Reliability of Histopathologic and Radiologic Grading of Cartilaginous Neoplasms in Long Bones

October 2007
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Oct2007, Vol. 89-A Issue 10, p2113
Academic Journal
Background: Providing the best treatment options and appropriate prognostic information to patients with cartilaginous neoplasms of long bones depends on distinguishing benign from malignant lesions. Correlative interpretation of imaging, histopathology, and clinical information is the current method for making this distinction, yet the reliability of this approach has not been critically evaluated. This study quantifies the interobserver reliability of the determination of grade for cartilaginous neoplasms among a group of experienced musculoskeletal pathologists and radiologists. Methods: Nine recognized musculoskeletal pathologists and eight recognized musculoskeletal radiologists reviewed forty-six consecutive cases of cartilaginous lesions in long bones that underwent open biopsy or intralesional curettage. All diagnosticians had a bulleted history and preoperative conventional radiographs for review. Pathologists reviewed the original hematoxylin and eosin-stained glass slides from each case. Radiologists reviewed any additional imaging that was available, variably including serial radiographs, magnetic resonance imaging, and computed tomography scans. Each diagnostician classified a lesion as benign, low-grade malignant, or high-grade malignant. Kappa coefficients were calculated as a measure of reliability. Results: Kappa coefficients for interrater reliability were 0.443 for the pathologists and 0.345 for the radiologists (p < 0.0001 for both). Kappa coefficients for a subgroup of cases determined to be high risk by subsequent clinical course were poorer at 0.236 and 0.206, respectively (p < 0.0001 for both). Slightly improved agreement among radiologists was noted for the twenty lesions that had magnetic resonance imaging available (Kappa = 0.437, p < 0.0001), but not for the lesions analyzed with serial plain radiographs or computed tomography scans. Conclusions: This study demonstrates low reliability for the grading of cartilaginous lesions in long bones, even among specialized and experienced pathologists and radiologists. This included low reliability both in differentiating benign from malignant lesions and in differentiating high-grade from low-grade malignant lesions, both of which are critical to the safe treatment of these neoplasms. This may explain in part the wide variation in outcomes reported for chondrosarcomas treated in different medical centers. New diagnostic and grading strategies linked to protocol-driven treatments are needed, but they must be measured against the long-term gold standard of patient outcomes.


Related Articles

  • The scourge of "outside" studies. Mirvis, Stuart E. // Applied Radiology;Jun2006, Vol. 35 Issue 6, p6 

    Comments on the difficulties experienced by radiologists when reviewing outside imaging studies. Issues involved in the process; Accuracy of the interpretation of outside imaging studies.

  • Osteochondroma: MR imaging of tumor-related complications. Woertler, K.; Lindner, N.; Gosheger, G.; Brinkschmidt, C.; Heindel, W. // European Radiology;May2000, Vol. 10 Issue 5, p832 

    Osteochondromas can be complicated by mechanical irritation, compression or injury of adjacent structures, fracture, malignant transformation, and postoperative recurrence. Magnetic resonance imaging represents the most valuable imaging modality in symptomatic cases, because it can demonstrate...

  • The role of imaging in the staging and treatment planning of primary malignant bone tumors in children. Teo, Harvey E. L.; Peh, Wilfred C. G. // European Radiology;Mar2004, Vol. 14 Issue 3, p465 

    The accurate staging of primary bone tumors in children is critical for treatment planning. Limb salvage operations can now be performed with excellent outcomes in suitable patients. The purpose of this article is to review the current state of imaging techniques and their roles in enabling...

  • Chest x rays—who should report them acutely? Bain, Gillian; Sawicka, Elizabeth; Tyler, Phillipa // Postgraduate Medical Journal;Jul2009, Vol. 85 Issue 1005, p1 

    The author reflects on the efficacy of chest radiograph (CXR) in radiological examination. The author implies that the tool is only used for acutely ill patients during medical emergencies. The author comments on the complex modalities of the tool, inexperienced junior doctors and limited...

  • A classification of pulmonary nodules by CT scan. Bellomi, M. // Ecancermedicalscience;2012, Vol. 6 Issue 260-270, p1 

    This Image Report aims to briefly describe, giving some imaging examples, the radiological definition of the features of lung nodules as commonly used by radiologists. We hope thus to improve communication and mutual understanding between radiologists and clinicians.

  • An external snapping hip caused by osteochondroma of the proximal femur. Inoue, Sanshiro; Noguchi, Yasuo; Mae, Takao; Rikimaru, Shunichi; Hotokezaka, Syunsuke // Modern Rheumatology (Springer Science & Business Media B.V.);Dec2005, Vol. 15 Issue 6, p432 

    We herein report the findings of a 17-year-old boy who suffered from a right external snapping hip, which was caused by an osteochondroma of the proximal femur. He has been asymptomatic since the excision of the tumor. This case shows a rare etiology in which an external snapping hip occurred...

  • Delayed Diagnosis of a Symptomatic Osteochondroma of the Distal Clavicle. Kontakis, George M.; Karantanas, Apostolos H.; Pasku, Dritan; Alpantaki, Kalliope; Katonis, Pavlos; Hadjipavlou, Alexander G. // Orthopedics;Aug2006, Vol. 29 Issue 8, p734 

    Presents a case study of the delayed diagnosis of a symptomatic osteochondroma of the distal clavicle. Detection of symptomatic osteochondroma during adolescence or childhood; Comments on the substantial growth of an osteochondroma after closure; Symptoms of the disease such as constant...

  • The imaging of cartilaginous bone tumours. I. Benign lesions. Douis, H.; Saifuddin, A. // Skeletal Radiology;Oct2012, Vol. 41 Issue 10, p1195 

    Benign cartilage tumours of bone are the most common benign primary bone tumours and include osteochondroma, (en)chondroma, periosteal chondroma, chondroblastoma and chondromyxoid fibroma. These neoplasms often demonstrate typical imaging features, which in conjunction with lesion location and...

  • Intra-articular osteochondroma of the posterior cavity of the knee. Dienst, Michael; Schneider, Guenther; Pahl, Stefan; Ensslin, Stefan; Kohn, Dieter // Archives of Orthopaedic & Trauma Surgery;Aug2002, Vol. 122 Issue 8, p462 

    A patient with a large intra-articular osteochondroma of the posterior cavity of the knee joint is presented. Preoperative imaging included radiographs and magnetic resonance imaging, which revealed a completely intra-articular, locally expanding, mineralised mass in the intercondylar tunnel and...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics