Avoiding the danger that stop smoking services may exacerbate health inequalities: building equity into performance assessment

Low, Allan; Unsworth, Louise; Low, Anne; Miller, Iain
January 2007
BMC Public Health;2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p198
Academic Journal
Background: The UK is the only developed country to have established a nation-wide stop smoking treatment service. Apart from addressing tobacco dependence, which is the leading preventable cause of ill health and premature death, smoking cessation has been identified by the UK department of health as a service priority for reducing gaps in health between disadvantaged groups and the country as a whole. However smoking cessation tends to be more successful among affluent than disadvantaged groups. This means that for stop smoking services there is a trade-off to be had in terms of maximising the number of quitters and reducing socioeconomic inequalities in smoking prevalence. Current performance targets for the national stop smoking services in the UK are set only in terms of numbers of quitters, which does not encourage the adoption of strategies to reduce socioeconomic inequalities in smoking prevalence. Discussion: This paper proposes an assessment framework, which allows the two dimensions of overall reduction in smoking prevalence and reductions of inequalities in smoking prevalence to be assessed together. The framework is used to assess the performance over time of a stop smoking service in Derwentside, a former Primary Care Trust in the North East of England, both in terms of meeting targets for the overall number of quitters and in terms of reducing socioeconomic inequalities in smoking prevalence. The example demonstrates how the proposed assessment framework can be applied in practice given existing records kept by stop smoking services in England and the available information on smoking prevalence at small area level. For Derwentside it is shown that although service expansion was successful in increasing the overall number of quitters, the service continued to exacerbate inequality in smoking prevalence between deprived and affluent wards. Summary: The Secretary of State for Health in the UK has warned about the dangers of health promotion services and messages being taken up more readily by the better-off, thus exacerbating health inequalities. Because smokers from affluent backgrounds are more successful at quitting than those living in deprived circumstances, it is important to build an equity element into the monitoring of individual stop smoking services. Otherwise the danger highlighted by the Secretary of State for Health will go undetected and unaddressed.


Related Articles

  • Socioeconomic predictors of smoking and smoking frequency in urban China: evidence of smoking as a social function. Zhenfeng Pan // Health Promotion International;Sep2004, Vol. 19 Issue 3, p309 

    A number of previous studies have documented the worsening smoking problems in China. This paper identifies several key socioeconomic variables associated with smoking among urban working adults and calls researchers' attention to the important function of cigarette smoking as a social...

  • Shame-based appeals in a tobacco control public health campaign: potential harms and benefits. Brown-Johnson, Cati G.; Prochaska, Judith J. // Tobacco Control;Sep2015, Vol. 24 Issue 5, p419 

    The authors reflect on the benefits and harmful effects of shame-based approach in public health campaigns for tobacco control. The authors agree that public health campaigns should not have damaging effects to socially isolated members of society due to stigmatised disorders or socioeconomic...

  • Tobacco taxes as a tobacco control strategy. Chaloupka, Frank J.; Yurekli, Ayda; Fong, Geoffrey T. // Tobacco Control;Mar2012, Vol. 21 Issue 2, p172 

    Background: Increases in tobacco taxes are widely regarded as a highly effective strategy for reducing tobacco use and its consequences. Methods: The voluminous literature on tobacco taxes is assessed, drawing heavily from seminal and recent publications reviewing the evidence on the impact of...

  • Cross-national gender differences in the socioeconomic factors associated with smoking in Australia, the United States of America and South Korea. French, Davina; Jang, Soong-Nang; Tait, Robert; Anstey, Kaarin // International Journal of Public Health;Jun2013, Vol. 58 Issue 3, p345 

    Objectives: We compared rates of smoking among those aged 45 years and older in Australia, the United States of America and South Korea, and examined cross-national gender differences in key socioeconomic differentials in smoking. Methods: We conducted weighted analyses on cross-sectional data...

  • The use of legal, illegal and roll-your-own cigarettes to increasing tobacco excise taxes and comprehensive tobacco control policies: findings from the ITC Uruguay Survey. Curti, Dardo; Ce Shang; Ridgeway, William; Chaloupka, Frank J.; Fong, Geoffrey T. // Tobacco Control;2015 Supplement, Vol. 24, p17 

    Background Little research has been done to examine whether smokers switch to illegal or roll-your-own (RYO) cigarettes in response to a change in their relative price. Objective This paper explores how relative prices between three cigarette forms (manufactured legal, manufactured illegal and...

  • Socioeconomic factors associated with tobacco smoking among adult males in Sri Lanka. Fernando, Hiranya Nilakshi; Wimaladasa, Imaesha Thilini Pradeepika; Sathkoralage, Anjali Nimaya; Ariyadasa, Ashani Nisansala; Udeni, Chathurika; Galgamuwa, Lahiru Sandaruwan; Herath, Prasanna; Kumarasinghe, Nishantha // BMC Public Health;6/18/2019, Vol. 19 Issue 1, pN.PAG 

    Background: Tobacco smoking is considered as a major public health issue worldwide. Reduction of tobacco usage has been one of the main government policies in Sri Lanka and the price of cigarettes has been raised several times in the last few years. The purpose of this study was to...

  • Nurses Must Do Their Part to Stop Tobacco Use in People of All Ages.  // ONS News;Apr2000, Vol. 15 Issue 4, p10 

    Presents information on the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids sponsored by the 2000 Kick Butts Day in the U.S. Role of oncology nurses in educating patients about the hazards of cigarettes and tobacco use; Statistics related to tobacco use.

  • Profile of Maternal Smokers Who Quit During Pregnancy: A Population-Based Cohort Study of Tasmanian Women, 2011-2013. Frandsen, Mai; Thow, Megan; Ferguson, Stuart G. // Nicotine & Tobacco Research;May2017, Vol. 19 Issue 5, p532 

    Introduction: Smoking remains the single-most significant preventable cause of poor pregnancy outcomes, yet around 12% of Australian women smoke during pregnancy. Many women are motivated to quit when they find out they are pregnant, yet few are successful. While previous studies...

  • Headlights on tobacco road to low birthweight outcomes. Bache, Stefan; Dahl, Christian; Kristensen, Johannes // Empirical Economics;Jun2013, Vol. 44 Issue 3, p1593 

    Low birthweight outcomes are associated with considerable social and economic costs, and therefore the possible determinants of low birthweight are of great interest. One such determinant which has received considerable attention is maternal smoking. From an economic perspective this is in part...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics