Perceptions of "futile care" among caregivers in intensive care units

Sibbald, Robert; Downar, James; Hawryluck, Laura
November 2007
CMAJ: Canadian Medical Association Journal;11/6/2007, Vol. 177 Issue 10, p1201
Academic Journal
Background: Many caregivers in intensive care units (ICUs) feel that they sometimes provide inappropriate or excessive care, but little is known about their definition of ‘futile care’ or how they attempt to limit its impact. We sought to explore how ICU staff define medically futile care, why they provide it and what strategies might promote a more effective use of ICU resources. Methods: Using semi-structured interviews, we surveyed 14 physician directors, 16 nurse managers and 14 respiratory therapists from 16 ICUs across Ontario. We analyzed the transcripts using a modified grounded-theory approach. Results: From the interviews, we generated a working definition of medically futile care to mean the use of considerable resources without a reasonable hope that the patient would recover to a state of relative independence or be interactive with his or her environment. Respondents felt that futile care was provided because of family demands, a lack of timely or skilled communication, or a lack of consensus among the treating team. Respondents said they were able to resolve cases of futile care most effectively by improving communication and by allowing time for families to accept the reality of the situation. Respondents felt that further efforts to limit futile care should focus on educating the public and health care professionals about the role of the ICU and about alternatives such as palliative care; mandating early and skilled discussion of resuscitation status; establishing guidelines for admission to the ICU; and providing legal and ethical support for physicians who encounter difficulties. There was a broad consistency in responses among all disciplines. Interpretation: ICU physicians, nurses and respiratory therapists have similar and well-formed opinions about how to define and resolve medically futile care and where to focus future efforts to limit the impact of futile care in the ICU.


Related Articles

  • Withdrawal of mechanical ventilation in the home: A case report and review of the literature. Clinch, Alexandra; Le, Brian // Palliative Medicine;Jun2011, Vol. 25 Issue 4, p378 

    Once it has been determined that aggressive medical treatment can no longer meet the goals of care for a ventilated patient, the process of withdrawing mechanical ventilation begins. This is a challenging clinical situation, drawing on the treating physician's skills including clinical decision...

  • Almanya örneÄŸinde saÄŸlık sisteminde palyatif bakım uygulamaları. BAG, Beyhan // Turkish Journal of Oncology / Türk Onkoloji Dergisi;2012, Vol. 27 Issue 3, p142 

    Although the discipline of palliative care is new, it has rapidly gained its place in other areas of medicine. The most important reason for its fast development is that the provision of the necessary care and treatment for incurable patients has acquired increasing importance today. Palliative...

  • Aged care and other workforce reviews step up.  // Nursing Review (1175-2904);Jun2011, Vol. 12 Issue 2, p4 

    The article offers information on aged care and other workforce reviews set up by Health Workforce New Zealand (HWNZ) to come up with a vision for the 2020 workforce. The aged-care review suggests that improved home and community-based preventive and rehabilitation services could reduce the...

  • Long-Term Palliative Care Workers: More Than a Story of Endurance. Webster, Judi; Kristjanson, Linda J. // Journal of Palliative Medicine;Dec2002, Vol. 5 Issue 6, p865 

    This study sought to explore the stories of long-term palliative care workers to generate an understanding of their experiences of working in palliative care for an extended period of time. Six health professionals participated in the study, each of whom were currently working in a palliative...

  • Empowerment interventions, knowledge translation and exchange: perspectives of home care professionals, clients and caregivers. Tribble, Denise St-Cyr; Gallagher, Frances; Bell, Linda; Caron, Chantal; Godbout, Pierre; Leblanc, Jeannette; Morin, Pascale; Xhignesse, Marianne; Voyer, Louis; Couture, Mélanie // BMC Health Services Research;2008, Vol. 8, Special section p1 

    Background: Few studies have examined empowerment interventions as they actually unfold in home care in the context of chronic health problems. This study aims to document the empowerment process as it plays out in interventions with adults receiving home care services. Methods/design: The...

  • Chronic Critical Illness: The Growing Challenge to Health Care. MacIntyre, Neil R. // Respiratory Care;Jun2012, Vol. 57 Issue 6, p1021 

    The chronically critically ill (CCI) comprise a rapidly growing population of patients who have survived acute critical illness, only to be left with ongoing organ dysfunctions requiring high levels of specialized care for months or years. In many ways, CCI is an "iatrogenic" process, reflecting...

  • Withdrawal of ventilatory support outside the intensive care unit: guidance for practice. Laddie, Joanna; Craig, Finella; Brierley, Joe; Kelly, Paula; Bluebond-Langner, Myra // Archives of Disease in Childhood;Sep2014, Vol. 99 Issue 9, p812 

    Objective: To review the work of one tertiary paediatric palliative care service in facilitating planned withdrawal of ventilatory support outside the intensive care setting, with the purpose of developing local guidance for practice. Methods: Retrospective 10-year (2003-2012) case note review...

  • The intubating laryngeal mask: is there a role for paramedics? Menzies, Robert; Manji, Hamid // Emergency Medicine Journal;Mar2007, Vol. 24 Issue 3, p198 

    The article presents a study which compared the ability of British paramedics to intubate a simulated difficult airway using a Mackintosh laryngoscope and an intubating laryngeal mask airway (ILMA). Researchers found that all of the paramedics successfully intubated a simulated difficult airway...

  • An Intervention to Improve Respiratory Therapists' Comfort With End-of-Life Care. Brown-Saltzman, Katherine; Upadhya, Devesh; Larner, Lyle; Wenger, Neil S. // Respiratory Care;Jul2010, Vol. 55 Issue 7, p858 

    BACKGROUND: Respiratory therapists (RTs) are often involved in treating seriously ill and dying patients, but receive little instruction in end-of-life care. Prompted by several difficult cases, we developed an interdisciplinary program to introduce practicing RTs to ethical and end-of-life...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics