The value of multiple tests of respiratory muscle strength

Steier, Joerg; Kaul, Sunny; Seymour, John; Jolley, Caroline; Rafferty, Gerrard; Man, William; Luo, Yuan M.; Roughton, Michael; Polkey, Michael I.; Moxham, John
November 2007
Thorax;Nov2007, Vol. 62 Issue 11, p975
Academic Journal
Background: Respiratory muscle weakness is an important clinical problem. Tests of varying complexity and invasiveness are available to assess respiratory muscle strength. The relative precision of different tests in the detection of weakness is less clear, as is the value of multiple tests. Methods: The respiratory muscle function tests of clinical referrals who had multiple tests assessed in our laboratories over a 6-year period were analysed. Thresholds for weakness for each test were determined from published and in-house laboratory data. The patients were divided into three groups: those who had all relevant measurements of global inspiratory muscle strength (group A, n = 182), those with full assessment of diaphragm strength (group B, n = 264) and those for whom expiratory muscle strength was fully evaluated (group C, n = 60). The diagnostic outcome of each inspiratory, diaphragm and expiratory muscle test, both singly and in combination, was studied and the impact of using more than one test to detect weakness was calculated. Results: The clinical referrals were primarily for the evaluation of neuromuscular diseases and dyspnoea of unknown cause. A low maximal inspiratory mouth pressure (PImax) was recorded in 40.1% of referrals in group A, while a low sniff nasal pressure (Sniff Pnasal) was recorded in 41.8% and a low sniff oesophageal pressure (Sniff Poes) in 37.9%. When assessing inspiratory strength with the combination of all three tests, 29.6% of patients had weakness. Using the two non-invasive tests (PImax and Sniff Pnasal) in combination, a similar result was obtained (low in 32.4%). Combining Sniff Pdi (low in 68.2%) and Twitch Pdi (low in 67.4%) reduced the diagnoses of patients with diaphragm weakness to 55.3% in group B. 38.3% of the patients in group C had expiratory muscle weakness as measured by maximum expiratory pressure (PEmax) compared with 36.7% when weakness was diagnosed by cough gastric pressure (Pgas), and 28.3% when assessed by Twitch T10. Combining all three expiratory muscle tests reduced the number of patients diagnosed as having expiratory muscle weakness to 16.7%. Conclusion: The use of single tests such as PImax, PEmax and other available individual tests of inspiratory, diaphragm and expiratory muscle strength tends to overdiagnose weakness. Combinations of tests increase diagnostic precision and, in the population studied, they reduced the diagnosis of inspiratory, specific diaphragm and expiratory muscle weakness by 19-56%. Measuring both PImax and Sniff Pnasal resulted in a relative reduction of 19.2% of patients falsely diagnosed with inspiratory muscle weakness. The addition of Twitch Pdi to Sniff Pdi increased diagnostic precision by a smaller amount (18.9%). Having multiple tests of respiratory muscle function available both increases diagnostic precision and makes assessment possible in a range of clinical circumstances.


Related Articles

  • Qualify of life and palliation predict survival in patients with chronic alveolar hypoventilation and nocturnal ventilatory support. Olofson, Jan; Dellborg, Catharina; Sullivan, Marianne; Midgren, Bengt; Caro, Oscar; Bergman, Bengt // Quality of Life Research;Apr2009, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p273 

    Non-invasive positive pressure ventilation (NPPV) improves health-related quality of life (HRQL) in patients with chronic alveolar hypoventilation (CAH). We studied the prognostic impact of HRQL on survival in relation to clinical factors. Forty-four patients with CAH due to post-polio (12),...

  • Lung Volume Recruitment in Multiple Sclerosis. Srour, Nadim; LeBlanc, Carole; King, Judy; McKim, Douglas A. // PLoS ONE;Jan2013, Vol. 8 Issue 1, Special section p1 

    Introduction: Pulmonary function abnormalities have been described in multiple sclerosis including reductions in forced vital capacity (FVC) and cough but the time course of this impairment is unknown. Peak cough flow (PCF) is an important parameter for patients with respiratory muscle weakness...

  • Adding muscle to neuromuscular degeneration investigation.  // Journal of Clinical Investigation;Aug2004, Vol. 114 Issue 3, p310 

    The article reports that, a new, noninvasive method, called electrical impedance myography (EIM), which is now undergoing detailed testing in patients, holds promise as an accurate and painless means to assess muscle tissue characteristics. EIM takes advantage of a fundamental trait of skeletal...

  • The Novel 10-Item Asthma Prediction Tool: External Validation in the German MAS Birth Cohort. Grabenhenrich, Linus B.; Reich, Andreas; Fischer, Felix; Zepp, Fred; Forster, Johannes; Schuster, Antje; Bauer, Carl-Peter; Bergmann, Renate L.; Bergmann, Karl E.; Wahn, Ulrich; Keil, Thomas; Lau, Susanne // PLoS ONE;Dec2014, Vol. 9 Issue 12, p1 

    Background: A novel non-invasive asthma prediction tool from the Leicester Cohort, UK, forecasts asthma at age 8 years based on 10 predictors assessed in early childhood, including current respiratory symptoms, eczema, and parental history of asthma. Objective: We aimed to externally validate...

  • Predictive Factors for Reintubation following Noninvasive Ventilation in Patients with Respiratory Complications after Living Donor Liver Transplantation. Chihara, Yuichi; Egawa, Hiroto; Oga, Toru; Tsuboi, Tomomasa; Handa, Tomohiro; Yagi, Shintaro; Iida, Taku; Yoshizawa, Atsushi; Yamamoto, Kazuhiko; Mishima, Michiaki; Tanaka, Koichi; Uemoto, Shinji; Chin, Kazuo // PLoS ONE;Dec2013, Vol. 8 Issue 12, p1 

    Background: Postoperative respiratory complications are a major cause of mortality following liver transplantation (LT). Noninvasive ventilation (NIV) appears to be effective for respiratory complications in patients undergoing solid organ transplantation; however, mortality has been high in...

  • Effects of Pillar implants for sleep-related breathing disorders on middle ear function. Lin, Hsin-Ching; Friedman, Michael; Chang, Hsueh-Wen; Lai, Chi-Chih; Chin, Chien-Hung; Lin, Meng-Chih; Pott, Thomas; Samuelson, Christian // European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology;Aug2013, Vol. 270 Issue 8, p2339 

    Pillar implants provide a reasonable outcome with minimal post-operative morbidity and complications in treating patients with sleep-disordered breathing (SDB) who had obvious palatal obstruction. The palatal structure is responsible for a normal functioning Eustachian tube; however, little is...

  • Modeling and Simulation of Physical Parameters of Human Respiratory System. MEIRELES, Catarina; MACHADO, José; LEÃO, Celina P. // Applied Mechanics & Materials;2014, Issue 658-659, p447 

    The respiratory system, due to its non-linear behaviour, is of difficult representation through fixed physical components and common control systems. Therefore, mathematical equations, that represents the respiratory cycle; mechanical components, giving dimension and movement to the simulator;...

  • What is Myasthenia Gravis and What Causes it?  // Tennessee Tribune;6/5/2014, Vol. 25 Issue 23, p10B 

    The article offers information on myasthenia gravis, a chronic condition in which proximal muscles weaken, and mentions the causes, diagnosis, and pathophysiology of the condition.

  • The Critical Role of Insulin-Like Growth Factor-1 Isoforms in the Physiopathology of Skeletal Muscle. Musaro, A.; Rosenthal, N. // Current Genomics;Mar2006, Vol. 7 Issue 1, p19 

    The prolongation of skeletal muscle strength in aging and neuromuscular disease has been the objective of numerous studies employing a variety of approaches. To date however, efforts to prevent or attenuate age- or disease-related muscle degeneration have been largely unsuccessful. Cell-based...


Read the Article


Sign out of this library

Other Topics