Deprived children or deprived neighbourhoods? A public health approach to the investigation of links between deprivation and injury risk with specific reference to child road safety in Devon County, UK

Hewson, Paul
January 2004
BMC Public Health;2004, Vol. 4, p15
Academic Journal
Background: Worldwide, injuries from road traffic collisions are a rapidly growing problem in terms of morbidity and mortality. The UK has amongst the worst records in Europe with regard to child pedestrian safety. A traditional view holds that resources should be directed towards training child pedestrians. In order to reduce socio-economic differentials in child pedestrian casualty rates it is suggested that these should be directed at deprived children. This paper seeks to question whether analysis of extant routinely collected data supports this view. Methods: Routine administrative data on road collisions has been used. A deprivation measure has been assigned to the location where a collision was reported, and the home postcode of the casualty. Aggregate data was analysed using a number of epidemiological models, concentrating on the Generalised Linear Mixed Model. Results: This study confirms evidence suggesting a link between increasing deprivation and increasing casualty involvement of child pedestrians. However, suggestions are made that it may be necessary to control for the urban nature of an area where collisions occur. More importantly, the question is raised as to whether the casualty rate is more closely associated with deprivation measures of the ward in which the collision occurred than with the deprivation measures of the home address of the child. Conclusion: Conclusions have to be drawn with great caution. Limitations in the utility of the officially collected data are apparent, but the implication is that the deprivation measures of the area around the collision is a more important determinant of socio-economic differentials in casualty rates than the deprivation measures of the casualties' home location. Whilst this result must be treated with caution, if confirmed by individual level case-controlled studies this would have a strong implication for the most appropriate interventions.


Related Articles

  • Benefits unit ensures families receive theirfull entitlement.  // Children & Young People Now;6/12/2012, p36 

    The article presents a case study on the Devon Quids for Kids project of the Devon Welfare Rights Unit in Devon County, England. The projects was funded with 113,000 pounds by the county's children and families service to ensure that families and children with special needs gain financial...

  • My Week The pride and prejudice is illuminating. Lynch, Jeanie // Children & Young People Now (Haymarket Business Publications Ltd;4/23/2009, p48 

    The author narrates her daily activities as a lead officer for equality and diversity in children and young people's services at Devon County Council, Devon County, England. She attended a meeting focusing on the development of Safe Space quality scheme for young people. She had training with...

  • Traffic safety focal point for grant projects in 15 states.  // Nation's Health;Feb2001, Vol. 31 Issue 1, p11 

    Covers the traffic safety programs in several states in the United States by the affiliates of the American Public Health Association. Passenger safety training project for Spanish-speaking children in Connecticut; Promotion campaign on traffic safety in Kentucky; Motor vehicle safety for...

  • Vibe. Puffett, Neil // Children & Young People Now (Haymarket Business Publications Ltd;8/24/2010, p23 

    The article discusses the success of the Vibe Youth Leisure Nights project the goal of which was to provide purposeful activities to young people and to encourage them to visit local leisure centres on Friday nights, with recent figures showing a decrease in youth crime across Devon County, England.

  • Understanding childhood obesity. Nelder, Robert // Primary Health Care;Jun2009, Vol. 19 Issue 5, p28 

    The article reports on the results of a survey conducted in Plymouth, England between 1995 and 2005. Researchers selected children in year one (five to six year olds) and year six (ten to 11 year olds) classes in Plymouth's infant, junior and primary schools and compared their body masses....

  • APHA institute teams improving traffic safety. Currie, Donya // Nation's Health;Mar2009, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p5 

    The article reports on the move of the American Public Health Association (APHA) to institute teams from several universities the U.S., which aims to improve motorcycle and pedestrian safety in the country. It notes that an average of two children a week were showing up at a hospital's trauma...

  • Ethnicity, deprivation and road traffic injury risk: a survey of risk and road safety and implications for injury prevention. Christie, Nicola; Kimberlee, Richard H.; Lyons, Ronan; Towner, Elizabeth; Ward, Heather // International Journal of Health Promotion & Education;2008, Vol. 46 Issue 4, p133 

    Objective: To gain an insight into the relationship between ethnicity and road safety among adults living in low socioeconomic areas. Design: Questionnaire based face-to-face interview survey among residents from low socioeconomic areas. Setting: The survey was conducted in five districts which...

  • Estate living. Alleman, Richard // Vogue;Sep2005, Vol. 195 Issue 9, p582 

    Features Hotel Endesleigh in Devon County, England. Details of the design and construction of the hotel; Ambiance and amenities; Features of gardens filled with streams, lily ponds, waterfalls and palm trees.

  • Bull runs amok at County show.  // Farmers Weekly;5/23/2008, p50 

    The article reports that a bull went on a five-hour rampage after escaping from the Devon County Show in England, causing damage to local property and requiring police and veterinary assistance. The Blonde d'Aquitaine bullock escaped on the eve of the show, breaking through a hedge and smashing...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics