'The Reality and Myth of New Zealand Egalitarianism: Explaining the Pattern of a Labour Historiography at the Edge Of Empires'

Nolan, Melanie
August 2007
Labour History Review (Maney Publishing);Aug2007, Vol. 72 Issue 2, p113
Academic Journal
The growing alarm in New Zealand over the development of a visible 'underclass' is underpinned by a wider concern in the face of the country's dramatic relative decline in the postwar period. In the generation after 1945, New Zealand was said to have 'full employment', the third highest standard of living in the world and an enviable record in the area of free education to university level. According to a popular self-image, and a central plank of New Zealand national identity, the country was egalitarian and universally prosperous. The development of an underclass, by contrast, seems to indicate that this former British colony at the edge of empires could not protect itself against the tide of international neo-liberalism. However, the view that an underclass has suddenly appeared does not take into account factors which always prevailed against the notion of social equality and inclusiveness — that, for example, most married women were not in education, employment or training in New Zealand in 1950; or that the indigenous New Zealanders, Maori, only began to enter paid employment in a systematic way as they urbanized. This article concentrates upon the shadow which New Zealand's egalitarian reputation casts upon the terrain of labour historiography. A national identity based upon the idea of egalitarianism is now the most difficult issue New Zealand labour historians face.


Related Articles

  • A comparative perspective on the underclass. Heisler, Barbara Schmjiter // Theory & Society;Aug91, Vol. 20 Issue 4, p455 

    The article considers a comparative approach that focuses less on the characteristics of the underclass and more on the processes that create it. Citizenship consists of three elements: civil, political and social citizenship, each of which is closely associated with social and political...

  • Chapter III: Tender Tyranny: The 1839 Custody of Infants Act and Custodial Incarcer-ation in Wuthering Heights and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall.  // Child, the State, & the Victorian Novel;1999, p93 

    Chapter 3 of the book "The Child, the State, and the Victorian Novel" is presented. It explores the need of a barrier against an appetitive underclass which family servants long to destroy the pantry. It cites that repentance may be the last course of degraded feasts in all social classes. It...

  • The underclass. M.M. // Columbia Journalism Review;Jul/Aug87, Vol. 26 Issue 2, p48 

    Focuses on press coverage of the underclass in the United States during the mid-1980s. Increase in references to the underclass in print media from 1979 to 1986; Examples of noteworthy works of journalism on the disenfranchised; Reactions to such reports by black leaders and journalists.

  • CLASS REVIVAL. Theil, Stefan // Newsweek (Atlantic Edition);8/11/2003 (Atlantic Edition), Vol. 142 Issue 6, p27 

    Every few years, a national polling institute asks Germans what they want most from their society. Each time, a majority--or close to it--answers Gleichheit, or equality. Germans' vision of equality--spreading the country's wealth, eliminating capitalist-class barriers, creating a prosperous and...

  • Is There a Hispanic Underclass? Moore, Joan // Social Science Quarterly (University of Texas Press);Jun1989, Vol. 70 Issue 2, p265 

    Does Wilson's analysis of the black underclass apply to Hispanics? A review of the literature suggests that economic restructuring operates similarly in the Rust Belt, but with much more complexity in the Sun Belt, because of specialized subeconomies. At the neighborhood level, there is no new...

  • COMPARING MODELS OF CLASS STRUCTURE. O'Brien, Robert M.; Burris, Val // Social Science Quarterly (University of Texas Press);Sep1983, Vol. 64 Issue 3, p445 

    Recent studies have used the variance explained on relevant dependent variables (R2) to evaluate categorical models of class structure. We show that A2 is not an unambiguous criterion for comparing class models. In the dichotomous case, A2 is biased in favor of class typologies, like the...

  • In Search of an Underclass in Poland. Tarkowska, Elbzbieta // Polish Sociological Review;1999, Issue 125, p3 

    Due to the political restrictions in communist Poland, Polish sociologists have finally acceded to the study of the so-called new poverty of the transition period with rather limited theoretical and methodological resources. Poland is only just beginning to discuss the problems of culture of...

  • From the Culture of Poverty to the Underclass: An Analysis of a Shift in Public Language. Morris, Michael // American Sociologist;Summer89, Vol. 20 Issue 2, p123 

    This paper focuses on the emergence of the "underclass," and the decline of the "culture of poverty," as terminologies used in scholarly and popular analysis of certain low-income groups in American society. It is argued that the theoretical cores of these two concepts are similar but not...

  • American Exceptionalism.  // National Review;5/26/1978, Vol. 30 Issue 21, p637 

    The article reports on the survey regarding American exceptionalism as nuisance of Marxist theory. The survey conducted by the "New York Times" and the CBS News confirmed that American exceptionalism is the bane of Marxist theory. The survey also shows that at least two percent of Americans...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics