'Excessive and Unreasonable': The Politics of the Scottish Hit List

Midwinter, Arthur; Keating, Michael; Taylor, Peter
September 1983
Political Studies;Sep83, Vol. 31 Issue 3, p394
Academic Journal
The Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) (Scotland) Act marks a major change in central-local relations in allowing selective intervention in the expenditure decisions of individual councils. The criteria for action, based upon the concept of 'excessive and unreasonable' expenditure are broadly drawn. In taking action against seven councils in 1981-2, the Scottish Office applied its own criteria inconsistently. The case against the councils tacked intellectual credibility and an alternative 'hit list' could as plausibly be produced. The councils' reactions and the exchanges with the Scottish Office show a varied pattern, with a minority stressing the principle of local autonomy. The Act has failed to achieve the objectives which central government appeared to have in mind. It has, instead, further eroded local autonomy and destabilized central-local relations in Scotland.


Related Articles

  • Materiality and Governmental Financial Statements. Loyd, D. Scot; Crawford, Michael A. // Miller GAAP Update Service;10/30/2004, Vol. 4 Issue 20, p1 

    Focuses on materiality and governmental financial statements. Modification of the governmental financial reporting model by the Governmental Accounting Standards Board; Sections found in financial statements; Preparation of financial statements.

  • Laboratories of Democracy. Schultz, David // Public Integrity;Spring2004, Vol. 6 Issue 2, p115 

    Drawing upon a recent study of state and local government efforts to regulate money in politics, this article demonstrates that state campaigns and elections are increasingly facing the same problems with money and politics that federal races confront. The analysis also reveals that while many...

  • Expenditures and receipts in state and local government finances: Reply. Marlow, Michael L.; Manage, Neela // Public Choice;Dec1988, Vol. 59 Issue 3, p287 

    Presents a reply by Michael L. Marlow and Neela Manage to the comments of Abdur R. Chowdhury on their article "Expenditures and Recipients: Testing for Causality in State and Local Government Finances," published in the 1987 issue of the journal "Public Choice." Evaluation of the univariate and...

  • EFEKTYWNOŚĆ DZIAŁANIA JEDNOSTEK SAMORZÄ„DU TERYTORIALNEGO. Skica, Tomasz // Research Papers of the Wroclaw University of Economics / Prace N;2012 Part 2, Issue 271, p306 

    The article discusses the issue of the effectiveness of local government units. It consists of three parts. The first is a review of definition approaches in the area of efficiency. The second identifies the sources of inefficiency in local government. The third part of the article includes the...

  • Counties win reprieve. Wild, Damian // Public Finance;11/4/94, p15 

    Discusses the implications of the British government's decision to retain county councils. Restatement of British ministers commitment to unitary authorities; Decline of support for unitary authorities; Comment by Robin Wendt, Association of County Councils (ACC) secretary; Factors causing the...

  • The Advisory Referendum in America. Goldman, Ralph M. // Public Opinion Quarterly;Summer50, Vol. 14 Issue 2, p303 

    The advisory referendum, wherein voters make their views known on important issues without thereby binding legislation to action, has been used by a considerable number of state and local governments in the U.S. The earliest examples go back to the 18th century, but a number of states and cities...

  • 10th Amendment Turf War. Kettl, Donald F. // Governing;Oct1998, Vol. 12 Issue 1, p13 

    Discusses the relationship between the federal and state governments in the U.S. under the 10th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution as of October 1998. Rule under the amendment; Implication of the amendment for federal and state responsibilities; Issue raised by state legislators upon the...

  • Municipal Home Rule in California III. Peppin, John C. // California Law Review;Dec44, Vol. 32 Issue 4, p341 

    Discusses section 11 of Article XI of the California Constitution on municipal home rule. Scope of the grant of power contained in section 11; Type of general laws of the state legislature which is apparently no longer deemed a general law within section 11; Main problems presented in...

  • Local self-governments in Hungary and in Croatia. Bakota, Boris; Fábián, Adrián; Ljubanović, Boris // Proceedings of the Conference on Contemporary Legal Challenges: ;2012, p287 

    The article presents a discussion on local self-governments in Croatia and Hungary. Topics discussed include Fundamental Law regulations such as the implication of transformed Constitution, the new Constitution's general regulations, and the duties and authority of local self-governments. Also...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics