TITLE

DISSONANT HARMONIZATION: LIMITATIONS ON "CASH N' CARRY" CREATIVITY

AUTHOR(S)

Long, Doris Estelle

PUB. DATE

August 2007

SOURCE

Albany Law Review;2007, Vol. 70 Issue 4, p1163

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

Even though creativity lies at the heart of present copyright laws, the impulse to create--or more precisely what triggers such creativity--remains largely unexamined. Coinciding with the digital demand for access to information, new standards for "cash 'n' carry" creativity are being urged with little regard to what level of authorial control may be required to ensure continued enrichment of the public domain through the creation of vibrant new works. Scientific, psychological, and sociological studies indicate that "cash 'n' carry" creativity fails to implement the critical triggering mechanisms for the creative impulse. Moreover, such "cash 'n' carry" attitudes toward authors' rights threaten to establish new international harmonization standards that continue the inequality of earlier protection regimes. Instead of freeing works for the public domain, current movements such as "access to knowledge," if not carefully circumscribed in the copyright area, may adversely impact efforts by developing nations and previously excluded voices to protect local creative industries. Dissonances between the roles of culture industries in economic development, and perceived boundaries of the public domain, must be respected. In fact, new international standards for the protection of "authors' rights" should actually be broadened in certain instances to allow protection for those voices whose creative works have been excluded or ignored in previous regimes, including protection for indigenous works of folklore and other traditional cultural expressions, and for works whose intellectual creativity has been previously under appreciated, including traditional "women's arts." Ultimately "cash 'n' carry" creativity as an international standard, without sufficient calibration for cultural and other dissonances, will only continue to marginalize the already-excluded. Effective harmonization requires more.

ACCESSION #

28811226

 

Related Articles

• Hollywood eyes fate of copyright law.  // Daily Variety;9/30/2011, Vol. 312 Issue 59, p2 

  The article reports that a group of home video distributors, educators, and orchestra conductors in the U.S. are challenging the constitutionality of the 1994 act of Congress concerning the restoration of copyright laws which have fallen into public domain.

• Your Legal Companion. Fishman, Stephen // Public Domain: How to Find & Use Copyright Free Writings, Music,;Jun2012, p1 

  An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including copyright law, legal rules in works first published abroad, and the duration of copyright protection.

• PROTECTING A DELICATE BALANCE: FACTS, IDEAS, AND EXPRESSION IN COMPILATION COPYRIGHT CASES. Bunker, Matthew D.; Bolger, Bethany // Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly;Spring2003, Vol. 80 Issue 1, p183 

  Analyzes the fact/expression and idea/expression dichotomies, two of copyright law's significant doctrines for preserving a vibrant public domain and protecting free expression interests. Fundamental principle of copyright law; Problems associated with the application of the two dichotomies to...

• Your Legal Companion. Fishman, Stephen // Public Domain: How to Find & Use Copyright-Free Writings, Music,;2014, p1 

  An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including public domain, copyright law, and choreography.

• Index. Fishman, Stephen // Public Domain: How to Find & Use Copyright-Free Writings, Music,;2014, p423 

  A subject index for the book "Public Domain: How to Find & Use Copyright-Free Writings, Music, Art & More" is presented.

• Images and Copyright.  // Online;Jan/Feb2002, Vol. 26 Issue 1, p31 

  Discusses copyright issues for online images. Excerpt from a copyright notice from Lycos; Factor to consider when using images for professional purposes; Example of online images that are in the public domain and copyright-free.

• Copyright snarl for U.S. museums. Robinson, Walter // Art in America;Oct95, Vol. 83 Issue 10, p31 

  Informs about the new rule that restores copyrights to certain foreign works that are in the public domain in the US from the start of 1996, due to a provision of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade. Impact of same on museums, artists and others; Illustration of same with the example of...

• Global commons, public space and contemporary IPR. Liang, Lawrence // Media Development;2003, Vol. 50 Issue 1, p29 

  Focuses on the issue of global commons in the context of the politics of intellectual property rights (IPR) in software and cyberspace. Result of the expansion of IPR into public life; Reasons for outlining the history of the common concept; Application of public domain in India.

• Europeana Helps Clarify the Importance of Public Domain.  // Online;Jul/Aug2010, Vol. 34 Issue 4, p6 

  The article reports that Europe's digital library, museum and archive Europeana.eu has published the Public Domain Charter to clarify the importance of public domain.

Read the Article