Comparison of the Diurnal Precipitation Cycle in Convection-Resolving and Non-Convection-Resolving Mesoscale Models

Clark, Adam J.; Gallus Jr., William A.; Chen, Tsing-Chang
October 2007
Monthly Weather Review;Oct2007, Vol. 135 Issue 10, p3456
Academic Journal
The diurnal cycles of rainfall in 5-km grid-spacing convection-resolving and 22-km grid-spacing non-convection-resolving configurations of the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model are compared to see if significant improvements can be obtained by using fine enough grid spacing to explicitly resolve convection. Diurnally averaged Hovmöller diagrams, spatial correlation coefficients computed in Hovmöller space, equitable threat scores (ETSs), and biases for forecasts conducted from 1 April to 25 July 2005 over a large portion of the central United States are used for the comparisons. A subjective comparison using Hovmöller diagrams of diurnally averaged rainfall show that the diurnal cycle representation in the 5-km configuration is clearly superior to that in the 22-km configuration during forecast hours 24–48. The superiority of the 5-km configuration is validated by much higher spatial correlation coefficients than in the 22-km configuration. During the first 24 forecast hours the 5-km model forecasts appear to be more adversely affected by model “spinup” processes than the 22-km model forecasts, and it is less clear, subjectively, which configuration has the better diurnal cycle representation, although spatial correlation coefficients are slightly higher in the 22-km configuration. ETSs in both configurations have diurnal oscillations with relative maxima occurring in both configurations at forecast hours corresponding to 0000–0300 LST, while biases also have diurnal oscillations with relative maxima (largest errors) in the 22-km (5-km) configuration occurring at forecast hours corresponding to 1200 (1800) LST. At all forecast hours, ETSs from the 22-km configuration are higher than those in the 5-km configuration. This inconsistency with some of the results obtained using the aforementioned spatial correlation coefficients reinforces discussion in past literature that cautions against using “traditional” verification statistics, such as ETS, to compare high- to low-resolution forecasts.


Related Articles

  • Operational Implementation of the Fritsch-Chappell Convective Scheme in the 24-km Canadian Regional Model. Belair, Stephane; Methot, Andre; Mailhot, Jocelyn; Bilodeau, Bernard; Patoine, Alain; Pellerin, Gerard; Cote, Jean // Weather & Forecasting;Jun2000, Vol. 15 Issue 3, p257 

    The objective and subjective evaluations that led to the implementation of the Fritsch and Chappell (FC) convective scheme in the new 24-km Canadian operational regional model are described in this study. Objective precipitation scores computed for a series of 12 benchmark cases equally...

  • Multiple-Radar Data Assimilation and Short-Range Quantitative Precipitation Forecasting of a Squall Line Observed during IHOP_2002. Xiao, Qingnong; Sun, Juanzhen // Monthly Weather Review;Oct2007, Vol. 135 Issue 10, p3381 

    The impact of multiple–Doppler radar data assimilation on quantitative precipitation forecasting (QPF) is examined in this study. The newly developed Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model Advanced Research WRF (ARW) and its three-dimensional variational data assimilation system...

  • A Numerical Sensitivity Study on the Impact of Soil Moisture on Convection-Related Parameters and Convective Precipitation over Complex Terrain. Barthlott, Christian; Kalthoff, Norbert // Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences;Dec2011, Vol. 68 Issue 12, p2971 

    The impact of soil moisture on convection-related parameters and convective precipitation over complex terrain is studied by numerical experiments using the nonhydrostatic Consortium for Small-Scale Modeling (COSMO) model. For 1 day of the Convective and Orographically Induced Precipitation...

  • Mesoscale Model Simulations of Three Heavy Precipitation Events in the Western Mediterranean Region. Romero, Romualdo; Ramis, Clemente; Alonso, Sergio; Doswell III, Charles A.; Stensrud, David J. // Monthly Weather Review;Jul98, Vol. 126 Issue 7, p1859 

    A mesoscale numerical model with parameterized moist convection is applied to three cases involving heavy rainfall in the western Mediterranean region. Forecast precipitation fields, although not perfect when compared to the observations of rainfall, appear to have sufficient information to be...

  • Eta Simulations of Three Extreme Precipitation Events: Sensitivity to Resolution and Convective Parameterization. Gallus Jr., William A. // Weather & Forecasting;Jun99, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p405 

    A versatile workstation version of the NCEP Eta Model is used to simulate three excessive precipitation episodes in the central United States. These events all resulted in damaging flash flooding and include 16-17 June 1996 in the upper Midwest, 17 July 1996 in western Iowa, and 27 May 1997 in...

  • First Northeast Regional Operational Workshop. Auciello, Eugene P. // Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society;Jun2000, Vol. 81 Issue 6, p1327 

    Highlights the topics discussed at the First Northeast Regional Workshop, focusing on hydrometeorology in the northeastern United States, held in Albany, New York from September 21 to 23, 2000. Local and mesoscale modeling; Lake-effect snow; Heavy precipitation forecasting and events; Northeast...

  • Mesoscale modeling of lake effect snow over Lake Erie -- sensitivity to convection, microphysics and the water temperature. Theeuwes, N. E.; Steeneveld, G. J.; Krikken, F.; Holtslag, A. A. M. // Advances in Science & Research;2010, Vol. 4, p15 

    The article offers information on the study which evaluates the capacity of the fifth generation mesoscale model (MM5) and weather research and forecasting (WRF) for lake effect snow (LES) over Lake Erie and Buffalo in New York. It aims to identify the lake's sensitivity to microphysics,...

  • Vertical Variability of Cloud Hydrometeors in the Stratiform Region of Mesoscale Convective Systems and Bow Echoes. McFarquhar, Greg M.; Timlin, Michael S.; Rauber, Robert M.; Jewett, Brian F.; Grim, Joseph A.; Jorgensen, David P. // Monthly Weather Review;Oct2007, Vol. 135 Issue 10, p3405 

    During the Bow Echo and Mesoscale Convective Vortex Experiment, the NOAA P-3 research aircraft executed 17 spiral descents to the rear of convective lines to document the vertical variability of hydrometeors above, within, and below the stratiform melting layer. Ten spirals were behind lines...

  • A Multiple-Vortex Tornado in Southeastern Brazil. de Lima Nascimento, Ernani; Held, Gerhard; Gomes, Ana Maria // Monthly Weather Review;Sep2014, Vol. 142 Issue 9, p3017 

    During the late afternoon hours of 24 May 2005 a severe weather outbreak occurred in the state of São Paulo, southeastern Brazil. Severe thunderstorms were observed ahead of a surface cold front, including a (Southern Hemisphere) cyclonic left-moving supercell that produced a multiple-vortex...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics