Are alcoholism treatments effective? The Project MATCH data

Cutler, Robert B.; Fishbain, David A.
January 2005
BMC Public Health;2005, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p75
Academic Journal
Background: Project MATCH was the largest and most expensive alcoholism treatment trial ever conducted. The results were disappointing. There were essentially no patient-treatment matches, and three very different treatments produced nearly identical outcomes. These results were interpreted post hoc as evidence that all three treatments were quite effective. We re-analyzed the data in order to estimate effectiveness in relation to quantity of treatment. Methods: This was a secondary analysis of data from a multisite clinical trial of alcohol dependent volunteers (N = 1726) who received outpatient psychosocial therapy. Analyses were confined to the primary outcome variables, percent days abstinent (PDA) and drinks per drinking day (DDD). Overall tests between treatment outcome and treatment quantity were conducted. Next, three specific groups were highlighted. One group consisted of those who dropped out immediately; the second were those who dropped out after receiving only one therapy session, and the third were those who attended 12 therapy sessions. Results: Overall, a median of only 3% of the drinking outcome at follow-up could be attributed to treatment. However this effect appeared to be present at week one before most of the treatment had been delivered. The zero treatment dropout group showed great improvement, achieving a mean of 72 percent days abstinent at follow-up. Effect size estimates showed that two-thirds to three-fourths of the improvement in the full treatment group was duplicated in the zero treatment group. Outcomes for the one session treatment group were worse than for the zero treatment group, suggesting a patient self selection effect. Nearly all the improvement in all groups had occurred by week one. The full treatment group had improved in PDA by 62% at week one, and the additional 11 therapy sessions added only another 4% improvement. Conclusion: The results suggest that current psychosocial treatments for alcoholism are not particularly effective. Untreated alcoholics in clinical trials show significant improvement. Most of the improvement which is interpreted as treatment effect is not due to treatment. Part of the remainder appears to be due to selection effects.


Related Articles

  • Are Alcoholism Treatments Effective? The Project MATCH Data: Response. Miller, William R. // BMC Public Health;2005, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p76 

    The article discusses the response of Project MATCH (Matching Alcoholism Treatments to Client Heterogeneity) on statements stating the ineffectiveness of alcoholism treatments. The authors are not recommending to stop alcoholism treatment. Still, they hold their claims despite the logical flaws...

  • The influence of psychoeducation on regulating biological rhythm in a sample of patients with bipolar IIdisorder: a randomized clinical trial. Faria, Augusto Duarte; de Mattos Souza, Luciano Dias; de Azevedo Cardoso, Taiane; Tavares Pinheiro, Karen Amaral; Pinheiro, Ricardo Tavares; da Silva, Ricardo Azevedo; Jansen, Karen // Psychology Research & Behavior Management;2014, Vol. 7, p167 

    Introduction: Changes in biological rhythm are among the various characteristics of bipolar disorder, and have long been associated with the functional impairment of the disease. There are only a few viable options of psychosocial interventions that deal with this specific topic; one of them is...

  • Exercise or relaxation after stroke? Mead, Gillian // BMJ: British Medical Journal (International Edition);6/4/2005, Vol. 330 Issue 7503, p1337 

    Comments on the results of a study on the benefits of physical exercise for stroke patients. Description of a twelve-week clinical trial, in which stroke patients participated in physical fitness training classes; Positive response of patients in the study to participating in the fitness class;...

  • Trastornos del espectro autista. Álvarez-Alcántara, Elsa // Revista Mexicana de Pediatria;nov/dic2007, Vol. 74 Issue 6, p269 

    This is a review of the autistic spectrum disorders. The approaches in order to get an opportune diagnosis and the psychosocial areas affected in the children and the general clinical features of those. It is also mentioned some intervention programs for these patients, since the simple approach...

  • Self-report and parent-report of physical and psychosocial well-being in Dutch adolescents with type 1 diabetes in relation to glycemic control. De Wit, Maartje; de Waal, Henriette A. Delemarre-Van; Bokma, Jan Alle; Haasnoot, Krijn; Houdijk, Mieke C.; Gemke, Reinoud J.; Snoek, Frank J. // Health & Quality of Life Outcomes;2007, Vol. 5, p10 

    Background: To determine physical and psychosocial well-being of adolescents with type 1 diabetes by self-report and parent report and to explore associations with glycemic control and other clinical and socio-demographic characteristics. Methods: Demographic, medical and psychosocial data were...

  • Health related quality of life and psychosocial function among patients with carcinoid tumours. A longitudinal, prospective, and comparative study. Fröjd, Camilla; Larsson, Gunnel; Lampic, Claudia; Von Essen, Louise // Health & Quality of Life Outcomes;2007, Vol. 5, p18 

    Background: The aim was to investigate HRQoL and psychosocial function among patients with carcinoid tumours, longitudinally and prospectively, and to compare HRQoL among patients with carcinoid tumours to that of the Swedish general population. The aim was also to investigate the prevalence of...

  • Effectiveness of the Antenatal Psychosocial Health Assessment (ALPHA) form in detecting psychosocial concerns: a randomized controlled trial. Carroll, June C.; Reid, Anthony J.; Biringer, Anne; Midmer, Deana; Glazier, Richard H.; Wilson, Lynn; Permaul, Joanne A.; Pugh, Patricia; Chalmers, Beverley; Seddon, Freda; Stewart, Donna E. // CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;8/2/2005, Vol. 173 Issue 3, p253 

    Background A pregnant woman's psychological health is a significant predictor of postpartum outcomes. The Antenatal Psychosocial Health Assessment (ALPHA) form incorporates 15 risk factors associated with poor postpartum outcomes of woman abuse, child abuse, postpartum depression and couple...

  • Vitiligo impact scale: An instrument to assess the psychosocial burden of vitiligo. Krishna, Gaurang S.; Ramam, M.; Mehta, Manju; Sreenivas, V.; Sharma, Vinod K.; Khandpur, Sujay // Indian Journal of Dermatology, Venereology & Leprology;Mar/Apr2013, Vol. 79 Issue 2, p205 

    Background: Vitiligo is a disease that significantly impairs quality of life. Previous studies have shown that vitiligo has an impact that may not correlate with the size and extent of depigmentation, indicating a need for an independent measure of the psychosocial burden. Aims: To develop a...

  • Effects of caesarean section on maternal health in low risk nulliparous women: a prospective matched cohort study in Shanghai, China. Bing-shun Wang; Li-feng Zhou; David Coulter; Hong Liang; Ye Zhong; Yu-na Guo; Li-ping Zhu; Xiao-ling Gao; Wei Yuan; Er-sheng Gao // BMC Pregnancy & Childbirth;2010, Vol. 10, p78 

    Background: Rates of caesarean section are progressively increasing in many parts of the world. As a result of psychosocial factors there has been an increasing tendency for pregnant women without justifiable medical indications for caesarean section to ask for this procedure in China. A...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics