Follow-up on Misrepresentation of Research Activity by Orthopaedic Residency Applicants: Has Anything Changed?

Konstantakos, Emmanuel K.; Laughlin, Richard T.; Markert, Ronald J.; Crosby, Lynn A.
September 2007
Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Sep2007, Vol. 89-A Issue 9, p2084
Academic Journal
Background: In our previous study, published in 1999, we showed that 18% of research citations listed as published by orthopaedic residency applicants were misrepresented. Since our last report, we sought to determine whether there had been any change in the behavior of applicants wishing to pursue the field of orthopaedic surgery. Methods: We evaluated the research citations that were identified after a review of the Publications section of the Common Application Form from the Electronic Residency Application Service for all applicants to our orthopaedic residency program for 2005 and 2006. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were established for citations listed on candidate applications. Citations were required to be from journals listed in Ulrich's Periodicals Directory. The PubMed-MEDLINE database engine was used to search for citations. If searching failed to yield the cited publication, a review of the journal of alleged publication was undertaken and an interlibrary search was conducted with the use of several re- search databases. When no match was found, the citation was labeled as misrepresented. Misrepresentation was defined as either (1) nonauthorship of an existing article or (2) claimed authorship of a nonexistent article. Results: One hundred and forty-two (35.9%) of 396 applicants during the 2005 and 2006 application periods listed publications. A total of 304 citations were claimed from these 142 applicants. Listings included articles that were in press or in print (thirty-four citations), articles in journals not found in U/rich's Periodicals Directory (twenty-eight citations), book chapters (twenty-three citations), and articles recorded as having been submitted (eighty-eight citations). These 173 works were excluded from our analysis. One hundred and thirty-one citations were referenced as appearing in journals per our search criteria, and all were verified. Twenty-seven or 20.6% (95% confidence interval, 14.2% to 28.7%) of 131 citations were misrepresented. Conclusions: The prevalence of misrepresented research publications from orthopaedic surgery residency applicants increased modestly to 20.6% compared with that found in our original report (18%). As we recommended in our last report, we strongly urge residency programs to require applicants to submit reprints of their publications with their residency applications. Perhaps standardized guidelines should be developed to help to prevent misrepresentation through the Electronic Residency Application Service.


Related Articles

  • How Should Unmatched Orthopaedic Surgery Applicants Proceed? Amin, Nirav; Jakoi, Andre; Cerynik, Douglas; Kumar, Neil; Johanson, Norman // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Feb2013, Vol. 471 Issue 2, p672 

    Background: Obtaining an orthopaedic surgery residency is competitive. Advisors must understand what factors may help unmatched candidates reapply successfully. Questions/purposes: We determined (1) the attitude of leaders of orthopaedic surgery residency programs toward interviewing unmatched...

  • Assessment of Arthroscopic Training in U.S. Orthopaedic Surgery Residency Programs. Hall, Michael P.; Kaplan, Kevin M.; Gorczynski, Christopher T.; Zuckerman, Joseph D.; Rosen, Jeffrey E. // Bulletin of the NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases;2010, Vol. 68 Issue 1, p5 

    Background: There has been an increasing number of arthroscopic surgeries performed in general orthopaedic surgery practice, as well as a rapid evolution of arthroscopic techniques. The objective of this investigation was to assess the adequacy of arthroscopic training in U.S. orthopaedic...

  • The Residency Review Committee for Orthopaedic Surgery. Luck Jr., James V.; Nestler, Steven P.; Simon, Michael A. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Mar2001, Vol. 83-A Issue 3, p466 

    Discusses the U.S. Residency Review Committee's for establishing the standard for the quality of residency education in orthopedic surgery. Outline of program requirements for residency education; Development of a national surgical-experience database; Evaluation of postgraduate education on...

  • The Canadian Orthopaedic Residency Experience. Baillargeon, David // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;Jun2001, Vol. 83-A Issue 6, p956 

    Focuses on the practice of orthopedic surgery in Canada. Health care system of the country; Admission to an orthopedic residency program; Curriculum of the orthopedic residency programs; Advantages of being an orthopedic surgery resident in Canada; Completion of the residency program; Methods...

  • SHOULD THERE BE A MINIMAL SURGICAL EXPERIENCE FOR A GRADUATING ORTHOPAEDIC SURGERY RESIDENT? Simon, Michael A.; Springfield, Dempsey S.; Nestler, Steven P. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;May2006, Vol. 88-A Issue 5, p1153 

    The article focuses on the debate on whether there should be a minimal surgical experience for a graduating orthopedic surgery resident in the U.S. The orthopedic surgery residency consists of five years of graduate medical education. According to a survey, the recommended minimal range of...

  • Feedback on Practice Management, Mandates, Diversity, and MoM. Calandra, Joseph J.; Mallon, William J.; Cleary, Joel E.; Kalbac, Daniel G.; Tower, Stephen S. // AAOS Now;Sep2013, Vol. 6 Issue 9, p6 

    Several letters to the editor are presented in response to the article published in previous issue of the journal including articles on metal-on-metal (MoM) hip replacement, on teaching residents about practice management and practicing orthopaedic surgery.

  • Sufficient Competence to Enter the Unsupervised Practice of Orthopaedics: What Is It, When Does It Occur, and Do We Know It When We See It? Pellegrini Jr., Vincent D.; Ferguson, Peter C.; Cruess, Richard; Cruess, Sylvia; Briggs, Timothy W. R. // Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, American Volume;9/2/2015, Vol. 97 Issue 17, p1459 

    The goal of residency programs is to provide an educational venue with graduated responsibility and increasing levels of independence as preparation for entering the unsupervised practice of medicine. Surgical programs are required to both cultivate and convey skills pursuant to three...

  • Meadowlands to add surgical residency slots. Caliendo, Melinda // njbiz;2/25/2013, p3 

    The article reports that Meadowlands Hospital Medical Center announced 20 five-year orthopedic surgical residency slots, which will be opened in July 2013.

  • Male Practice: Gender Inequality in Orthopaedic Surgery. Bernstein, Joseph // Clinical Orthopaedics & Related Research;Jun2013, Vol. 471 Issue 6, p1754 

    The article reflects on the gender imbalance in orthopaedic residencies with increasing participation of male physicians in orthopaedic surgery positions. It mentions the reasons why female students do not seek residency positions in orthopaedics. Further are included comments from medical...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics