Suicide and no axis I psychopathology

Ernst, Carl; Lalovic, Aleksandra; Lesage, Alain; Seguin, Monique; Tousignant, Michel; Turecki, Gustavo
January 2004
BMC Psychiatry;2004, Vol. 4, p7
Academic Journal
Background: It is unclear why approximately 10% of suicide completers seem to be psychiatrically normal. To better understand this issue, we studied suicide completers without an axis I diagnosis and compared them, on measures of psychopathology other than axis I, to normal controls and suicide cases with axis I psychopathology. Methods: 168 suicide cases were examined by way of a psychological autopsy with the best possible informant. Sixteen cases did not meet criteria for an axis I diagnosis; each of these cases was then age and gender matched to 52 suicide completers with an axis I disorder and 110 normal controls. Results: Fourteen of sixteen suicide cases without an axis I diagnosis had detectable abnormalities that were more similar to the axis I diagnosed suicide group than to a living group. Both suicide groups were similar in the total number of past suicide attempts, the total number of individuals with an axis II disorder, and similar scores on measures of impulsive-aggressive behaviors. Conclusions: These findings suggest that most of the individuals who committed suicide and appeared psychiatrically normal after a psychological autopsy may probably have an underlying psychiatric process that the psychological autopsy method, as commonly carried out, failed to detect.


Related Articles

  • Psychological Autopsy -- An Effective Method for the Positive Diagnosis of Suicide in Schizophrenia. V., Hădărean; Andreea, Sălcudean; I., Gaboș-Grecu; Marieta, Gaboș-Grecu; Gabriela, Buicu; D., Sălcudean; Camelia, Stanciu // Acta Medica Marisiensis;Aug2011, Vol. 57 Issue 4, p300 

    Purpose: This paper aims to analyze suicide in schizophrenia in terms of application of psychological autopsy. Material and methods: We studied 53 persons who committed suicide between 2000-2009. We carried a series of interviews with people close to the persons who committed suicide, to analyze...

  • Cross-national prevalence and risk factors for suicidal ideation, plans and attempts. Nock, Matthew K.; Borges, Guilherme; Bromet, Evelyn J.; Alonso, Jordi; Angermeyer, Matthias; Beautrais, Annette; Bruffaerts, Ronny; Wai Tat Chiu; De Girolamo, Giovanni; Gluzman, Semyon; De Graaf, Ron; Gureje, Oye; Haro, Josep Maria; Yueqin Huang; Karam, Elie; Kessler, Ronald C.; Lepine, Jean Pierre; Levinson, Daphna; Medina-Mora, Maria Elena; Ono, Yutaka // British Journal of Psychiatry;Feb2008, Vol. 192 Issue 2, p98 

    Background Suicide is a leading cause of death worldwide; however, the prevalence and risk factors for the immediate precursors to suicide -- suicidal ideation, plans and attempts -- are not well-known, especially in low- and middle-income countries. Aims To report on the prevalence and risk...

  • Isparta Ä°l Merkezinde Ä°ntihar GiriÅŸimi, Ölüm Düşünceleri Yaygınlığı ve Risk Faktörleri. Atay, İnci Meltem; Eren, İbrahim; Gündoğar, Duru // Turk Psikiyatri Dergisi;Summer2012, Vol. 23 Issue 2, p89 

    Objective: Suicide is a complex process from the initiation of ideation to planning, and finally to an attempt. This study aimed to investigate the prevalence of death ideation, attempted suicide, and the associated risk factors in Isparta, Turkey. Materials and Methods: The study included 600...

  • Psychopathologische Aspekte des 'Raptus melancholicus'. Erkwoh, R.; Huber, G. // Nervenarzt;Jul2009, Vol. 80 Issue 7, p813 

    The term 'raptus melancholicus' is rarely used in clinical or scientific discussions. There is a lack of data on frequency and attribution to psychiatric disorders. It is found more often in the older literature where authors write of detailed personal experiences with this malicious phenomenon,...

  • Assessment of Suicide Risk. Hawton, K. // British Journal of Psychiatry;Feb87, Vol. 150, p145 

    The article explores the problems in assessing suicide risk. Several problems in assessing suicide risk include difficulties in applying general risk factors to individuals, means of identifying risk factors and changeability of risk factors. It provides a chart summarizing the prevalence of...

  • Child and Adolescent Suicide: Epidemiology, Risk Factors, and Approaches to Prevention. Pelkonen, Mirjami; Marttunen, Mauri // Pediatric Drugs;2003, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p243 

    Suicide is rare in childhood and early adolescence, and becomes more frequent with increasing age. The latest mean worldwide annual rates of suicide per 100 000 were 0.5 for females and 0.9 for males among 5–14-year-olds, and 12.0 for females and 14.2 for males among...

  • Ethnic Differences in Suicidal Ideation and Attempts. Perez-Rodriguez, M. Mercedes; Baca-Garcia, Enrique; Oquendo, Maria A.; Blanco, Carlos // Primary Psychiatry;Feb2008, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p44 

    Suicide is one of the leading causes of death, and suicidal ideation and attempts are a major public health concern. However, lithe is known about the relationship between ethnicity and suicidal behaviors. This article provides an update on the relationship between ethnicity and suicidal...

  • The Maudsley long-term follow-up of child and adolescent depression: 2. Suicidality, criminality and social dysfunction in adulthood. Fombonne, Eric; Wostear, Gail; Cooper, Vanessa; Harrington, Richard; Rutter, Michael // British Journal of Psychiatry;Sep2001, Vol. 179, p218 

    Background Strong links exist between juvenile and adult depression, but comorbid conduct disorder may be associated with worse adult social difficulties. Aims To test the impact of comorbid conduct disorder on social adjustment and dysfunction, suicidality and criminality of adults who had had...

  • The rippling effects of suicide. Pahl, Jorg J. // USA Today Magazine;Sep96, Vol. 125 Issue 2616, p62 

    Focuses on suicide in the United States. Number of Americans who experience suicidal ideation as compared to the number who actually commit suicide; Difficulties involved in identifying those who are likely to attempt suicide; The psychological and biological risk factors; Relation of seratonin...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics