Measuring the tail of the dog that doesn't bark in the night: the case of the national evaluation of Choose Life (the national strategy and action plan to prevent suicide in Scotland)

Mackenzie, Mhairi; Blamey, Avril; Halliday, Emma; Maxwell, Margaret; McCollam, Allyson; McDaid, David; MacLean, Joanne; Woodhouse, Amy; Platt, Stephen
January 2007
BMC Public Health;2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p146
Academic Journal
Background: Learning about the impact of public health policy presents significant challenges for evaluators. These include the nebulous and organic nature of interventions ensuing from policy directives, the tension between long-term goals and short-term interventions, the appropriateness of establishing control groups, and the problems of providing an economic perspective. An example of contemporary policy that has recently been subject to evaluation is the first phase of the innovative Scottish strategy for suicide prevention (Choose Life). Discussion and summary: This paper discusses how challenges, such as those above, were made manifest within this programme. After a brief summary of the overarching approach taken to evaluating the first phase of Choose Life, this paper then offers a set of recommendations for policymakers and evaluators on how learning from a second phase might be augmented. These recommendations are likely to have general resonance across a range of policy evaluations as they move from early planning and implementation to more mature phases.


Related Articles

  • Perspectives de la santé publique pour la prévention du suicide. Lesage, Alain; St-Laurent, Danielle; Gagné, Mathieu; Legaré, Gilles // Sante Mentale au Quebec;automne2012, Vol. 37 Issue 2, p239 

    Suicide prevention from a public health perspective: Suicide and suicide prevention represent major public health challenges. The public health perspective juxtaposes a multifactor understanding of society's health phenomena to a mobilization around determinants on which actions can be taken....

  • A new public health policy in Sweden. Larsson, Maria // Scandinavian Journal of Public Health;Jul2008, Vol. 36 Issue 5, p555 

    The article discusses the new public health policy in Sweden. It is noted that the new policy aims to strengthen and support parents in their parenthood, intensify suicide prevention efforts and promote good eating habits and physical activity. The bill contains 11 target areas which include...

  • Congressional hearing focuses on prevention of suicide.  // Nation's Health;Mar2000, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p18 

    Reports on the Congressional hearing on the need for research and funding for suicide awareness, prevention and intervention in the United States. Strategic elements for successfully reducing suicide rates; Link between suicide and mental illness; Variance in rates of suicide among different...

  • MORE BROKEN PROMISES.  // Community Care;9/19/2002, Issue 1440, p5 

    Editorial. Comments on the bills in Great Britain aimed to reduce suicide risks. Background on the campaign on child and adolescent mental health; Description of the government's policy on suicide prevention; Views of the Mental Health Alliance on the bill.

  • Policymaking ‘under the radar’: a case study of pesticide regulation to prevent intentional poisoning in Sri Lanka. Pearson, Melissa; Zwi, Anthony B; Buckley, Nicholas A; Manuweera, Gamini; Fernando, Ravindra; Dawson, Andrew H; McDuie-Ra, Duncan // Health Policy & Planning;Feb2015, Vol. 30 Issue 1, p56 

    Background Suicide in Sri Lanka is a major public health problem and in 1995 the country had one of the highest rates of suicide worldwide. Since then reductions in overall suicide rates have been largely attributed to efforts to regulate a range of pesticides. The evolution, context, events and...

  • Suicide prevention strategies in Japan: A 15-year review (1998-2013). Takeshima, Tadashi; Yamauchi, Takashi; Inagaki, Masatoshi; Kodaka, Manami; Matsumoto, Toshihiko; Kawano, Kenji; Katsumata, Yotaro; Fujimori, Maiko; Hisanaga, Ayaka; Takahashi, Yoshitomo // Journal of Public Health Policy;Feb2015, Vol. 36 Issue 1, p52 

    Suicide is a global public health problem and solutions to it can be found only through a global dialog. The suicide rate in Japan has been alarming, but Japan has made substantial efforts to reduce this rate, making prevention a high priority. This report reviews the developmental stages of a...

  • Suicide prevention strategies from medical perspective. Sang-Bin Bae; Jong-Min Woo // Journal of the Korean Medical Association / Taehan Uisa Hyophoe ;Apr2011, Vol. 54 Issue 4, p386 

    Even though suicide ranks as the fourth cause of death and is causing a significant loss in Korea, it seems that the conventional notion regarding suicide as a feasible way of solving a troublesome life situation hinders early recognition and proper management of suicide. This article reviews...

  • COMMUNITY CALENDAR.  // Navajo Times;9/25/2014, Vol. 53 Issue 39, pC-2 

    A calendar for several community events in Navajo Nation from September 25, 2014 to November 13, 2014 is presented which includes Beauty of Life Conference "Healthy Mind, Body and Spirit", 6th annual Celebration of Women, and Public Health 101, free introduction to public health training.

  • The US Air Force Suicide Prevention Program: Implications for Public Health Policy. Knox, Kerry L.; Pflanz, Steven; Talcott, Gerald W.; Campise, Rick L.; Lavigne, Jill E.; Bajorska, Alina; Tu, Xin; Caine, Eric D. // American Journal of Public Health;Dec2010, Vol. 100 Issue 12, p2457 

    Objectives. We evaluated the effectiveness of the US Air Force Suicide Prevention Program (AFSPP) in reducing suicide, and we measured the extent to which air force installations implemented the program. Methods. We determined the AFSPP's impact on suicide rates in the air force by applying an...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics