Measuring the tail of the dog that doesn't bark in the night: the case of the national evaluation of Choose Life (the national strategy and action plan to prevent suicide in Scotland)

Mackenzie, Mhairi; Blamey, Avril; Halliday, Emma; Maxwell, Margaret; McCollam, Allyson; McDaid, David; MacLean, Joanne; Woodhouse, Amy; Platt, Stephen
January 2007
BMC Public Health;2007, Vol. 7, p146
Academic Journal
Background: Learning about the impact of public health policy presents significant challenges for evaluators. These include the nebulous and organic nature of interventions ensuing from policy directives, the tension between long-term goals and short-term interventions, the appropriateness of establishing control groups, and the problems of providing an economic perspective. An example of contemporary policy that has recently been subject to evaluation is the first phase of the innovative Scottish strategy for suicide prevention (Choose Life). Discussion and summary: This paper discusses how challenges, such as those above, were made manifest within this programme. After a brief summary of the overarching approach taken to evaluating the first phase of Choose Life, this paper then offers a set of recommendations for policymakers and evaluators on how learning from a second phase might be augmented. These recommendations are likely to have general resonance across a range of policy evaluations as they move from early planning and implementation to more mature phases.


Related Articles

  • Evidence for beneficial effects of antidepressants on suicidality in depressive patients. Möller, Hans-Jürgen // European Archives of Psychiatry & Clinical Neuroscience;2006, Vol. 256 Issue 6, p329 

    The role of antidepressants in suicide prevention is a major public health question, given the high prevalence of both depression and depression-related suicidality. Therefore all means available should be utilised to clarify the influence of antidepressants on suicidality. This paper gives a...

  • (MENTAL HEALTH) American Foundation/Suicide Prevention.  // Children & Youth Funding Report;10/23/2009, p23 

    The article reports that the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention is accepting applications for its 2008 multi-leveled Research Grants program. The goal of the program is to understand the factors related to suicidal behavior and to test treatments and interventions designed to prevent...

  • The risk of suicide attempt by a child or adolescent is highest after a contact with a psychiatric department. Christiansen, Erik; Mehlum, Lars // Evidence Based Mental Health;May2012, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p44 

    The article presents a study on whether there is an increased risk to commit or attempt suicide for children and adolescents after contact with a psychiatric department. The study found the highest risk of suicide attempt to be shortly after discharge from the last contact with a psychiatric...

  • Youth Suicide Prevention Programs. Kalafat, John // Prevention Researcher;Sep2006, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p12 

    The article analyzes current youth suicide prevention strategies in the U.S. that have been evaluated and show promise. These prevention strategies can be grouped into three categories, including identification and referral of at-risk youth to treatment, addressing risk factors, and enhancing...

  • Why are we not getting any closer to preventing suicide? de Leo, Diego // British Journal of Psychiatry;Nov2002, Vol. 181, p372 

    The author reflects on the unimproved means to prevent suicide. Despite strong a interest in mental health, contemporary psychiatrists lack the capacity to develop approaches for suicide prevention because of its extreme complexity and relative rarity. In addition, multi-disciplinary approaches...

  • Suicide, Firearms, and Public Health. Browning, Charles H. // American Journal of Public Health;Apr1974, Vol. 64 Issue 4, p313 

    The article discusses the study that probes the effectiveness of the public health model created to decrease the availability of firearms to suicidal persons in the U.S. Whether such a program would be worth continuing would depend in part on whether it resulted in a significant reduction in the...

  • La investigación sobre suicidio en México en el periodo 1980-2014: análisis y perspectivas. Vázquez-Vega, Daniela; Piña-Pozas, Maricela; González-Forteza, Catalina; Jiménez-Tapia, Alberto; Mondragón-Barrios, Liliana // Acta Universitaria;Sep2015 Special, Vol. 25 Issue NE-2, p62 

    From an epidemiological perspective, suicidal behavior and suicide constitute a growing public health problem because of its impact on morbidity and mortality of young and economically active population, both worldwide and in Mexico. Therefore, since the decade of 1970 the identification of risk...

  • Which deliberate self-poisoning patients are most likely to make high-lethality suicide attempts? Sang Hoon Oh; Han Joon Kim; Soo Hyun Kim; Young Min Kim; Kyu Nam Park // International Journal of Mental Health Systems;9/7/2015, Vol. 9, p1 

    Background: The risk/rescue rating scale (RRRS) assesses the lethality of a suicide attempt, which is defined as the probability of inflicting irreversible damage. We assessed the lethality of suicide attempts using the RRRS and identified the socio-demographic profiles of patients who achieved...

  • Suicide prevention and social capital: A Samoan perspective. Stewart-Withers, Rochelle R; O'Brien, Anthony P // Health Sociology Review;Jun2006, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p209 

    This paper draws on the example of Samoa to argue that Western models of health promotion and suicide prevention, especially those which draw on conventional understandings of social capital, are not appropriate for non-Western communities, for they are generally not sensitive to cultural...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics