TITLE

Etzioni's new theory: a synthesis of liberal and communitarian views

AUTHOR(S)
Schilcher, Bernd
PUB. DATE
August 1999
SOURCE
Journal of Socio-Economics;1999, Vol. 28 Issue 4, p429
SOURCE TYPE
Academic Journal
DOC. TYPE
Article
ABSTRACT
There has always been a rather strong contrast between liberal and communitarian views. The liberal doctrine of "irreversible plurality of philosophical and moral ideas" for instance does not only mean that consensus about social values is difficult. "A public consensus about the necessary conception of the good cannot be obtained," says Rawls. On the other hand, communitarians such as MacIntyre, Sandel, and Walzer, are deeply convinced by the idea of an "immanent telos" of societies, which in their opinion have the utmost influence on the development of individuals. A similar strong contrast exists between the liberal universalism of values and the communitarian particularism. Etzioni's New Theory now tries to overcome these unsatisfactory "tyrannies of dualism" (A. Gutmann) Instead of the traditional and hostile either- or, Etzioni puts a reconciliatory as well as. "As many other dichotomies the dualism between universalism and particularism stands in the way of the development of a social Paradigm," he regrets. Therefore Etzioni wants to combine instead of dividing. For example, social order (communitarian value) and personal autonomy (liberal value). So he proposes to install more personal autonomy in states with strong social order, as for instance Japan, and he demands more social order in traditional individualistic states like the United States ("Inverse Symbiosis"). Such "combining and balancing solutions" coincide with the theory of a "Flexible System of Private Rights" created and proposed by the famous Austrian Legal Scholar Walter Wilburg. On the level of "value principles" in the sense of Ronald Dworkin (instead of "rules" of law), Wilburg combines the differing "weights and strengths" of values (elements). An example of this is negligence, dangerous behavior, and economic capacity of risk spreading to more or less far reaching compensations of private damages, instead of the traditional either-or. The underlying idea is that of proportion. In term...
ACCESSION #
2748015

 

Related Articles

  • The Global Community, Religion, and Education: The Modernity of Dewey's Social Philosophy. Tr�hler, Daniel // Studies in Philosophy & Education;Mar2000, Vol. 19 Issue 1/2, p159 

    As a starting point this paper takes Dewey's nowadays often stressed modernity and examines his social philosophy against the background of the current debates on republicanism and communitarianism. Particularly, the anaysis of Dewey's The Public and its Problem (1927) concludes that the...

  • Crisis, what crisis? Leadbeater, Charles // New Statesman;6/28/96, Vol. 125 Issue 4290, p17 

    Comments on the debate between liberals and communitarians over the state of the British economy. Liberalism's central claim that social progress is best measured by the expansion of choice; Overstated case against economic liberalism; Flaw of candidates to replace the market as the guiding...

  • Reform Liberalism Reconsidered. Cha, In-Suk // Diogenes;2000, Vol. 48 Issue 192, p97 

    Reconsiders reform liberalism in the United States. Persistence of the liberal-communitarian debate in social and political philosophy during the 1980s; Advocacy of the values of capitalism and liberalism in reform liberalism; Conception of big government.

  • Particular Values and Critical Morality. Waldron, Jeremy // California Law Review;May89, Vol. 77 Issue 3, p561 

    Criticizes the idea of communitarianism. Concept of communitarianism; Communitarian response to critical liberalism; Details on the framework for analyzing the communitarian response.

  • Liberal Kamusal Alan: Rawls'un Uzlasimci Liberal K�lt�r�. M�ft�oglu, Aydin // Sivil Toplum: Dusunce & Aastirma Dergisi;2003, Vol. 1 Issue 2, p31 

    The liberal tradition, always defined the public realm stemming from different social problems. In our age, the liberal thinkers needed to redefine the public realm stemming from present social problems. The demands for equality in liberal democracies implied that the concept of public realm...

  • KAIROS OF HISTORICAL ALTERNATIVE: LIBERALISM, GLOBALISM, TERRORISM--OR METANOIA, DIALOGUE, SYNERGY, SYMPATHY, UNIVERSAL CIVILIZATION.  // Dialogue & Universalism;2001, Vol. 11 Issue 11/12, p5 

    Editorial. Introduces a series of articles published in the 2001 issue of the journal 'Dialogue and Universalism.' Focus on the history of Kairos; Lists of concepts on intellectual conscience of the world; Impact of terrorism on liberalism.

  • BAKHTINIAN THOUGHT AND THE DEFENCE OF NARRATIVE: OVERCOMING UNIVERSALISM AND RELATIVISM. Owen, Hana M. // Cosmos & History;2011, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p136 

    In light of continuing global issues including the prevalence of various levels and forms of inequality and increased environmental destruction, there is a growing recognition of the limitations, epistemological, political, social, cultural, ethical and ecological, of the modes of thought that...

  • Sociology Making a Difference. Wood, Brennon // New Zealand Sociology;2003, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p24 

    This article offers a reflection on sociology. The difference that sociology makes is on the agenda and difference is not a simple concept. According to the tenets of academic purism, sociologists make a difference by constituting a unique discipline within the epistemic manifold of the...

  • NEW PUBLIC MANAGEMENT:AN EXAMINATION OF ITS INFLUENCE ON CONTEMPORARY PUBLIC AFFAIRS AND ITS IMPACT ON SHAPING THE INTELLECTUAL AGENDA OF THE FIELD. Ventriss, Curtis // Administrative Theory & Praxis (Administrative Theory & Praxis);Sep2000, Vol. 22 Issue 3, p500 

    This paper contends that an effective way to examine new public management and its assumptions is by focusing on its relationship to the public philosophy of modern liberalism. It will also be argued that while the New Public Management may be effective in addressing certain administrative...

Share

Read the Article

Courtesy of VIRGINIA BEACH PUBLIC LIBRARY AND SYSTEM

Sign out of this library

Other Topics