Investigation of sources of potential bias in laboratory surveillance for anti-microbial resistance

Laupland, Kevin B.; Ross, Terry; Pitout, Johann D. D.; Church, Deirdre L.; Gregson, Daniel B.
August 2007
Clinical & Investigative Medicine;Aug2007, Vol. 30 Issue 4, pE159
Academic Journal
Purpose: There are a number of biases that may influence the validity of laboratory-based surveillance for antimicrobial resistance. Our objective was to evaluate the potential magnitude of bias in reporting of etiologic agents and their resistance rates associated with inclusion of multiple patient samples and non-random timing and location of sampling. Methods: All urine cultures submitted to a regional laboratory in the Calgary Health Region during 2004 and 2005 were studied. Comparisons were then made using either the overall cohort or different subgroups compared with the "reference" or gold standard population where only the first isolate per patient per year per species was included. Results: Overall 56,897 organisms were cultured at ≤104 cfu/mL from 53,548 samples from 35,890 patients; 39,835 organisms were included in the reference cohort. Escherichia coli was reported in 37,246 (65.5%) of overall cohort and 28,257 (70.9%) of the reference cohort. Therefore, the overall cohort resulted in a relative underestimation of the importance of E. coli as the principal cause of urinary tract infections by 8%. Similarly, reported rates of resistance to antimicrobial agents most notably ciprofloxacin [6,480/ 52,544 (12.3%) vs. 2,647/37,086 (7.1%)], gentamicin [2,991/48,070 (6.2%) vs. 1,567/34,608 (4.5%)], and ceftriaxone [1,737/44,922 (3.9%) vs. 889/32,745 (2.7%)] were higher in the overall than in the reference cohorts. There were large differences in both the distribution of organisms and rates of resistance associated with sampling during different times of the day, week, and year as well as from acute care hospitals and outpatient clinics (P≤0.001). Conclusions: Reports from laboratory-based surveillance studies may be biased depending on the population studied and method of sampling employed. Care must be taken in interpreting results of surveillance studies that do not protect from these major sources of bias.


Related Articles

  • Antimicrobial susceptibility of e. Coli and Klebsiella Pneumoniae strains isolated from urine samples. Zvizdic, Sukrija; Hamzic, Sadeta; Sestic, Sabina; Hedzic, Advija; Ljuca, Senad; Tandir, Salih; Kudumovic, Azra // HealthMed;2011, Vol. 5 Issue 4, p996 

    resistance to imipenem. Isolated strains of K. pneumoniae are resistant to ampicillin in 60.0% of cases, and the results of testing other antibiotics refer to resistance in the range between 40 and 10%. K. pneumoniae is completely susceptible to imipenem. The isolated strains of E. coli in the...

  • Antimicrobial resistance in equine faecal Escherichia coli isolates from North West England. Ahmed, Mohamed O.; Clegg, Peter D.; Williams, Nicola J.; Baptiste, Keith E.; Bennett, Malcolm // Annals of Clinical Microbiology & Antimicrobials;2010, Vol. 9, p12 

    Background: Escherichia coli isolates of equine faecal origin were investigated for antibiotic resistance, resistance genes and their ability to perform horizontal transfer. Methods: In total, 264 faecal samples were collected from 138 horses in hospital and community livery premises in...

  • Antimicrobial Resistance and Association with Class 1 Integrons in Escherichia coil Isolated from Turkey Meat Products. KHAITSA, M. L.; OLOYA, J.; DOETKOTT, D.; KEGODE, R. // Journal of Food Protection;Aug2008, Vol. 71 Issue 8, p1679 

    The objective of this study was to quantify the role of class 1 integrons in antimicrobial resistance in Escherichia coli isolated from turkey meat products purchased from retail outlets in the Midwestern United States. Of 242 E. coli isolates, 41.3% (102 of 242) tested positive for class 1...

  • Antimicrobial Drug Resistance in Escherichia coli Isolated from Commercial Chicken Eggs in Grenada, West Indies. Arathy, D. S.; Vanpee, G.; Belot, G.; Mathew, V.; DeAllie, C.; Sharma, R. // West Indian Medical Journal;Jan2011, Vol. 60 Issue 1, p53 

    Objective: To determine the antimicrobial resistance profile of Escherichia coli (E coli) isolated from the shell membrane and yolk of commercial chicken eggs in Grenada. Methods: A total of 450 eggs were collected from different locations including small (33.3%) and big farms (26.7%), roadside...

  • Canadian integrated program for antimicrobial resistance surveillance: Retail food highlights, 2003-2012. Avery, B. P.; Parmley, E. J.; Reid-Smith, R. J.; Daignault, D.; Finley, R. L.; Irwin, R. J. // Canada Communicable Disease Report;11/7/2014, Vol. 42 Issue S-2, p29 

    Background: The Canadian Integrated Program for Antimicrobial Resistance Surveillance (CIPARS) is a collaborative, integrated program designed to track antimicrobial resistance (AMR) among enteric bacteria isolated from various livestock commodities along the food-producing continuum ("farm to...

  • Antimicrobial Resistance of Escherichia coli 026, 0103, 0111, 0128, and 0145 from Animals and Humans. Shroeder, Carl M.; Jianghong Meng; Shaohua Zhao; DebRoy, Chitrita; Torcolini, Jocelyn; Cuiwei Zhao; McDermott, Patrick F.; Wagner, David D.; Walker, Robert D.; White, David G. // Emerging Infectious Diseases;Dec2002, Vol. 8 Issue 12, p1409 

    Provides information on a study which determined the susceptibilities to antimicrobial agents in clinical medicine and agriculture of Escherichia coli isolates. Antimicrobial susceptibility testing; Detection of virulence genes; Comparison of antimicrobial resistance to isolation source.

  • ANTIMICROBIAL SUSCEPTIBILITY OF Eschericia coli ISOLATED FROM ARIEÅž RIVER (ROMANIA). Florea, Andreea Bodoczi // Analele Universitatii din Oradea, Fascicula Biologie;2011, Vol. 18 Issue 1, p34 

    We studied the prevalence of antimicrobial resistance (AR) and multiple antimicrobial resistances (MAR) among the faecal bacteria found in the Aries river (Romania) affected by strong anthropogenic pressures. Isolation and identification of E. coli were done by using enrichment media, selective...

  • National survey of Escherichia coli causing extraintestinal infections reveals the spread of drug-resistant clonal groups O25b:H4-B2-ST131, O15:H1-D-ST393 and CGA-D-ST69 with high virulence gene content in Spain. Blanco, Jorge; Mora, Azucena; Mamani, Rosalia; López, Cecilia; Blanco, Miguel; Dahbi, Ghizlane; Herrera, Alexandra; Blanco, Jesús E.; Alonso, María Pilar; García-Garrote, Fernando; Chaves, Fernando; Orellana, María Ángeles; Martínez-Martínez, Luis; Calvo, Jorge; Prats, Guillem; Larrosa, María Nieves; González-López, Juan José; López-Cerero, Lorena; Rodríguez-Baño, Jesús; Pascual, Álvaro // Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy (JAC);Sep2011, Vol. 66 Issue 9, p2011 

    Objectives To evaluate the current prevalence of the three clonal groups O25b:H4-B2-ST131, O15:H1-D-ST393 and CGA-D-ST69 (where ST stands for sequence type) among Escherichia coli isolates causing extraintestinal infections in Spain and to characterize their virulence background, 500 consecutive...

  • A proposed model for understanding human-bacterial interactions: Space-time approach on community Escherichia coli occurrence and resistance phenomenon. Kiffer, Carlos R. V.; Monteiro, Antonio M. V.; Camargo, Eduardo C. G.; Pignatari, Antonio C. C. // Advances in Bioscience & Biotechnology;Apr2013, Vol. 4 Issue 4, p505 

    Due to ecological effect, it is expected that population exposures to antimicrobial drugs may lead to microorganisms' modifications, occasionally leading to resistance emergence. The present review was based on previous empirical data and on related literature search for quantitative empirical...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics