Risk Behavior in Response to Quotas and Contests

Gaba, Anil; Kaira, Ajay
September 1999
Marketing Science;1999, Vol. 18 Issue 3, p417
Academic Journal
Much of the salesforce compensation literature has focused on developing incentive schemes to maximize effort levels on the part of the salesforce. The amount of effort to expend in the selling task is considered to be the sole decision variable for a sales representative. In this paper, we introduce another key decision variable for a sales representative which is how much risk to undertake in the selling task. In other words, we consider the fact that for a sales representative "riskiness" of performance (e.g.. the dispersion of the probability distribution for sales) is often a choice and not a given fate. For example, a sales representative, Irving to increase sales, may have the choice of allocating a given amount of effort on the low-risk approach of pursuing a small set of existing customers or incur the same effort on the high-risk option of getting new larger customers to switch from competitors. This paper examples how decisions on risk behavior on the part of the sales representatives are influenced by compensation schemes. We show that such decisions are sensitive to the payoff structure when a quota-based or a rank- order contest-based compensation scheme is used. More specifically, we argue that a high quota level or a rank-order contest where only the top few win induce sales representatives to opt for high-risk prospects, whereas a low quota level or a rank-order contest where a high proportion win induce sales representatives to opt for low-risk prospects. This does not stem from any kind of violation of standard expected utility theory but arises from the specific a structure of jumps in payoffs It is not that the inherent risk, attitudes of the sales representatives are being altered. Rather, under some quota and contest conditions, a more risk prospect may yield higher expected utility for an inherently risk- averse sales representative while under some other quota and contest conditions, a less risky prospect may lead to a higher expected utility for an inherently risk-seeking sales representative. The theoretical propositions are tested in a series of five experiments The first two experiments test the theoretical results of quota-based compensation. The quota levels arc manipulated. Subjects select between segment types where the mean expected sales are the same but the variance varies. The next two experiments test the risk behavior of subjects in contest-based incentive schemes when the proportion of winners in the contest is manipulated. The results provide strong support for our models, with only a few subjects departing from the theoretical predictions. A fifth experiment shows some cognitive response data to explain the behavior that is inconsistent with the theoretical predictions. This paper provides implications that are useful for managers who design compensation schemes. A common assumption in most normative models on salesforce compensation is that all sales representatives are either risk averse or risk neutral. This might often lead to the conclusion that sales representatives cannot be expected to engage in high- risk activities n the absence of a risk premium over and above the compensation scheme. While this may be true if sales representatives are facing only a piece-rate compensation plan, it need not be the case when quota-based or contest-based compensation schemes are used. Our results suggest that when the sales quotas are set "high" or if the proportion of winners in a sales contest is "low", sales representatives may engage in nigh-risk behavior. Alternatively, of the quotas are low" or the proportion of winners in a sales contest is "high", sales representatives may engage in low- risk prospects. Hence, if a firm would like to dampen high- risk behavior on the part of the salesforce, lowering quota level or increasing the proportion of winners in sales contests might do so. Similarly in order to reduce conservatism Towards risk, moving up the quota levels or reducing the proportion of winners in sales contests could be useful. Our results extend beyond just salesforce management, to any situation where payoffs are based on reaching a certain threshold level in performance or are based on relative performance. For example, similar implications hold in tournaments for promotion to a limited number of top management positions in an organization, influencing the portfolio of R&D managers, and so on.


Related Articles

  • Every great salesperson was a beginner at one point.  // njbiz;6/22/2009, Vol. 22 Issue 25, p13 

    The article offers several tips to new salespeople. Beginners are advised to trust their instincts, to be willing to take risks, to be consistent performers and to be friendly and likeable. They should believe that they can do it since mental strength, which stems from their attitude, their...

  • Sales Goals That Motivate. Reilly, Tom // Official Board Markets;12/17/2011, Vol. 87 Issue 51, p6 

    The article discusses the challenges in writing effective sales goals such as the targeted number and the sales goals may focus only on productivity.

  • Selecting Appropriate Sales Quota Plan Structures and Quota-Setting Procedures. Darmon, René Y. // Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management;Winter97, Vol. 17 Issue 1, p1 

    The typical objective of a sales quota-bonus plan (QBP) is to enhance salespeople's performance by granting them a bonus when they reach a prespecified performance level (a sales quota), set higher than the performance level they would achieve otherwise. Even though QBPs are short-term plans,...

  • Sales Quotas: Critical Interpretations and Implications. Good, David J.; Schwepker Jr., Charles H. // Review of Business;Spring/Summer2001, Vol. 22 Issue 1/2, p32 

    Accomplishing sales objectives is a critical activity of sales organizations. Effected through the assignment of sales quotas, their impact on the firm can be enormous. Yet, despite the key role of sales quotas, very little is known about their use within marketing organizations. To address this...

  • Sales Quotas Are Like an Upset Stomach. Quick, Mike // Sell!ng;Apr99, p7 

    Offers tips on setting sales quotas. Identification of a team; Issue on selling behaviors; Link between the performance standards and the team's sales objectives.

  • Every great salesperson was once a beginner. Gitomer, Jeffrey // Inside Tucson Business;2/2/2009, Vol. 18 Issue 36, p10 

    The article offers tips for new salespeople on how position themselves and attract customers. Beginners must be willing to take risk, trust their instincts and passionate about their products or services. It emphasizes the importance of mental strength, dedication and excellence. The author...

  • In The Sales World It's All About 'Me' Gitomer, Jeffrey // Grand Rapids Business Journal;1/23/2006, Vol. 24 Issue 4, p21 

    The article discusses the fundamental elements of becoming a good salesman. The author mentioned that growing up in a family which stressed that education is one of the requirements for success was a factor. Having an entrepreneurial environment has laid an understanding of the world for the...

  • Every great salesperson was once a beginner. Gitomer, Jeffrey // Enterprise/Salt Lake City;2/2/2009, Vol. 38 Issue 32, p8 

    The author offers insights on becoming a successful salesperson. He elaborates on the idea that every great person was once a beginner. He cites the qualities that beginners should possess in order to succeed, including willingness to take a risk, constant studying and being passionate about...

  • Are your words costing you sales? Schulz, Greta // Buffalo Law Journal;11/8/2012, Vol. 84 Issue 90, p3 

    The author discusses the ITALK accronym for initial situation, thought, attached feelings, lead action, and known result which depict the beliefs of some sales representatives which can affect their sales quotas.


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics