Differing mental health practice among general practitioners, private psychiatrists and public psychiatrists

Younès, N.; Hardy-Bayle, M. C.; Falissard, B.; Kovess, V.; Chaillet, M. P.; Gasquet, I.
January 2005
BMC Public Health;2005, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p104
Academic Journal
Background: Providing care for mental health problems concerns General Practitioners (GPs), Private Psychiatrists (PrPs) and Public Psychiatrists (PuPs). As patient distribution and patterns of practice among these professionals are not well known, a survey was planned prior to a re-organisation of mental health services in an area close to Paris Methods: All GPs (n = 492), PrPs (n = 82) and PuPs (n = 78) in the South-Yvelines area in France were informed of the implementation of a local mental health program. Practitioners interested in taking part were invited to include prospectively all patients with mental health problem they saw over an 8-day period and to complete a 6-month retrospective questionnaire on their mental health practice. 180 GPs (36.6%), 45 PrPs (54.9%) and 63 PuPs (84.0%) responded. Results: GPs and PrPs were very similar but very different from PuPs for the proportion of patients with anxious or depressive disorders (70% v. 65% v. 38%, p < .001), psychotic disorders (5% v. 7% v. 30%, p < .001), previous psychiatric hospitalization (22% v. 26 v. 61%, p < .001) and receiving disability allowance (16% v. 18% v. 52%, p < .001). GPs had fewer patients with long-standing psychiatric disorders than PrPs and PuPs (52%, 64% v. 63%, p < .001). Time-lapse between consultations was longest for GPs, intermediate for PuPs and shortest for PrPs (36 days v. 26 v. 18, p < .001). Access to care had been delayed longer for Psychiatrists (PrPs, PuPs) than for GPs (61% v. 53% v. 25%, p < .001). GPs and PuPs frequently felt a need for collaboration for their patients, PrPs rarely (42% v. 61%. v. 10%, p < .001). Satisfaction with mental health practice was low for all categories of physicians (42.6% encountered difficulties hospitalizing patients and 61.4% had patients they would prefer not to cater for). GPs more often reported unsatisfactory relationships with mental health professionals than did PrPs and PuPs (54% v. 15% v. 8%, p < .001). Conclusion: GP patients with mental health problems are very similar to patients of private psychiatrists; there is a lack of the collaboration felt to be necessary, because of psychiatrists' workload, and because GPs have specific needs in this respect. The "Yvelines-Sud Mental Health Network" has been created to enhance collaboration.


Related Articles

  • Biggest Gripes.  // Minnesota Medicine;Jan2007, Vol. 90 Issue 1, p7 

    The article focuses on a survey which aims to know the concerns of psychiatrists in their practices in the U.S. Of the 647 psychiatrists who participated in the survey, 9 percent of them admit that they are not bothered with constraints of their practices. Meanwhile, 33 percent complain of...

  • A sense of proportion: the place of psychiatry in medicine. Lloyd, G. G. // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Oct1996, Vol. 89 Issue 10, p563 

    Psychiatric disorders have a high prevalence in medical and surgical patients and the need for an effective liaison psychiatry service is widely accepted. However, the development of liaison psychiatry may be jeopardized by the trend towards establishing psychiatric facilities in the community...

  • Delivery of psychiatric care. Strathdee, G. // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Apr1990, Vol. 83 Issue 4, p222 

    This paper proposes criteria essential for the effective delivery of psychiatric care and briefly reviews the extent to which they are fulfilled by current services. An audit study is described where district general practitioners were asked to evaluate the extent to which their local...

  • Hope, optimism and delusion. McGuire-Snieckus, Rebecca // British Journal of Psychiatry;Apr2014 Supplement, p49 

    Optimism is generally accepted by psychiatrists, psychologists and other caring professionals as a feature of mental health, interventions typically rely on cognitive-behavioural tools to encourage individuals to 'stop negative thought cycles and to 'challenge unhelpful thoughts'. However,...

  • The medical model is dead -- long live the medical model. Shah, Premal; Mountain, Deborah // British Journal of Psychiatry;Nov2007, Vol. 191, p375 

    Many people criticise, and psychiatrists apologise, for the use of the 'medical model'. We examine what is currently meant by this term and suggest a refinement of definition to reflect the ideals and contemporary practice of medicine. We propose that psychiatrists should use the medical model...

  • Role of the Prescribing Observatory for Mental Health. Barnes, Thomas R. E.; Paton, Carol // British Journal of Psychiatry;Dec2012, Vol. 201 Issue 6, p428 

    Positive change in prescribing practice in psychiatric services can be achieved with participation in the UK Prescribing Observatory for Mental Health (POMH-UK) quality improvement programmes. Key elements are feedback of benchmarked performance for local clinical reflection and customised...

  • Interlace between research and clinical practice in child psychiatry--some personal reflections: discussion paper. Rutter, M. // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Jul1990, Vol. 83 Issue 7, p444 

    The article presents the author's comments about the similarities and differences between research and clinical practice in child psychiatry. The author says that research and clinical practice are very similar. He says that the main difference between the two fields is the time frame and the...

  • Psychiatric Medication Refill Practices of Juvenile Detainees. Neff, Mallery; Aalsma, Matthew; Rosenman, Marc; Wiehe, Sarah // Child Psychiatry & Human Development;Dec2013, Vol. 44 Issue 6, p717 

    To examine the psychiatric medication fill rates of adolescents after release from juvenile detention. The team reviewed 177 charts. A fill was defined as a psychiatric medication charge to Medicaid 30- or 90-days after release. Differences in demographic characteristics were compared among...

  • Living with accelerating speed of change. Rae-Grant, Quentin; Rae-Grant, Q // Canadian Journal of Psychiatry;Feb1997, Vol. 42 Issue 1, p17 

    The author reflects on the fast-paced changes in the practice of psychiatry. He noted that these changes will eventually characterize the practice of psychiatry and mental health especially in the funding patterns which directly affects teaching, research and practice problems. He also believes...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics