The virtues of belief: toward a non-evidentialist ethics of belief-formation

Amesbury, Richard
February 2008
International Journal for Philosophy of Religion;Feb2008, Vol. 63 Issue 1-3, p25
Academic Journal
William Kingdon Clifford famously argued that “it is wrong always, everywhere, and for anyone, to believe anything upon insufficient evidence.” His ethics of belief can be construed as involving two distinct theses—a moral claim (that it is wrong to hold beliefs to which one is not entitled) and an epistemological claim (that entitlement is always a function of evidential support). Although I reject the (universality of the) epistemological claim, I argue that something deserving of the name ethics of belief can nevertheless be preserved. However, in the second half of the paper I argue that Clifford’s response to the problem of unethical belief is insufficiently attentive to the role played by self-deception in the formation of unethical beliefs. By contrasting the first-person perspective of a doxastic agent with the third-person perspective of an outside observer, I argue that unethical belief is a symptom of deficiencies of character: fix these, and belief will fix itself. I suggest that the moral intuitions implicit in our response to examples of unethical belief (like Clifford’s famous example of the ship owner) can better be accounted for in terms of a non-evidentialist virtue ethics of belief-formation, and that such an account can survive the rejection of strong versions of doxastic voluntarism.


Related Articles

  • CRIME CONTROL IN JAPAN. Shain, I. J. // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Mar1977, Vol. 68 Issue 1, p166 

    Reviews the book "Crime Control in Japan," by William Clifford.

  • AN INTRODUCTION TO AFRICAN CRIMINOLOGY. Baunach, Phyllis Jo // Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology;Sep1977, Vol. 68 Issue 3, p466 

    Reviews the book "An Introduction to African Criminology," by William Clifford.

  • THE COWARD'S ATONEMENT.  // Image;Jan1958, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p17 

    The article reviews the film "THE COWARD'S ATONEMENT," directed by Francis Ford and starring William Clifford and Raymond Myers.

  • Clifford Algebras in Mathematics and Applied Sciences. Sprössig, Wolfgang; Gürlebeck, Klaus // AIP Conference Proceedings;9/6/2007, Vol. 936 Issue 1, p709 

    The article presents information on Clifford algebras, which is a useful tool in multidimensional applied sciences. Invented by William Kingdom Clifford in 1878, Clifford algebras play an important role in a wide range of multidimensional mathematical, physical and engineering topics....

  • Message Board.  // Bank Technology News;Jul2006, Vol. 19 Issue 7, p14 

    The article presents quotes from notable people in IT. Aperture CEO William Clifford notes that at least half of data centers built for the past five years need refurbishing. Joe Ferra, chief wireless officer of Fidelity eBusiness makes a statement on the data speed expectations of mobile-device...

  • Common Bank Server Strategy: Plug 'N Pray. Fest, Glen // Bank Technology News;Jul2006, Vol. 19 Issue 7, p16 

    The article presents an interview with Aperture CEO William Clifford. When asked why banks should place premium on enterprise infrastructure management of data centers, he emphasizes that server growth has been expanding exponentially. Clifford observes that old data centers hinder banks because...

  • Clifford, William Kingdon (1845 - 1879).  // Hutchinson Dictionary of Scientific Biography;2005, p1 

    English mathematician and scientific philosopher who developed the theory of biquaternions and proved a Riemann surface (see Bernhard Riemann) to be topologically equivalent to a box with holes in it. His name is perpetuated in "Clifford parallels" and "Clifford...

  • Structure and Content in "The Will to Believe". Kasser, Jeffrey L. // Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society;Summer2015, Vol. 51 Issue 3, p320 

    This paper argues that sustained attention to the highlighted structure of William James's "The Will to Believe" yields surprising insights into the essay. "Highlighted structure" includes James's announcements of his intentions, his section breaks, and, especially, patterns of repetition and...

  • CLIFFORD, William Kingdon (1845-79). Madigan, Timothy J. // Continuum Encyclopedia of British Philosophy;2006, Vol. 1, p641 

    An encyclopedia entry for British philosopher William Kingdon Clifford is presented. Clifford was born on May 4, 1845 in Exeter, England and died on March 3, 1879 in Madeira, Portugal. It provides background on his family, education and career as a mathematician and educator. His philosophical...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics