Transhiatal versus Transthoracic Esophagectomy: Complication and Survival

Boyle, Michael J.; Franceschi, Dido
December 1999
American Surgeon;Dec1999, Vol. 65 Issue 12, p1137
Academic Journal
The classic approach for esophagectomy is via a combined thoracic and abdominal approach. Concerns persist regarding the adequacy of this approach as a cancer operation. A study was carried out to compare these approaches, with particular reference to complication rates and long-term survival. The charts of all adult patients undergoing esophagectomy for carcinoma at the University of Miami/ Jackson Memorial Hospital between July 1991 and June 1996 were reviewed. Patients who had transabdominal resections alone or colon interpositions were excluded. Of 65 esophageal resections, 38 (58%) were performed transhiatally (THE) and 27 (42%) were performed via the transthoracic (TTE) route. Treatment groups were matched for age and site, stage, and histology of tumor. Similarly, the treatment groups were homogeneous with respect to distribution of neoadjuvant chemotherapy/ radiation. The number of patients experiencing any postoperative complication was similar in both treatment groups, occurring in 22 THE (58%) and 17 TTE (63%) patients (P > 0.05). Anastomotic leak occurred in five THE patients (13%) and one TTE patient (4%) (P > 0.05). The single TTE patient with a leak died within 3 months without leaving the hospital. All five THE patients who developed a leak left the hospital. Although there was a tendency toward a higher percentage of patients in the TTE group to suffer respiratory failure and sepsis and a higher percentage of THE patients to experience anastomotic leak, these did not reach statistical significance. Again, although perioperative mortality tended to be higher in the TTE group, this did not reach statistical significance. Four and 5-year survival rates were similar in both groups. Whereas a 4-year cumulative survival difference of 42% for THE patients and 31% in TTE patients extended at 58 months to 28% and 8%, respectively, these did not reach statistical significance. Similarly, analysis by stage and preoperative treatment type (+/- neoadjuvant c...


Related Articles

  • Double-Stapled Esophagogastric Anastomosis for Resection of Esophagogastric or Cardia Cancer: New Application for an Old Technique. Bisgaard, Thue; Wojdemann, Morten; Larsen, Henrik; Heindorff, Hans; Gustafsen, Jens; Svendsen, Lars Bo // Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques;Aug99, Vol. 9 Issue 4, p335 

    Deals with a study which evaluated surgical efficacy using an esophagogastric double-stapled end-to-end anastomosis for subtotal esophagectomy and cardia resection. Characteristics of patients with esophageal or cardia cancer treated with surgery; Techniques in surgery utilized in the treatment...

  • Extended Transthoracic Resection Compared with Limited Transhiatal Resection for Adenocarcinoma of the Esophagus. Hulscher, Jan B.F.; van Sandick, Johanna W.; de Boer, Angela G.E.M.; Wijnhoven, Bas P.L.; Tijssen, Jan G.P.; Fockens, Paul; Stalmeier, Peep F.M.; ten Kate, Fiebo J.W.; van Dekken, Herman; Obertop, Huug; Tilanus, Hugo W.; van Lanschot, J. Jan B. // New England Journal of Medicine;11/21/2002, Vol. 347 Issue 21, p1662 

    Background: Controversy exists about the best surgical treatment for esophageal carcinoma. Methods: We randomly assigned 220 patients with adenocarcinoma of the mid-to-distal esophagus or adenocarcinoma of the gastric cardia involving the distal esophagus either to transhiatal esophagectomy or...

  • esophagectomy.  // Taber's Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary (2009);2009, Issue 21, p811 

    A definition of the term "esophagectomy," which refers to the surgical removal of all or a portion of the esophagus, is presented.

  • Quality of Life After Esophagectomy for Cancer. Sweed, Margot Roberts; Schiech, Linda; Barsevick, Andrea; Babb, James S.; Goldberg, Melvyn // Oncology Nursing Forum;Aug2002, Vol. 29 Issue 7, p1127 

    Purpose/Objectives: To examine symptoms and quality of life (QOL) of esophagectomy patients after curative surgery. Design: Longitudinal, descriptive pilot study. Setting: Comprehensive cancer center in the northeastern United States. Sample: 23 patients were surveyed: 20 men and 3 women. The...

  • Should Esophagectomy Be Performed in a Low-Volume Center? Padmanabhan, Rajesh S.; Byrnes, Matthew C.; Helmer, Stephen D.; Smith, R. Stephen // American Surgeon;Apr2002, Vol. 68 Issue 4, p348 

    A significant difference has been reported between rates of morbidity and mortality for elective esophagectomy performed at low-volume centers versus high-volume centers. Some authors have suggested that complex surgical procedures such as esophagectomy should be performed only in regional...

  • Efficacy of mediastinal lymphadenectomy in transhiatal esophagectomy with and without diaphragm opening: a cadaveric study. Herbella, F. A. M.; Del Grande, J. C.; Colleoni, R. // Diseases of the Esophagus;Sep2002, Vol. 15 Issue 2, p160 

    SUMMARY. Transhiatal esophagectomy (THE) is believed to induce a lower morbidity and mortality compared with transthoracic esophagectomy, but to be inefficient in performing mediastinal lymphadenectomy. Some surgeons are convinced that lymphadenectomy of the lower mediastinum in THE and...

  • Simultaneous transhiatal esophagectomy and coronary artery bypass grafting without cardiopulmonary bypass. Jones; Melua; Anikin; Campalani; Jones // Diseases of the Esophagus;Dec99, Vol. 12 Issue 4, p312 

    A 69-year-old patient underwent simultaneous transhiatal esophagectomy for carcinoma of the esophagogastric junction and benign spindle cell gastric tumor and coronary artery bypass grafting without cardiopulmonary bypass. A standard technique of transhiatal esophagectomy was used. The long...

  • Original article Comparative anatomical study of the anterior and posterior mediastinum as access routes after esophagectomy. Coral, R.P.; Constant-Neto, M.; Silva, I.S.; Kalil, A.N.; Boose, R.; Beduschi, T.; Gemelle, T.F. // Diseases of the Esophagus;Oct2003, Vol. 16 Issue 3, p236 

    Esophagectomy is the main option for treatment of esophageal cancer. Among the subjects of surgical interest is the use of anterior versus posterior mediastinum to permit reconstruction of the alimentary tract. We performed postmortem measurements in order to analyze the lengths of both routes....

  • Pyloroplasty in gastric replacement of the esophagus after esophagectomy: one-layer or two-layer technique? Lee, Y.-M.; Law, S.; Chu, K.-M.; Wong, J. // Diseases of the Esophagus;Sep2000, Vol. 13 Issue 3, p203 

    Pyloroplasty is our routine drainage procedure performed when the stomach is used as the esophageal substitute after esophageal resection for cancer. The technique of pyloroplasty varies among surgeons and effectiveness has not been studied. Thirty-four patients with a gastric conduit whose...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics