Comparing the clinical effectiveness of different new-born hearing screening strategies. A decision analysis

Grill, Eva; Hessel, Franz; Siebert, Uwe; Schnell-Inderst, Petra; Kunze, Silke; Nickisch, Andreas; Wasem, J├╝rgen
January 2005
BMC Public Health;2005, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p12
Academic Journal
Background: Children with congenital hearing impairment benefit from early detection and treatment. At present, no model exists which explicitly quantifies the effectiveness of universal newborn hearing screening (UNHS) versus other programme alternatives in terms of early diagnosis. It has yet to be considered whether early diagnosis (within the first few months) of hearing impairment is of importance with regard to the further development of the child compared with effects resulting from a later diagnosis. The objective was to systematically compare two screening strategies for the early detection of new-born hearing disorders, UNHS and risk factor screening, with no systematic screening regarding their influence on early diagnosis. Methods: Design: Clinical effectiveness analysis using a Markov Model. Data Sources: Systematic literature review, empirical data survey, and expert opinion. Target Population: All newborn babies. Time scale: 6, 12 and 120 months. Perspective: Health care system. Compared Strategies: UNHS, Risk factor screening (RS), no systematic screening (NS). Outcome Measures: Quality weighted detected child months (QCM). Results: UNHS detected 644 QCM up until the age of 6 months (72,2%). RS detected 393 child months (44,1%) and no systematic screening 152 child months (17,0%). UNHS detected 74,3% and 86,7% weighted child months at 12 and 120 months, RS 48,4% and 73,3%, NS 23,7% and 60,6%. At the age of 6 months UNHS identified approximately 75% of all children born with hearing impairment, RS 50% and NS 25%. At the time of screening UNHS marked 10% of screened healthy children for further testing (false positives), RS 2%. UNHS demonstrated higher effectiveness even under a wide range of relevant parameters. The model was insensitive to test parameters within the assumed range but results varied along the prevalence of hearing impairment. Conclusion: We have shown that UNHS is able to detect hearing impairment at an earlier age and more accurately than selective RS. Further research should be carried out to establish the effects of hearing loss on the quality of life of an individual, its influence on school performance and career achievement and the differences made by early fitting of a hearing aid on these factors.


Related Articles

  • VOICE for Hearing-Impaired Children Launches a Position Paper on Listening and Spoken Language for Children with Hearing Loss. Bernstein, Anita // Sound Matters;2011, p28 

    The article offers information on the auditory-verbal (A-V) programs offered by VOICE for Hearing-Impaired Children. It presents the principles that guide the VOICE A-V program on listening and spoken language for children with hearing disorders. It adds that the A-V practice must be implemented...

  • Early Identification of Hearing Loss: Listen to Parents. Thompson, Marie D.; Thompson, Gary // Clinical Pediatrics;Feb1991, Vol. 30 Issue 2, p77 

    Families of 49 hearing-impaired children responded to a questionnaire requesting information about the identification of their child's hearing loss. Parents were the first to suspect the hearing loss in 48 cases but more often than not were told that the child would outgrow it or was too young...

  • DETERMINING the prevalence of Hearing Impaired Children. Connor, Leo E. // Exceptional Children;Feb1961, Vol. 27 Issue 6, p337 

    The article focuses on the need for a comprehensive national researches and studies in determining the prevalence of hearing impaired children in the U.S. The testing and surveys conducted in the past 30 years had produced varied results which made it impossible for the appropriation of...

  • Why Johnny Can't Hear. Garwood, Victor P.; Goodhill, Victor // Education;Mar1959, Vol. 79 Issue 7, p423 

    The article focuses on deafness, its diagnosis and treatment. While it has been demonstrated clinically that only a very few children have absolutely no hearing, that majority classified as deaf have some residual hearing, usually for low pitched tones only. The information carried by such tones...

  • CONSIDERATIONS IN EDUCATION of children with various degrees of hearing loss. Roach, Robert E. // Exceptional Children;May1954, Vol. 20 Issue 8, p330 

    The article focuses on the considerations in education of children with various degrees of hearing loss in the U.S. For children having 40-60 decibel hearing loss, the desired educational goal for them is public school. Nevertheless, they will need special instruction to compete successfully...

  • Effect of Minimal Hearing Loss on Children's Ability to Multitask in Quiet and in Noise. McFadden, Brittany; Pittman, Andrea // Language, Speech & Hearing Services in Schools;Jul2008, Vol. 39 Issue 3, p342 

    Purpose: The purpose of the present study was to examine the effect of minimal hearing loss (HL) on children's ability to perform simultaneous tasks in quiet and in noise. Method: Ten children with minimal HL and 11 children with normal hearing (NH) participated. Both groups ranged in age from 8...

  • New Directions in Pediatric Cochlear Implantation: Effects on Candidacy. Kirk, Karen Iler; Firszt, Jill B.; Hood, Linda J.; Holt, Rachael Frush // ASHA Leader;11/28/2006, Vol. 11 Issue 16, p6 

    The article describes advances in cochlear implants and their effect on candidacy criteria for children to receive cochlear implants. Success in unilateral cochlear implants is leading many to consider bilateral implantations. Cochlear implantation in people with auditory...

  • Hearing and Marijuana.  // Pediatrics for Parents;2004, Vol. 21 Issue 1, p3 

    Reports that prenatal exposure to marijuana increases the chances of childhood hearing loss. Effect of prenatal exposure to cigarette smoke on hearing; Percentage of seven year old children who had prenatal exposure to marijuana who have hearing loss; Association of cigarettes with hearing problems.

  • Young Children Who are Deaf-Blind: Implications for Professionals in Deaf and Hard of Hearing Services. Chen, Deborah // Volta Review;Winter2004, Vol. 104 Issue 4, p273 

    Children who have both a hearing loss and a visual impairment are a very small hut extremely heterogeneous law incidence group. These children vary greatly in the types and degrees of visual impairment and hearing loss. The majority of them have some usable vision and/or hearing, and many have...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics