'Issues of equity are also issues of rights': Lessons from experiences in Southern Africa

London, Leslie
January 2007
BMC Public Health;2007, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p14
Academic Journal
Background: Human rights approaches to health have been criticized as antithetical to equity, principally because they are seen to prioritise rights of individuals at the expense of the interests of groups, a core tenet of public health. The objective of this study was to identify how human rights approaches can promote health equity. Methods: The Network on Equity in Health in Southern Africa undertook an exploration of three regional case studies - antiretroviral access, patient rights charters and civic organization for health. A combination of archival reviews and stakeholder interviews were complemented with a literature review to provide a theoretical framework for the empirical evidence. Results: Critical success factors for equity are the importance of rights approaches addressing the full spectrum from civil and political, through to socio-economic rights, as well as the need to locate rights in a group context. Human rights approaches succeed in achieving health equity when coupled with community engagement in ways that reinforce community capacity, particularly when strengthening the collective agency of its most vulnerable groups. Additionally, human rights approaches provide opportunities for mobilising resources outside the health sector, and must aim to address the public-private divide at local, national and international levels. Conclusion: Where it is clear that rights approaches are predicated upon understanding the need to prioritize vulnerable groups and where the way rights are operationalised recognizes the role of agency on the part of those most affected in realising their socio-economic rights, human rights approaches appear to offer powerful tools to support social justice and health equity.


Related Articles

  • Mainstreaming Social Justice. VanderPlaat, Madine; Teles, Nair // Canadian Journal of Public Health;Jan/Feb2005, Vol. 96 Issue 1, p34 

    Our interest in a human rights and health discourse emerges from our efforts as social scientists to bring a meaningful social justice perspective to the realm of public health. In Canada, as in many countries, "health" is still firmly within the domain of the biomedical and the clinical. While...

  • Addressing Equity in Health Research: Applying a Democratic Education Framework for Social Justice. Clark, Marc D.; Hollander, Roberta B. // Journal of Negro Education;Winter2005, Vol. 74 Issue 1, p30 

    This article examines inequities in health and research using a framework that draws on the work of democratic education theorists Amy Gutmann and Kenneth Howe. Specifically, this article has three purposes: (a) extend the framework of democratic education to analyzing equity in health research,...

  • Leading the movement for health equity, social justice, human rights. Troutman, Adewale // Nation's Health;Nov/Dec2013, Vol. 43 Issue 9, p3 

    The author comments on the role and credibility of the American Public Health Association (APHA) in the movement for social justice, health equity and human rights in the U.S.

  • Challenges and Possibilities for Innovative Praxis in Health and Human Rights: Reflections from Peru. Yamin, Alicia Ely // Health & Human Rights: An International Journal;2002, Vol. 6 Issue 1, p35 

    Examples drawn from Peru suggest both challenges and possibilities for linking the health and human rights fields more systematically in a campaign for health as a basic question of social justice. Criteria that distinguish a human rights framework can be derived from an understanding of health...

  • Introduction. Gallavan, Nancy P.; Craig, Cheryl J. // Action in Teacher Education;2011 Yearbook, Vol. 33 Issue 5/6, p409 

    The author contemplates on his career in the academe and how he instilled in his learners a comprehension and appreciation of the concepts of democratic principles, social justice, human rights and educational equity. During his 20 years as an elementary and middle school teacher, he notes that...

  • El Sistema : On Music and Social Justice.  // Washington Report on the Hemisphere;6/7/2013, Vol. 33 Issue 9, p1 

    The article offers information on an innovative social justice movement taken by EI Sistema, publicly financed voluntary sector music education program, that uses musical education to reduce inter-generational poverty in Latin American countries. It mentions that the EI Sistema model has been an...

  • Transforming Social Protection: Human Wellbeing and Social Justice. Devereux, Stephen; McGregor, J Allister // European Journal of Development Research;Jul2014, Vol. 26 Issue 3, p296 

    This article calls for a moment of pause to consider the current direction of social protection thinking and practice. It introduces a special issue in which a range of authors explore the relationship between social protection and social justice. The article argues that the currently...

  • Response to Rodríguez: A "Long Walk to Freedom" and Democracy? Smith, Keri Iyall // Social Forces;Sep2004, Vol. 83 Issue 1, p413 

    This article presents the author's comments on the article A Long Walk to Freedom and Democracy: Human Rights, Globalization, and Social Injustice, by Havidán Rodríguez in the same issue. Rodríguez's title, A Long Walk to Freedom and Democracy, implies that freedom and democracy are...

  • Beyond ‘New Humanitarianism’: Physicians for Human Rights–Israel's Mobile Clinic and Open Clinic on the Interface of Social Justice, Human Rights and Medical Relief. Filc, Dani; Davidovitch, Nadav; Gottlieb, Nora // Journal of Human Rights Practice;Feb2015, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p88 

    The present article examines two projects of Physicians for Human Rights–Israel (PHR–IL)—a clinic in the Occupied Palestinian Territories and a clinic for undocumented migrant workers and asylum seekers—in order to examine the tensions between medical humanitarian...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics