TITLE

Small Business Administration: Additional Measures Needed to Assess 7(a) Loan Program's Performance: GAO-07-769

AUTHOR(S)

Shear, William B.

PUB. DATE

August 2007

SOURCE

GAO Reports;8/13/2007, p1

SOURCE TYPE

Government Document

DOC. TYPE

Article

ABSTRACT

The Small Business Administration's (SBA) 7(a) program, initially established in 1953, provides loan guarantees to small businesses that cannot obtain credit in the conventional lending market. In fiscal year 2006, the program assisted more than 80,000 businesses with loan guarantees of nearly $14 billion. This report examines (1) the program's purpose, based on its legislative history, and performance measures; (2) evidence of constraints, if any, affecting small businesses' access to credit; (3) the types of small businesses served by 7(a) and conventional loans; and (4) differences in SBA's estimates and reestimates of the program's credit subsidy costs. GAO analyzed agency documents, studies on the small business lending market, and data on the characteristics of small business borrowers and loans. As the 7(a) program's underlying statutes and legislative history suggest, the loan program is intended to help small businesses obtain credit. The program reflects this intent, in part, by guaranteeing a portion of each loan, alleviating some of the lender's risk. However, determining the program's success is difficult, as the performance measures show only outputs--the number of loans provided--and not outcomes, or the fate of the businesses borrowing with the guarantee. The agency is currently undertaking efforts to develop additional, outcome-based performance measures for the 7(a) program, but is not certain when any outcome-based measures may be introduced or what they may capture. Limited evidence from economic studies suggests that some small businesses may face constraints in accessing credit in the conventional lending market, but this evidence--which dates from the early 1970s through the early 1990s--does not account for recent developments that have occurred in the small business lending market. Several studies concluded, for example, that credit rationing--that is, when lenders do not provide loans to all creditworthy borrowers--was more likely to affect small businesses in part because these firms might not have sufficient information for lenders to assess their risk. However, the studies did not address recent significant changes to the small business lending market, such as the use of credit scoring, which may reduce the extent to which credit rationing occurs. GAO found that 7(a) loans went to certain segments of the small business lending market in higher proportions than conventional loans. A higher percentage of 7(a) loans went to minority-owned and start-up businesses compared with conventional loans from 2001 to 2004. More similar percentages of loans with and without SBA guarantees went to small businesses owned by women and those located in economically distressed neighborhoods. The characteristics of 7(a) and market loans differed in several key respects, however. For example, loans guaranteed by the 7(a) program were more likely to be larger and have variable interest rates, longer maturities, and higher...

ACCESSION #

26299579

 

Related Articles

• SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION: Opportunities Exist to Improve Oversight of Women's Business Centers and Coordination among SBA's Business Assistance Programs. Shear, William B. // GAO Reports;11/16/2007, preceding pi 

  The article discusses the study conducted by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), which addresses uncertainties associated with the funding process for Women's Business Centers, Small Business Administration's (SBA) oversight of the program and actions taken to avoid duplication. GAO...

• Observations on Agencies' Data Collection and Eligibility Determination Efforts.  // GAO Reports;8/6/2009, preceding p1 

  The article presents a study conducted by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) regarding the developments of the Small Business Innovation Research Program (SBIR). It cites the achievement of the goals of the program such as improving the role of small businesses in federal research...

• Government-Sponsored Enterprises: A Framework for Strengthening GSE Governance and Oversight: GAO-04-269T. Walker, David M. // GAO Reports;2/10/2004, p1 

  Congress established government sponsored enterprises (GSE)-- such as Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, the FHLBank System, and the Farm Credit System--to facilitate the development of mortgage and agricultural lending in the United States. Although the federal government does not explicitly guarantee...

• Recent Slowdown in Institutionalizing Key Management Controls Needs to Be Addressed. Hite, Randolph C. // GAO Reports;5/18/2009, preceding p1 

  The article focuses on the study by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) regarding the institutionalization of key management controls at the Department of Defense (DoD). The move aims to help DoD in addressing the challenges of its business systems. It also reviewed DoD's latest...

• NNSA Needs More Comprehensive Infrastructure and Workforce Data to Improve Enterprise Decision-making. Aloise, Gene // GAO Reports;2/14/2011, preceding p1 

  The article presents the report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) which examines the extent to which the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) has the data necessary to make informed enterprisewide decisions. The report shows that the agency uses contractors to...

• SMALL BUSINESS INNOVATION RESEARCH: DOD's Program Supports Weapon Systems, but Lacks Comprehensive Data on Technology Transition Outcomes. Sullivan, Michael J. // GAO Reports;12/20/2013, preceding p1 

  The article presents a study that was conducted by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) to examine the Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) programs documentation and data that works under the military departments. It mentions the role of military department in facilitating the...

• Additional Steps Needed to Help Ensure More Timely Disaster Assistance. Shear, William B. // GAO Reports;10/23/2014, preceding p1 

  The article discusses the research study conducted by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) to examine the additional steps needed to help ensuring more timely disaster assistance in the small business administration (SBA). Topics discussed include the administering the disaster loan...

• Leaders either see dreams or create them. Joachim, Ann; Wilcox, Sarah // Marketing News;03/27/2000, Vol. 34 Issue 7, p14 

  The article focuses on the aspects small business leadership. Small business leaders in fast-moving and hard-charging environment can survive by being a strategic opportunist. Some experts believe that opportunists are only tacticians with no particular endgame in mind. Opportunists are not...

• 10 Cost-Saving Business Ideas.  // Power Equipment Trade;Jan/Feb2012, Vol. 61 Issue 1, p14 

  The article discusses how can small business owners, particularly in the U.S., save money, improve profits and enhance efficiency. It cites several cost-saving recommendations, including shifting to a paperless operation, utilizing an A 0% credit card balance transfer, and leasing equipment. The...

Read the Article