Screening for Mental Illness: The Merger of Eugenics and the Drug Industry

Sharav, Vera Hassner
July 2005
Ethical Human Psychology & Psychiatry;Summer2005, Vol. 7 Issue 2, p111
Academic Journal
The implementation of a recommendation by the President's New Freedom Commission (NFC) to screen the entire United States population--hildren first--for presumed, undetected, mental illness is an ill-conceived policy destined for disastrous consequences. The "pseudoscientific" methods used to screen for mental and behavioral abnormalities are a legacy from the discredited ideology of eugenics. Both eugenics and psychiatry suffer from a common philosophical fallacy that undermines the validity of their theories and prescriptions. Both are wed to a faith-based ideological assumption that mental and behavior manifestations are biologically determined, and are, therefore, ameliorated by biological interventions. NFC promoted the Texas Medication Algorithm Project (TMAP) as a "model" medication treatment plan. The impact of TMAP is evident in the skyrocketing increase in psychotropic drug prescriptions for children and adults, and in the disproportionate expenditure for psychotropic drugs. The New Freedom Commission's screening for mental illness initiative is, therefore, but the first step toward prescribing drugs. The escalating expenditure for psychotropic drugs since TMAP leaves little doubt about who the beneficiaries of TMAP are. Screening for mental illness will increase their use.


Related Articles

  • Bush vows to work with Congress on mental health parity legislation. Parker, Che // AHA News;5/6/2002, Vol. 38 Issue 17, p6 

    Reports on the announcement of U.S. President George W. Bush, in May 2002, that he would pass federal mental health parity legislation to eliminate disparities in the coverage of mental health benefits. Reaction of the American Hospital Association; Obstacles that must be overcome; Discussion...

  • Report: U.S. mental health system in crisis, needs reform.  // Nation's Health;Dec/Jan2003, Vol. 32 Issue 10, p6 

    Focuses on a report from the U.S. New Freedom Commission on Mental Health regarding the mental health system in the U.S. Factors affecting mental health care delivery; Information on ways to achieve recovery from mental illness; Effects of public mental health system failures.

  • Psychiatry: Circa 1919--1969--2019. Rome, Howard P. // Annals of Internal Medicine;Oct69, Vol. 71 Issue 4, p845 

    Focuses on the history of psychiatry in the U.S. Criticisms on U.S. psychiatry; Status of psychiatry before World War II; Revitalization efforts in the field of psychiatry; Overview of the technological progress in psychiatry.

  • Expanding the Role of the School Psychologist in the Delivery of School-Based Mental Health Services. EKLUND, KATIE; VAILLANCOURT, KELLY; PEDLEY, TRISHA // Communique (0164775X);2013, Vol. 41 Issue 5, p1 

    The article discusses the enhancement of school based mental health services by defining the role of the school psychologist. It states that schools provide an ideal and accessible environment for addressing mental health needs of children. Providing professional development opportunities for...

  • RON PAUL VS. THE NEW FREEDOM COMMISSION. Stoil, Michael J. // Behavioral Health Management;Sep/Oct2005, Vol. 25 Issue 5, p8 

    Focuses on the implications of the recommendations from the U.S. New Freedom Commission on Mental Health for mental health screening in the schools for the approval of the Child Medication Safety Act of 2003 sponsored by Representative Ronald Paul. Prohibition of mental health screening program...

  • Evidence-Based Suicide Prevention Screening in Schools. Joe, Sean; Bryant, Heather // Children & Schools;Oct2007, Vol. 29 Issue 4, p219 

    Screening for suicidality, as called for by the President's New Freedom Commission on Mental Health, is a major public health concern. As a place where adolescents spend a considerable amount of their waking hours, school is an important venue for screening adolescents for suicidal behaviors and...

  • Schools' Role in Mental-Health Care Uneven, Experts Say. Samuels, Christina A. // Education Week;5/2/2007, Vol. 26 Issue 35, p14 

    The article reports on the efforts that schools are making to diagnose and treat mental health problems among the student population. Many schools, the article states, do not offer such services leaving many children at risk for depression, suicide, and low school performance. The role of the...

  • President Bush Presides Over a Dying System. J. Stoil, Michael // Behavioral Health Management;Nov/Dec2002, Vol. 22 Issue 6, p8 

    Provides information on the appointment of the New Freedom Commission on Mental Health by U.S. President George W. Bush to study the problems in mental health care. Overview of the interim report issued by the commission; Barriers to health care; Complaints against Medicaid; Ways to overcome...

  • Proclamation 7804--Anniversary of the Americans With Disabilities Act, 2004. Bush, George W. // Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents;8/2/2004, Vol. 40 Issue 31, p1380 

    Presents a proclamation by U.S. President George W. Bush on July 26, 2004, regarding the anniversary of the Americans With Disabilities Act 2004. Benefits of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) for individuals with disabilities; Overview of the New Freedom Initiative; Executive...


Read the Article


Sorry, but this item is not currently available from your library.

Try another library?
Sign out of this library

Other Topics