Diller, Paul
December 2007
Boston University Law Review;Dec2007, Vol. 87 Issue 5, p1113
Academic Journal
City policy experimentation is a catalyst for change at the state and national levels. From gay rights to the environment to public health, cities and other forms of local government are adopting new and innovative policies in the wake of inaction by the higher levels of government. The legality of these policies is frequently challenged, however, by claims that a city's ordinance has been preempted by state law. Despite the crucial importance of intrastate preemption to the question of city power, it has heretofore received scant academic attention. This paper demonstrates how, as currently applied, intrastate preemption dampens local policy innovation, which has a negative effect on the state and national political processes. It argues that state courts, drawing on their institutional advantages, should take a new approach to intrastate preemption that facilitates good-faith policy experimentation by cities, while discouraging parochial and exclusionary municipal action.


Related Articles

  • FIELD PREEMPTION AND THE PRESUMPTION OF FEDERAL ACTION: A THREE-WAY SUPREMACY CLAUSE TUG OF WAR. Zeis Jr., Joseph E. // University of Dayton Law Review;2016, Vol. 41 Issue 1, p157 

    The article focuses on the topical incidents of state government stymied by field preemption and the system that embodies dual citizenship and states have express needs and responsibilities to their citizens under state law and restrictions under the Constitution.

  • The problem concerning provincial powers. Robson, Ian // Politeia (02568845);2009, Vol. 28 Issue 3, p5 

    Some two years ago, the government announced a 'policy process' concerning provincial and local government. The background document issued at the time leaves little doubt that there is serious concern in government circles regarding the country's system of provincial government, to the extent of...

  • The Anti-Subordination Principle of Labor and Employment Law Preemption. Fisk, Catherine L. // Harvard Law & Policy Review;Jan2011, Vol. 5 Issue 1, p1 

    An essay is presented regarding the anti-subordination theory of preemption of local law by the federal law. It explores the local labor initiatives in Southern California and provides a factual context to understand the need for a new approach for the preemption of labor and employment law....

  • PREEMPTION AND INSTITUTIONAL CHOICE. Merrill, Thomas W. // Northwestern University Law Review;2008 Special Issue, Vol. 102 Issue 2, p727 

    The article presents information on institutional choice analysis of the law of preemption in the U.S. The insight of Stephen Gardbaum on the nature of preemption reveals that preemption entails far more than the idea that federal law prevails over state law cases of conflict. It is inferred...

  • MONOPHONIC PREEMPTION. Schapiro, Robert A. // Northwestern University Law Review;2008 Special Issue, Vol. 102 Issue 2, p811 

    The article presents information on the normative theory of preemption within a broader theory of federalism in the U.S. The polyphonic conception of federalism has several important implications for understading preemption. The limitations on the constitutional power of the national government...

  • Threading the Needle: State Immigration-Related Employment Laws Surviving a Federal Preemption Analysis. Sherwood, Christopher M. // Wyoming Law Review;2012, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p253 

    The author discusses the aspects of illegal immigration and its effect on the economy. He mentions the need of active and effective enforcement of federal immigration law or state immigration-related law because of the negative economic effects of undocumented immigrants. Also discussed is the...

  • McCarran-Ferguson Reverse Preemption.  // Dispute Resolution Journal;Feb-Apr2012, Vol. 67 Issue 1, p92 

    The article focuses on the U.S. court case Southern Pioneer Life Ins. Co. v. Thomas, which dealt with federal preemption of state law. Topics include the Arkansas McCarran-Ferguson Act, the Arkansas Uniform Arbitration Act (AAUA), and the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA). Information is provided on...

  • Agency Appraisal. WILLIAMSON, LAUREN // InsideCounsel;Aug2009, Vol. 20 Issue 212, p30 

    The article focuses on an order by U.S. President Barack Obama to review pre-emption clauses under federal rules created since 1999. According to Obama, federal agencies can pre-empt state laws only when there is sufficient legal basis for displacement. The move of Obama has reversed a policy of...

  • The Silent Sovereign: Tipping the Scales in Reverse-Erie Applications of Indian Law. VAN WIEREN, AMANDA // Oregon Law Review;2012, Vol. 91 Issue 1, p297 

    The article focuses on the application of the Eerie Doctrine, which is a law stating that federal courts must apply state substantive law in cases of diversity jurisdiction, in Indiana. Topics include federal preemption of state law, the status of tribal nations under U.S. law, and the rules of...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics