that both factors may contribute to this...

  • A Simple Method for Demonstrating the Giardia Lamblia Trophozoite. RAJURKAR, MONALI N.; LALL, NIHARIKA; BASAK, SILPI; MALLICK, SANJAY K. // Journal of Clinical & Diagnostic Research;Nov2012, Vol. 6 Issue 9, p1492 

    Introduction: Giardia lamblia is a flagellated protozoan parasite of man. Only 2 stages i.e. the trophozoite and the cyst forms are observed in the life cycle of Giardia. The Giardia infection is acquired from drinking water or by eating food which is contaminated with cysts. The symptoms of the...

  • Prenatal Lead Exposure in Mice. Barrett, Julia R. // Environmental Health Perspectives;Mar2008, Vol. 116 Issue 3, pA129 

    This article discusses the effects on mice of low level prenatal lead exposure. Female mice were subjected to various levels of lead in drinking water before or after gestation. There was a significant increase in body weight and a decrease in exploratory activity especially in the year-old,...

  • Toxicological Defense Mechanisms and the Shape of Dose-Response Relationships. Calabrese, Edward J. // Environmental Health Perspectives Supplements;Feb98 Supplement 1, Vol. 106, p273 

    Introduces a series of articles on the dose-response relationship, hazard assessment toxicology studies, and molecular and cellular defense mechanisms.

  • Dear Synergy... Cassidy, Mark; Higgins, Robert // Synergy: Imaging & Therapy Practice;Sep2011, p30 

    A letter to the editor, along with its reply, is presented in response to an article by Robert Higgins on the RITE Project, that was published in one of the previous issues.

  • Assessment of waterborne protozoan passage through conventional drinking water treatment process in Venezuela. Betancourt, Walter Q.; Mena, Kristina D. // Journal of Water & Health;Jun2012, Vol. 10 Issue 2, p324 

    Three drinking water treatment plants (DWTPs) differing in source water and treatment capacity were investigated for the potential passage of waterborne protozoan (oo)cysts through conventional processing. DWTP I (15,000 L/s), DWTP II (7,500 L/s) and DWTP III (4,300 L/s) provide drinking water...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics