TITLE

THE FIELD OF MANAGEMENT'S DEVOTION TO THEORY: TOO MUCH OF A GOOD THING?

AUTHOR(S)

HAMBRICK, DONALD C.

PUB. DATE

December 2007

SOURCE

Academy of Management Journal;Dec2007, Vol. 50 Issue 6, p1346

SOURCE TYPE

Academic Journal

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

The article examines whether the discipline of management science has placed an undue emphasis on the development of theory at the expense of research which observes and reports actual facts. It is well known that the leading scholarly periodicals in the field require articles to contribute to management science theory to be accepted for publication. This unnecessarily limits research, since the collection of previously unknown facts by itself will contribute to the development of theory. The bad effect forced theoretical discussion has on the comprehensibility and readability of academic writing is noted. Articles in scholarly periodicals in related fields such as marketing research and finance which introduce previously unknown facts are presented as a comparison. There is said to be an inherent contradiction in the emphasis of pure theory in a field devoted to the study of real world decision making.

ACCESSION #

28166119

Tags: MANAGEMENT science -- Research;  LEARNING & scholarship -- Social aspects;  COMMUNICATION in learning & scholarship;  SCHOLARLY periodicals -- Editing;  SCHOLARLY publishing -- Evaluation;  MANAGEMENT -- Study & teaching (Higher)

 

Related Articles

• UNA APUESTA AL FUTURO. Quintanilla, Susana // Revista Mexicana de Investigaci�n Educativa;2008, Vol. 13 Issue 37, p341 

  No abstract available.

• TIME FLIES WHEN YOU'RE HAVING FUN: AMJ, 2005-2007. RYNES, SARA L. // Academy of Management Journal;Dec2007, Vol. 50 Issue 6, p1273 

  The author offers opinions on her tenure as editor of the publication from 2005-2007. The editorial board's goals of making the publication of more professional interest, of increasing the transparency of its review process, and of making it more internationally focused are given, and the steps...

• EDITOR'S COMMENTS. Hillman, Amy // Academy of Management Review;Jan2009, Vol. 34 Issue 1, p7 

  The author offers opinions on management science and communication in the scholarship of that discipline. The role of scholarly periodicals in promoting communication between scholars and managers themselves is seen as highly important. The need for communication between scholars in different...

• From the Editor: Reflections on the Review Process. Kohli, Ajay K // Journal of Marketing;Nov2011, Vol. 75 Issue 6, p1 

  The author offers opinions on the editing of the publication. He announces that this issue will be his last as editor in chief of the publication, and thanks other editors and peer reviewers for their contributions during his tenure. Pride is expressed in the publication's status among marketing...

• How Not to Get Published. Martin, Jim // American Journalism;Summer2010, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p5 

  The author offers opinions on academic writing and the editing of scholarly periodicals. Suggestions, some humorous in nature, are made to writers on writing techniques or personal communication methods to avoid when seeking to be published in this publication or others. These include using the...

• State of the Journal. Erdem, T�lin // Journal of Marketing Research (JMR);Dec2010, Vol. 47 Issue 6, p997 

  The author offers opinions and presents information on the publication. An increase in the pages published by the periodical in 2010 is cited, as is an increase in the number of articles submitted for peer review and publication. Special issues of the publication planned for 2011 on consumer...

• Editorial Note. Sambamurthy, Vallabh // Information Systems Research;Jun2008, Vol. 19 Issue 2, p125 

  The article announces that the publication's reviewing and editing process will change from a single-blind to a double-blind process effective March, 2008. The reasons for the change in policy are given.

• Writing for Publication. HENSON, KENNETH T. // Phi Delta Kappan;Jun2007, Vol. 88 Issue 10, p781 

  The article presents advice for academic writers on getting published. Writers should remember that they are writing for a specific audience that expects a specific style and are interested in a specific content. Many writers attempt to please editors, but editors have their audience in mind and...

• Aims and Scope: UNLV Gaming Research & Review Journal. McNeal, Betty // UNLV Gaming Research & Review Journal;2008, Vol. 12 Issue 1/2, p63 

  The article presents the mission statement of the publication. Its aims in furthering knowledge created by gambling research are given. The editorial policies regarding articles submitted for publication are presented. Academic disciplines which are related to research on legal gambling are...

Read the Article