Patients Who Complete Advance Directives and What They Prefer

Nishimura, Adam; Mueller, Paul S.; Evenson, Laura K.; Downer, Lisa L.; Bowron, Catherine T.; Thieke, Michael P.; Wrobleski, Diane M.; Crowley, Mary E.
December 2007
Mayo Clinic Proceedings;Dec2007, Vol. 82 Issue 12, p1480
Academic Journal
OBJECTIVE: To determine health care preferences expressed by patients in advance directives (ADs) and to identify characteristics of patients who completed them. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A computer-generated random sample of 500 patients was selected from the 25,865 (margin of error, ±4.34%) unique patients who submitted ADs to Mayo Clinic Rochester between January 1, 2004, and July 1, 2005. After excluding 24 (4.8%) patients who had submitted documents related to financial and property matters instead of ADs, we analyzed the contents of the 476 ADs and the demographic features of the patients to whom the documents belonged. RESULTS: The median (range) age of the patients at the time they signed their respective ADs was 67 (19-97) years. Of the 476 study patients, 409 (91.3%) were high school graduates; 339 (71.2%) had submitted a combined AD, which has features of a living will and a health care power of attorney; 434 (91.2%) had designated a health care agent; and most had granted the agent powers to consent for procedures (340 [78.3%]), to access information (327 [75.3%]), and to withhold and withdraw life-sustaining treatments (337 [77.6%]). Most patients expressed a desire for pain control (308 [64.7%]). For the clinical situations of dying or permanent unconsciousness, most patients explicitly expressed a preference to avoid "general life support" (371 [77.9%]) but did not explicitly address common life-sustaining treatments, including cardiopulmonary resuscitation, mechanical ventilation, hemodialysis, blood transfusion, and artificial nutrition and hydration (if they did, nearly all expressed a preference to avoid the treatments). CONCLUSION: In ADs submitted to our institution, most patients designated a health care agent and granted the agent broad decision-making powers. Although most expressed a desire to avoid "general life support" If dying or permanently unconscious, few expressed preferences regarding specific life-sustaining treatments. Patients, clinicians, and others who use ADs, and investigators contemplating research involving ADs, might find these results Informative.


Related Articles

  • Will a Patient Preference Predictor Improve Treatment Decision Making for Incapacitated Patients? Rid, Annette // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Apr2014, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p99 

    An introduction is presented in which the editor discusses various reports within the issue on topics including advanced care planning, advanced directors and treatment decision making.

  • Promoting a patient's right to autonomy: implications for primary healthcare practitioners. Part 2. Taylor, Helen // Primary Health Care;Apr2014, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p34 

    The aim of this second of two articles is to consider a range of situations in which practitioners may find respecting an adult patient's right to autonomy challenging. There will be opportunities to reflect on practice, and consider how best to manage such situations should they arise....

  • Advance Directive from the Romanian Social Cultural Perspective. DUMITRAS, Silvia; ENACHE, Mariana; PÂRVU, Andrada; MOISÂ, Stefana Maria; IOV, Cătălin; IOAN, Beatrice // Postmodern Openings / Deschideri Postmoderne;Mar2013, Vol. 4 Issue 1, p87 

    Giving value to the wishes of the terminal patients regarding the treatment at the end of their life, the use of the advance directive, as an extension of their autonomy when the patients are incompetent, represents a mean to respect and promote their dignity. The authors present and discuss the...

  • Treatment Decision Making for Incapacitated Patients: Is Development and Use of a Patient Preference Predictor Feasible? Rid, Annette; Wendler, David // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Apr2014, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p130 

    It has recently been proposed to incorporate the use of a “Patient Preference Predictor” (PPP) into the process of making treatment decisions for incapacitated patients. A PPP would predict which treatment option a given incapacitated patient would most likely prefer, based on the...

  • Law, Ethics, and the Patient Preference Predictor. Dresser, Rebecca // Journal of Medicine & Philosophy;Apr2014, Vol. 39 Issue 2, p178 

    The Patient Preference Predictor (PPP) is intended to improve treatment decision making for incapacitated patients. The PPP would collect information about the treatment preferences of people with different demographic and other characteristics. It could be used to indicate which treatment...

  • Employing Behavioral Economics And Decision Science In Crucial Choices At End Of Life.  // Health Affairs;Dec2012, Vol. 31 Issue 12, p2789 

    The article focuses on the use of behavioral economics and decision science in crucial choices at the end-of-life stage by using a program created by physician Scott Halpern, called "Fostering Improvement in End-Of-Life Decision Science" (FIELDS), that employs multidisciplinary teams to assist...

  • Lasting power of attorney: a significant ethical responsibility. Lund, Samantha // British Journal of Hospital Medicine (17508460);Sep2015, Vol. 76 Issue 9, p518 

    A lasting power of attorney makes decisions for another person who lacks the capacity to make the decision him-/herself. There are significant ethical issues which must be considered, not only so that the decision made is morally robust but also so that the individuals entrusted with this...

  • Mental capacity, legal competence and consent to treatment. Buchanan, Alec // Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine;Sep2004, Vol. 97 Issue 9, p415 

    Deciding whether someone is legally competent to make decisions regarding their own treatment requires an assessment of their mental capacity. The assessed capacity required for legal competence increases with the seriousness of what is at stake. The usual explanation is that patient autonomy is...

  • SESSION PLANNING. Thompson, Diana // Massage & Bodywork;May/Jun2010, Vol. 25 Issue 3, p114 

    The article focuses on making informed decisions planning in treating an older population in terms of massage therapy. It stresses the importance of research when it comes to therapy sessions with the older adult population. It suggests to determine the demographic information in the subject...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics